Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Charity gift over $75: 3 checks for a written statement

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read

A payment over $75 that is partly a gift and partly for goods or services requires a written statement from the organization. A payment with nothing received back is outside that rule, so the first question is what, if anything, the client got in return.

Key takeaways

  • Check whether any part of a payment bought something back, such as a meal or an event seat.
  • For a payment over $75 that mixes a gift with a return, ask the organization for its written statement.
  • Match the statement to the bank record by date, amount, and payee name.
  • Record what the client received and who set its value.
  • Keep a running log of smaller gifts through the year.

A client hands you a folder of charity papers, a bank export with a few lines highlighted, and a question about which of it counts. At intake or during tax season, the real question is rarely whether the client gave to charity. It is whether the paper in hand supports what the client plans to claim. Most of the trouble sits in gifts over $75, where one payment can be part gift and part purchase, and where the record is thinner than anyone expected.

This post walks through three checks to run on a charity gift over $75. Each check gives you questions to ask the client and something specific to check in the file. Partners and operations leads can run them during intake, alongside the Accounting Client Intake Checklist for a Clear Handoff, and the same checks work again when the full year is reconciled before the return is prepared. None of them requires a specialist's background. They require the papers the client holds, the client's answers, and the source publication open next to your screen.

The $75 line comes from the IRS. Publication 526 (2025), Charitable Contributions says that a qualified organization must give you a written statement if you make a payment of more than $75 that is partly a contribution and partly for goods or services. Everything below follows from that sentence: a payment over the line, a payment that mixes a gift with something in return, and a document that should exist because of both.

Check 1: Was part of the payment for something the client received?

Start with the amount and the mix. The publication sets two conditions: a payment of more than $75, and a payment that mixes a contribution with something in return. A gala ticket, a dinner, a raffle ticket, or a membership that comes with event privileges can each carry a gift and a return in the same payment. The client usually thinks of it as one number. "I gave to the school" describes the check, not the transaction underneath it.

Ask three questions for each payment over $75:

  • What did you pay, and on what date?
  • Did you get anything back, even a meal, a bag, or a seat at an event?
  • Whose card or account paid, and whose name is on the paperwork?

The answers tell you which file to pull. If a payment over $75 bought the client a seat at a dinner, part of the payment bought a meal, so the organization should have given a written statement. If the client has only a bank debit or a card slip, you have a gap. A bank record proves that money moved. It does not show what the organization provided in return, so it cannot stand in for the statement.

Check that the statement lines up with the payment. The date should sit near the payment date, the amount should match the bank record, and the organization's name should match the payee on the bank line. Mismatches come up when a spouse paid from a joint account or a parent's card covered a child's event. Write down who paid, because the file should show whose money went where.

A card statement often shows a processor's name or a short merchant code instead of the charity's name, so a line you cannot match at first glance may still belong to the gift. Ask the client what the payment was for and when it was made, then match on the date and the amount. Note the match in the file so the next person does not have to repeat the search.

Before you start a client's batch, sort the client's papers into two piles: those over $75 and the rest. Work the over-$75 pile first, and mark each payment with three answers: is the payment mixed, is a statement on file, and does the statement match the bank record. The sort takes a few minutes and shows you how much of the batch needs follow-up.

When a statement is missing, ask the client to request a copy from the organization and keep the request with its date. A short request is enough. For example: "Please send a written statement for our client's payment of the amount shown on the attached bank record, dated the date shown, and note whether anything was provided in return." If the organization cannot produce one, record that as an open item on the intake sheet. Do not fill the gap with a number typed into the organizer. An open item is easy to revisit before filing; a guessed figure is harder to unwind once the return is done. For a related guide, see Charitable gift acknowledgment: 3 form steps.

Tell the client plainly what the gap means. The statement is the document that shows how the payment splits between a gift and a return, so its absence is the first thing to fix. Say this without alarm. Some gaps close with one phone call to the organization's front desk, and the client does not need to be the one who makes it.

Check 2: Did the client get a benefit back, and was it substantial?

Once you know a payment mixes a gift with something in return, the next question is how much came back. The publication gives that judgment to the charity, not to the client or the preparer. It reads: "The organization determines whether the value of an item or benefit is substantial by using Revenue Procedures 90-12 and 92-49 and the inflation adjustment in Revenue Procedure 2024-40." ( Publication 526)

That sentence has two practical consequences. First, you do not need to rebuild the calculation from scratch. The file needs the organization's determination and the value it assigned to what the client received. In practice, the organization's written reply is the document you file, not your own estimate of what the evening was worth. Second, a benefit the client does not think of as a benefit still belongs in the file.

A charity event is often priced as a single payment, so the client may never have seen a line item for what came with it. Ask whether the price included a meal, a performance, a seat, a parking space, or an item to take home. Ask about auction items won, event tickets, merchandise, and priority access. Ask in plain terms, such as "Did you get anything for that payment?" rather than "Did you receive a qualified benefit?" Plain questions get plain answers, and the answers are what you write down.

If the client says nothing came back, check that claim against the organization's event materials or its written statement. A client's memory of an evening is a useful start, but it is not the document the file needs. Where the materials and the client disagree, note both and ask the organization to confirm.

Publication 526 also carves out a specific case, and it deserves a careful read. It says: "But, item (1) doesn't include rights to purchase tickets for seating at an athletic event in an athletic stadium of a college or university as a result of a contribution to such institution." That sentence works as an exception, so read the paragraph around it before deciding anything. If a client gave to a college and received the right to buy seats at its athletic stadium, pull the full text and check it against the client's facts. Do not rely on a summary of the rule when the client's money depends on it.

When the organization does not state a value for what came with a payment, the file still needs a written answer. Ask the organization to say, in writing, what the client received and whether it assigned a value to it. Record the reply, even if the reply is that no value was assigned. A clear answer makes the file stronger than a guess does, and the next preparer can see that the question was asked.

Close the check with a plain note in the file: what the client received, who valued it, and on what date. If nothing came back, write "no benefit" on the intake sheet. A blank field looks like a question nobody asked. A written "none" shows that someone did.

Illustrative example: a $90 spring dinner

Assume a client pays $90 to a school for a spring dinner. The payment is over $75 and is partly a gift and partly for a meal, so the school should give a written statement. Suppose the statement assigns the meal a value of $25. The file holds the bank record, the statement, and a note of what the client attended. If the same client also won an auction item that night, that goes on its own line with its own description and value, so one benefit does not hide inside another.

Check 3: Does the value and the running total hold up?

The cases below sit side by side in one table. Each row starts with a situation, then what the source says, then what the file should show.

SituationWhat the source says What the file should show
Payment over $75 that is partly a gift and partly for goods or services A qualified organization must give a written statementThe statement, with a date and amount that match the payment
Benefit received with a gift The organization determines whether the value is substantial, using Revenue Procedures 90-12, 92-49, and 2024-40 The organization's determination and the value it gave for what was received
Tickets for seating at a college athletic event in an athletic stadium An exception stated in the publicationThe full paragraph, read against the client's facts
Noncash gift, such as a painting Fair market value at the time of donation is $100,000 in the publication's example, and the deductible contribution is $100,000The value, the date it reflects, and who set it
Smaller gifts made during the yearA practitioner advises tracking smaller donations through the yearOne running log with each gift listed

Publication 526 works an example with a painting. It says: "At the time of the donation, the painting has an FMV of $100,000." It then says: "Your deductible charitable contribution for your noncash contribution is $100,000." In that example the value at donation and the deductible amount are the same. The example takes the number as given. A real file needs the number explained: when it was set, by whom, and on what basis.

The date is the detail to watch. The example measures the painting at the time of the donation. A value from a later resale, a catalog listing, or an insurance schedule may not reflect the value on the donation date. Ask the client which date the number reflects, and write that date next to the value. The same question applies to any item the client gives, not only artwork.

If the item is large or hard to value, the client may need more help than a figure typed on an organizer. Decide that with the client and the return's preparer, and note in the file that the question was raised. The purpose at intake is to make the question visible early enough to answer it.

At intake, list noncash items in their own section of the organizer, separate from cash gifts. Each item gets a description, the date of the gift, the value and the date that value reflects, and who set the value. A separate section makes it easy to see which values need support and which entries are simple cash amounts that should match a bank record.

Smaller gifts are the ones that slip out of a file. A Journal of Accountancy newsletter on how the OBBBA changes charitable deduction strategies for 2025 and 2026 quotes one adviser: "I think this one is really interesting, so I am telling clients to keep track of their smaller donations during the course of the year so they can get credit for this going forward," he said. The same article says: "This change will benefit lower- and middle-income taxpayers the most." The article describes the change in more detail than this post does, so read it in full. For your purposes, the adviser's habit is the useful part: keep a running record of gifts through the year.

Ask the client early in the conversation whether they gave to the same organizations more than once during the year, and whether any of those gifts were small enough to forget. A look at the client's bank records for the year can bring those gifts back to mind. The question is cheap to ask at intake and harder to ask after the return is filed.

A running log can be one sheet with one row for each gift. The table that follows says what each column should hold.

Log columnWhat to enter
Date The date on the bank record, not the date on the letter
OrganizationThe payee name as it appears on the statement
Amount The amount on the bank record
Statement on fileYes, no, or requested, with the date of the request
Benefit received What the client got back, or "none"
Value and dateThe value the organization assigned and the date that value reflects

Update the log at intake, and again before the return is prepared, so the log and the file agree. During tax season, reconcile the log against the bank statements for the full year. For a related guide, see Client bank reconciliation with 4 balance checks. Any gift that appears in the bank record but not in the log is a question to ask the client. Any row without a statement is an open item.

Organize the client folder by the three checks, so anyone who opens it can see the work. Put the over-$75 payments in one section, the statement requests and replies in a second, and the benefit notes and value records in a third. Label each open item with its date and who is following it up. A folder built this way tells the next person what was checked, what was received, and what is still missing.

Run the three checks in the same order on every payment over $75: first the mix, then the benefit, then the value and the running total. Each check uses something the client can produce and something the file can show. When all three are done, the file answers the question you were handed at intake, and the open items are written down where the next person will find them.

Your next step today

Today, pull the client's bank records for the year and list every payment over $75 with its date, amount, and payee. Mark each one as mixed or not mixed, and log any mixed payment without a statement as an open item.

Frequently asked questions

Does every gift over $75 need a written statement?

No, because the rule covers only a payment over $75 that is partly a contribution and partly for goods or services, so a gift with nothing received back falls outside it.

Is a bank record enough?

No, because a bank record shows that money moved but does not show what the organization provided in return, so it cannot replace the written statement.

Who decides whether a benefit is substantial?

The organization does: Publication 526 says it determines whether the value of an item or benefit is substantial, so the file should hold its determination and the value it assigned.

Sources