Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Circular 230 Section 10.29: 2 intake unknowns

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read

Why intake is where conflicts start

Most small firms only look hard at conflicts after something goes wrong. A former client objects to a new engagement, or a partner realizes halfway through a project that the firm already advised the other side. By then the conflict check is history, and it was probably done in a hurry.

The real decision point is intake: the phone call, the email with attached returns, the first meeting where someone asks whether the firm can take the work. That is when a partner or operations lead says yes or no, often while juggling a dozen other tasks.

Intake is also where the firm has the most control. Once an engagement letter is signed and work has begun, the options narrow. Stepping away from a matter, explaining the situation to a client, and managing the fallout all cost more than a few questions at the start. That imbalance is the main argument for spending real time at intake, even when the rule itself is open to interpretation.

The quoted material describes a CPA's practice under Circular 230 as involving advocacy, and Section 10.29 is the part that deals with conflicts of interest. Read it once and you will see that it is short. That brevity is the reason this post exists. A short rule leaves gaps, and the gaps show up when you try to turn it into an intake form, a list of questions for the receptionist, or a sign-off step that staff actually follow.

This post covers two open questions about Section 10.29. The rule is not blank. It states a clear principle, and a careful firm can build a sound process on it. But two things remain uncertain, and each one affects how you should write your procedure. The first is how far the lawyers' conflict rules can be borrowed to fill gaps. The second is that the record of how the enforcing office reads the rule is thin, at least in the source I checked. Both questions push a small firm toward a more careful intake process, not a looser one.

This is written for partners and operations leads at small accounting firms who set conflict procedures at intake. It is a planning guide, not a substitute for advice on your own facts. Have your own counsel review any procedure before you adopt it, especially if your firm represents clients before the IRS.

Unknown one: how far the ABA rules reach

A common shortcut is to borrow from the lawyers. Many firms include a partner who trained as an attorney, or who learned conflict checks at a law firm before moving into accounting. The instinct is understandable. The ABA Model Rules are well developed, they come with commentary, and many of them address conflicts directly. So the reasoning goes that Section 10.29 must mean roughly the same thing, and the lawyers' interpretations can fill in whatever the IRS rule leaves out.

The rule's own text does not support that assumption. A 2011 Tax Adviser article compares IRS rules with AICPA professional standards, and it frames the core problem plainly: "Unstated is the extent to which the interpretations of Section 10.29 will follow the comments on the ABA Model Rules or case law interpreting them." Nobody can say from the text alone how much of the lawyers' commentary will carry over. For an intake procedure, that means the borrowed reasoning is a guess, and a guess is a poor foundation for a control your staff will rely on every day.

The lawyers' rules still matter, though, because they share some ground with Section 10.29. The overlap is spelled out in this line: " even though there is a common value of advocacy between the ABA Model Rules and Section 10.29 and practices regulated thereby, the standards of Section 10.29 must vary from and be more limited than the interpretation of the ABA Model Rule 1.7." Read that closely. The shared value is advocacy. The difference is that the Circular 230 standard is narrower than the lawyers' reading of Rule 1.7.

That difference cuts two ways at intake. A firm that screens to the broader lawyers' standard will probably decline work that the narrower IRS rule would not require it to decline, and it will spend time on checks that do not matter for the engagement in front of it. But the firm cannot assume that every narrowing it hopes for is available. The passage I checked says the IRS standard is narrower; it does not map out where the line falls for a given set of facts. So the safer design is to start from a clear list of questions and let a partner make the judgment, rather than to trim the list to match a reading you have not verified.

One more point affects the intake form itself. Representation is the part of the work the rule is built around: " even though a CPA is required to act with integrity and objectivity, unlike most aspects of a CPA's practice, his or her practice under Circular 230 inherently involves advocacy." Most of what many small firms do, such as bookkeeping, financial statement work, and routine compliance, is not described that way. Representing a client before the IRS is different. If your intake form asks the same questions about every new client, it treats the engagement that carries the most risk the same as the one that carries the least. Ask separately whether the matter involves representation before the IRS, and route those matters to the people in the firm who understand that part of the rule.

Unknown two: the interpretive record is thin

The second unknown is more basic. Even if you accept the first point, you still have to ask how the enforcing office will apply Section 10.29 to your facts. The record on that question is thin: " Unfortunately, the IRS and Treasury have not provided further guidance, and to date there is no case law or administrative law judge decision that could provide guidance as to how OPR will interpret Section 10.29."

Look at the date before you rely on that statement. It describes the record as it stood in 2011, and this post does not confirm whether guidance, decisions, or other materials have appeared since then. Before you finalize a procedure, search for current IRS guidance and for recent OPR and administrative decisions on Section 10.29, and write down what you found and when you looked. Treat the 2011 statement as the place to begin that search, not as a current report.

When you record the search, note the sources you checked, their dates, and any guidance you could not match to a current official page. A record of what you could not find is useful too. It shows the limit of the firm's research and tells the next reviewer where to look first.

What the missing record means for intake is simple to say and harder to do. You cannot look up how the office will read your fact pattern and then decide whether to take the work. You have to build the process on the cautious side of the uncertainty. The stakes of skipping that step are spelled out here: " It should be assumed that ignorance caused by failure to institute such procedures will not excuse a CPA's violation of Section 10.29. " In plain terms, a firm with no written intake procedure should not count on ignorance as a defense. A written procedure is the most direct evidence that the firm looked.

A different kind of conflict comes from the CPA's own position rather than from a competing client. In the passage I checked, where a CPA faces a Section 6694 penalty in the same matter, the representation " would be materially limited by the CPA's personal interest in avoiding a penalty (or action by OPR). " That is a useful prompt for intake. Asking only who the other clients are is not enough. Ask whether the firm itself has a stake in the outcome. Did the firm prepare the return under review? Did the firm give the advice that is being questioned? Did a partner sign something that will be examined? These questions are easy to skip when the intake form lists names and nothing else, and they are the questions most likely to reveal a problem the firm created.

Taken together, the two unknowns point to one conclusion: write more, not less. A procedure that asks about the firm's own work and its own exposure will catch things that a name list never will, and it does so without requiring anyone to settle the open interpretive questions first.

Three intake approaches compared

Most firms land on one of three intake approaches, or some mix of them. The three side by side:

ApproachWhat it checksMain gapBest fit
Name search onlyProspective client against current and former client listsMisses related parties, the firm's own prior work, and personal stake Quick, but too thin to rely on alone
Written intake checklist Names, related parties, prior firm work on the same facts, personal stake, and IRS representationDepends on staff completing it every time and on an owner reading the answers Default for most small firms
Partner memo on each matterEverything on the checklist, plus a written partner analysis before acceptance Costs time on every engagement, including routine workMatters with IRS representation or close overlaps

Each approach has a different strength and a different gap. The right balance depends on how many engagements your firm takes, how often it represents clients before the IRS, and how many people take part in accepting work.

A name search alone is what many firms already have, and it is the approach a reviewer would be most likely to find weakest. It answers one question: does the prospective client's name match a name on a list? It does not ask about related parties, about the firm's own work on the same facts, or about the firm's personal stake. A firm that relies on it has a process that is fast and easy to run, and that is exactly why it tends to miss the harder questions.

The written checklist is the option most small firms should start with. It keeps the speed of a name search but adds the questions that the two unknowns make important: related parties, prior work on the same matter, the firm's personal exposure, and whether the engagement involves IRS representation. Its weak point is execution. A checklist only helps if staff complete it every time and if someone with authority reads the answers. That means naming an owner, naming a backup, and making sure the person who answers the phone knows when to hand a request up.

The partner memo is the strongest option and also the most expensive. A written analysis by a partner before acceptance gives you a record of the reasoning, which matters when the rule is as open as this one. It also costs time on every engagement, including the routine ones. For most small firms, a sensible middle path is to run the checklist on everything and require a partner memo only where the checklist flags a related party, prior firm work on the same facts, a personal stake, or IRS representation. That keeps the cost where the risk is.

Consider a hypothetical. A firm is asked to represent a client in an IRS examination of a return the firm itself prepared last year. A name search finds no conflict, because the client is not on any list. The checklist asks whether the firm prepared the return under review, and the answer is yes. That single answer sends the request to a partner, who writes a memo before the firm accepts. The outcome does not depend on guessing how the lawyers' rules would apply, or on guidance the firm cannot find. It depends on asking the right question at intake.

Writing the procedure down

Once you pick an approach, write it down. A procedure that exists only in the head of a senior partner does not help the staff member who takes the call on a Friday afternoon. The written version should be short enough that people actually read it and specific enough that two people would reach the same answer on the same facts.

A workable written procedure for intake usually includes these elements:

  • An owner. Name the partner who makes the accept-or-decline decision, and name a backup for when that person is out.
  • The questions, in order. Put the questions in the order staff will ask them, and keep the wording the same every time.
  • The firm's own work. Ask whether the firm has already prepared, reviewed, or advised on the facts in question, not only whether it has represented the party.
  • Personal stake. Ask whether anyone at the firm could face a penalty or other action connected to the matter.
  • IRS representation. Ask directly whether the engagement involves representation before the IRS, and route yes answers to the partner who handles that work.
  • Related parties. Capture owners, affiliates, and other people tied to the matter.
  • A record. Keep the date, the answers, the decision, and the approver's name.
  • Re-checks. Run the check again when a new party appears after acceptance.
  • Review. Revisit the procedure on a regular schedule, and whenever you find new guidance or decisions on Section 10.29.

The AICPA-side requirements discussed alongside the rule are " not inconsistent with any provision of Circular 230." That gives a small firm reason to build one intake procedure that covers both sets of expectations, rather than two separate forms that staff have to reconcile on the phone. Check each part of the combined procedure against the sources themselves, not against this summary.

Two things about these elements matter more than their exact wording. First, the record is what shows the firm looked. Second, a procedure that staff can follow under time pressure beats a longer one they skip.

The idea of a written record is not unique to tax practice. Utah's court rules state the principle directly: " A written statement concerning the terms of the engagement reduces the possibility of misunderstanding. " The same logic applies to an intake form. When the answers to the key questions are written down, the firm and the prospective client are far less likely to remember the first conversation differently later.

Write down what staff should do with an unclear answer, too. The safe default is to escalate, not to decide at the front desk. A staff member who hears "my brother-in-law may be the other party" should not settle that question alone. The procedure should say who receives the flag, how quickly it gets reviewed, and that no engagement starts until the flag is cleared. These are operational choices, and they are the part of the process the firm controls completely.

Where this leaves the procedure

The two unknowns do not argue for paralysis. They argue for writing down what the firm does and why, checking the record regularly, and keeping the process strict where the facts are close. A firm that does this will not have every answer, but it will have a defensible record of how it reached each decision. That record is more valuable than a clever reading of a rule whose interpretation is still open in the source I checked.

One practical way to test the procedure is to run it against a few past engagements, including ones where the firm later wished it had asked a different question. Note where the checklist would have sent the request to a partner, and where it would have let the request through. Do this with the people who will use the procedure, not only the partners who wrote it. The gaps you find will usually concern wording, ordering, or who owns the decision. Those are fixable now, without waiting for anyone to settle the interpretive questions.

Before you adopt anything here, do three things. Pull the current text of Section 10.29 and the current guidance on it. Compare your checklist against those sources, and ask your own counsel to review the result for the kinds of clients your firm serves. Then train the staff who take the calls, because the best procedure does nothing if the first person a prospective client reaches does not know it exists.

Sources