Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Pennsylvania disclosure records: keep 6 years

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read

A matter has just closed, the client file is headed for the archive, and someone on the operations team asks the question every disclosure log eventually raises: how long do these records have to stay on file? One rule in this post's sources gives a specific answer. Under Pennsylvania's Rule 1.4, the period is 6 years. This post explains what that number covers, what it leaves open, how the other quoted provisions bear on timing, and how to build a retention schedule that uses the number without stretching it past its source. It is written for operations staff who set those schedules and for the people who review them.

Nothing in this post is legal advice. Where a question turns on your state, your practice area or your firm's own obligations, take it to counsel.

Where the 6-year period comes from

The 6-year figure comes from Pennsylvania's rule on communication, and it applies there only. It is not a general rule for every state, court or business. The duty is set out in one sentence: "A lawyer shall maintain a record of these disclosures for six years after the termination of the representation of a client." Pennsylvania Code, Rule 1.4

A team with a matter in Pennsylvania has a clear starting point. A team with a matter elsewhere does not get one from this post. The sources give no record period for any other state, so work in another state should rest on that state's own text, not on this number.

What the record duty covers

The duty has four parts, and each one needs a named owner on the team.

The first part is who holds the duty. The sentence puts it on "a lawyer." It does not assign the duty to staff, vendors or software, and it does not name clients as the holders of the duty. An operations team may run the filing system, but the quoted text does not say the team carries the duty. Decide how the duty passes down inside the firm and write that decision into the team's procedures.

The second part is where the period starts. The clock runs from the termination of the representation, which the quote names as an event but does not date. The title's plainer phrase, "client work ends," is a stand-in, and the quote does not define the termination date. It does not mean the last invoice, the last call or the day a project was marked closed. Use one agreed termination date for each matter and write it into the file, so the start point is never a guess.

The third part is the length. The quote says six years. It does not say what happens when they run out, and this post does not say the records must be destroyed then. Destruction is a separate decision, and it needs written approval before anyone acts.

The fourth part is which items the duty covers. The quote refers to "these disclosures," a phrase the excerpt does not define. Read the full paragraph that defines the disclosures before assigning records to them. A schedule that attaches the duty to the wrong items leaves a gap, even when every file is carefully kept.

Here is how the parts fit together for one file. Take a client matter governed by Pennsylvania's Rule 1.4, with a termination date that has been confirmed in writing. The duty, as quoted, runs six years from that date. The file should carry the confirmed termination date, the disclosure records and a retention end date computed from it. Because the period runs from termination, an error in the start date moves the end date by the same amount. If the termination date is later corrected, the retention end date changes with it, and the change is noted in the file.

Rules compared at a glance

The table lists the main provisions this post's guidance rests on, the place each one applies, and what the quoted text says; the settlement-offer example and the Minnesota history note are quoted in the text but not tabulated. The rows differ in scope, so compare them before relying on any one of them.

ProvisionWhere it applies What the quoted text says
Rule 1.4, record dutyPennsylvaniaA lawyer shall maintain a record of these disclosures for six years after the termination of the representation of a client.
Rule 1.4, paragraph (10)Pennsylvania A lawyer or firm maintaining professional liability insurance coverage in at least the minimum amounts provided in paragraph (c) is not subject to the disclosure obligations mandated by the rule if such coverage is subject to commercially reasonable deductibles, retention or co-insurance.
Rule 1.10, paragraph (2) PennsylvaniaWritten notice is promptly given to the appropriate client to enable it to ascertain compliance with the provisions of this rule.
Rule 1.10, paragraph (4)North Dakota Written notice is promptly given to all affected clients.

Three of the four rows are Pennsylvania provisions, and only the first gives a record period. The North Dakota row is the only one from another jurisdiction, and it gives a notice requirement, not a record period. That is a fact about the sources chosen for this post, not a statement about the rules elsewhere.

Why written notice timing matters

Pennsylvania's and North Dakota's Rule 1.10 each require written notice to clients, and each asks that it be given promptly. Pennsylvania's version, in paragraph (2) of the general rule, ties the notice to the client's ability "to ascertain compliance with the provisions of this rule." North Dakota's version, in paragraph (4), requires written notice "to all affected clients." The wording differs. Pennsylvania names "the appropriate client," and North Dakota names "all affected clients." Read each rule on its own terms, and do not treat them as interchangeable.

Neither quote says how quickly "promptly" must be. Pennsylvania's Rule 1.4 offers a different example of prompt communication. It describes a lawyer who receives "an offer of settlement in a civil controversy" from opposing counsel, and says that lawyer "must promptly inform the client of its substance," unless the client has already indicated the proposal will be acceptable or unacceptable, or has authorized the lawyer to accept or reject it. That example concerns communication about a settlement offer, not a written notice about conflicts, so keep the two apart.

For operations leads, the practical step is to log the date each written notice goes out, next to the disclosure it relates to. A reviewer can then check the timing from the file itself, without rebuilding it from email.

When the insurance exemption may apply

Pennsylvania's Rule 1.4, in paragraph (10), says that a lawyer or firm with professional liability insurance in at least the minimum amounts provided in paragraph (c) "is not subject to the disclosure obligations mandated by the rule" if the coverage is subject to commercially reasonable deductibles, retention or co-insurance.

Three cautions apply. This post does not reproduce paragraph (c), so it does not say what the minimum amounts are, and a team cannot tell from this post whether a firm's coverage meets them. The exemption speaks to "the disclosure obligations" in general, and the quote does not say whether it reaches the record-keeping sentence quoted earlier. Do not assume it does or does not. And the exemption belongs to Pennsylvania's rule and says nothing about disclosure duties in any other state.

Before relying on the exemption, get the firm's position in writing and keep it with the retention schedule. Anyone reading the schedule later can then see the basis for the decision.

Building a retention schedule

A retention schedule is a written list that says which records are kept, who owns them, what date starts the clock, and when each item is reviewed. The guidance below is general practice for operations leads. Apart from the Pennsylvania period quoted above, it does not state what any rule requires.

For each client matter, the schedule should carry:

  • The client and matter identifier, so the file can be found later.
  • The termination date, as agreed and written into the file.
  • Each disclosure made, with its date, recipient and method.
  • The person who approved each disclosure.
  • The date each written notice was sent, where a notice rule applies.
  • The governing rule for the matter, by state, with the rule cited.
  • The retention end date. For matters governed by Pennsylvania's Rule 1.4, this is 6 years after the termination date.
  • The review date, set early enough before the retention end date to allow time to act.

Keep the schedule in one place the team can search. Limit edit rights to the people it names, and note every change to a retention date, with who made it and why.

Put a hold on any file under dispute, audit or review. A held file is not due for destruction while the hold stands, and the hold is lifted only in writing.

When a retention end date arrives, do not destroy anything on the date alone. Check the hold list, confirm the duty has run, and record the approval and the date of destruction. That last entry answers the question later, if someone asks what happened to a file.

Mixed-state matters

A matter that touches more than one state needs each state's governing rule identified on its own. The Pennsylvania period does not carry over elsewhere. If a matter involves Pennsylvania and another state, the schedule should show which rule governs each part of the work and how those rules fit together. The sources for this post give no retention rule for other states, so those matters have to rest on each state's own text.

Keep a copy of the rule text you relied on

Rule text changes over time, so keep a dated copy of each provision that a retention date relies on. A rule's history can be as telling as its operative sentence. Minnesota's Rule 1.6, on the page linked below, closes with a history note: "(Amended effective January 1, 1990; amended April 14, 1992, effective June 1, 1992; amended effective October 1, 2005; amended effective April 1, 2015.)" Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes That note shows one rule changed several times, so a version in force in one year may not be the version in force later. It is a Minnesota rule, and this post does not use it for anything else.

Pennsylvania's Code page carries notes of its own. One reads: "Immediately preceding text appears at serial pages (316365) to (316367)." That note gives serial page numbers for the earlier text, so a copy taken from the Code can be checked against its earlier source. Another note reads: "The provisions of this Rule 1.4 amended October 22, 2013, effective in 30 days, 43 Pa.B." It shows that an amendment can be adopted on one date and take effect later. The date a provision was amended and the date it took effect may differ, and a retention schedule should say which one it relies on.

Note the date you checked each source and the address you checked it at. If a different version is later read, the file will show which version the team used when it set the dates. That matters most when a retention end date falls years after the work was done, because the people who set it may no longer be on the team. Rule 1.4 contains other paragraphs, including paragraph (c) and paragraph (10), and Rule 1.10 has its own general rule with several parts. A reader who sees one quoted sentence cannot tell what conditions surround it, so the full text belongs in the file beside the schedule.

Store the copies with the matter file, not in someone's inbox or personal folder. Mark any superseded copy so no one sets a date from it by mistake.

Questions to answer before the schedule is final

Five questions decide whether the schedule is ready to go live.

  1. Which state's rules govern each matter, and does any matter fall under Pennsylvania's Rule 1.4?
  2. What is the termination date for each representation, and is it in writing?
  3. Which items are "these disclosures" under the full text of the rule?
  4. Does the paragraph (10) exemption apply to the firm, and does it reach the record-keeping sentence?
  5. What does "promptly" mean for written notices under the Rule 1.10 provisions that apply to each matter?

Checklist

Use this list to check the schedule is complete before it goes live.

  • Settle which state's rules govern each matter.
  • Write each representation's termination date into its file.
  • Establish which items are "these disclosures" under the full text of the rule.
  • Set the retention end date to 6 years after termination for matters under Pennsylvania's Rule 1.4.
  • Record in writing whether the paragraph (10) exemption applies to the firm.
  • Log the date every written notice goes out, since both quoted Rule 1.10 provisions call for prompt written notice.
  • Place holds on any file under dispute, audit or review.
  • Obtain written approval before any record is destroyed.

Limits of this post

This post relies only on the provisions quoted from the official pages it links. It does not cover other states, other paragraphs of any rule, or other kinds of records, and it does not state what any rule says beyond those quotes. Read the full text of each rule before changing a retention period, a notice practice or a destruction process.

Sources