Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Failure to pay penalty: 4 figures to check

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read

The IRS failure to pay penalty has three monthly rates—0.5%, 0.25% and 1%—and a separate cap of 25% of unpaid taxes.

Key takeaways

  • Confirm the unpaid tax and payment dates before checking the penalty.
  • Check filing and approved payment plan records before using the lower rate.
  • Confirm when the client received any notice of intent to levy.
  • Compare the calculated penalty with the cap.

This post covers four figures: three monthly rates and one cap. The figures come from the IRS Failure to Pay Penalty page.

This post covers only the failure to pay penalty. It is meant to help you check the figures on a bill and prepare for the conversation with the client. It is not a full calculation for any one client.

The four figures at a glance

Each figure has its own condition, so the table below pairs each figure with the condition the IRS page gives for it.

FigureCondition on the IRS page
0.5% per month or part of a monthThe tax remains unpaid
0.25% per month or part of a month An individual who filed on time and has an approved payment plan, during that plan
1% per month or part of a month The tax is not paid within 10 days after getting a notice from the IRS with its intent to levy
25% of unpaid taxesThe penalty will not exceed this amount

Keep the table next to the notice when you work through the bill, so each condition gets its own check.

The penalty starts when tax is not paid on time

The failure to pay penalty applies if you don't pay the tax when due. That is the first condition to settle, and the IRS page is the place to confirm the rule itself. For partners and operations leads, the first job is to identify the tax the penalty is attached to: which tax, which period, what due date appears on the notice, and when the payment arrived, if it did.

Ask the client for the notice and the tax year it covers. Write down the due date and every payment date you can find. A payment that arrived after the due date and a balance that was never paid lead to different questions, so keep the two separate in your notes before you move on to the rate. Use the client intake checklist to organize the handoff.

The penalty is also tied to the tax amount. The IRS page says the penalty you must pay is a percentage of the taxes you didn't pay, so the unpaid tax on the bill is the starting point for every figure in the sections that follow. If the unpaid tax on the bill does not match the client's records, settle that first. A wrong starting amount makes every later step wrong too.

The base rate is 0.5% per month or part of a month

The failure to pay penalty is 0.5% of the unpaid taxes for each month or part of a month the tax remains unpaid. The IRS page gives this as the base rate. Two parts of that sentence matter for checking a bill.

First, the rate is applied to the unpaid taxes. Second, the count runs by month or part of a month. A tax that stays unpaid for part of a month is counted the same way as a full month under this rate, so the count does not stop at the last complete month.

Consider how the method works step by step. Take the unpaid tax from the notice, apply 0.5% for each month or part of a month it stayed unpaid, and compare the result with the penalty line on the notice. The rate applies to the unpaid tax, not to the whole balance, and each counted month adds the same percentage again. A longer unpaid period at the same rate increases the penalty only until it reaches 25% of the unpaid tax. If the two figures do not agree, find the input that differs before you say anything to the client.

The rate drops to 0.25% during an approved payment plan

The failure to pay penalty is reduced to 0.25% per month during an approved payment plan, but only if you filed your tax return on time as an individual. The IRS page sets three conditions: the return was filed on time, the filer is an individual, and the plan is approved. All three need to be checked.

Ask whether the return was filed on time. Confirm that the taxpayer is an individual, because the sentence says "as an individual." Do not assume the lower rate applies to a business or partnership client without checking that condition against the page. Then confirm that the plan is approved. The sentence depends on an approved plan, so a plan that has only been requested does not meet the wording. Get the plan paperwork from the client so you can see its status for yourself. For a related review, see the payment plan limits guide.

The lower rate applies during the approved plan, so the months to count at 0.25% are the months the plan covers. The 0.25% figure is half the base rate, so it changes the total only for those months. That comparison shows how the rates differ. It does not mean the client qualifies for the lower rate.

The rate is 1% after a notice of intent to levy

If you don't pay your tax in 10 days after getting a notice from the IRS with its intent to levy, the failure to pay penalty is 1% per month or partial month. The IRS page states this condition in those terms, so the trigger is the notice and the 10 days that follow it. The 10 days run after the client gets that notice, which means the date to pin down is the date the client received it.

Find that date before you apply the rate, and ask the client when the notice was received. If the tax was paid within the 10 days, this condition is not met on the page's wording. If it was not paid within the 10 days, the page gives 1% per month or partial month for that case.

Apply the 1% figure only to the months the page's wording covers, then check the result against the penalty figure on the bill. The 1% figure is a monthly rate, so the count of months still has to be right, and each partial month counts under the page's wording.

The total penalty will not exceed 25% of unpaid taxes

The failure to pay penalty will not exceed 25% of your unpaid taxes. The IRS page gives this as the cap. The monthly rates tell you how the penalty builds over time, and the cap tells you the most it can reach. The cap is measured against unpaid taxes, as the sentence says, so it is a percentage of the tax amount and not a percentage of the balance you happen to be looking at.

Work out 25% of the unpaid tax on the notice and use that figure as the ceiling. Use the cap as a final check. If a penalty line on a bill is larger than 25% of the unpaid tax, the number needs review before you explain it to the client. The cap does not replace the rate conditions above. It is a ceiling you compare against after the rate work is done.

Illustrative example: check the ceiling

For an illustrative unpaid tax amount of $40, multiply $40 by 25% to get a penalty ceiling of $10. Compare that ceiling with the penalty line, rather than with the entire balance. This checks the cap; you still need the dates and rate conditions to check the monthly calculation.

Check the bill step by step

Check the bill by confirming the unpaid tax, the due date, and the payment dates, then working through each rate condition in order. Keep the IRS page beside the notice as you work.

  1. Confirm the unpaid tax amount and the date it was due. IRS page
  2. Confirm every payment date, and note whether any payment came after the due date.
  3. Count the months or partial months the tax remained unpaid, and apply the base rate. IRS page
  4. Check whether the client filed on time as an individual and has an approved payment plan. Mark the months covered by the plan. IRS page
  5. Check whether the client received a notice of intent to levy and whether the tax was still unpaid 10 days after getting it. IRS page
  6. Compare the result with the cap. IRS page

Write the result of each step on the page next to the notice. A step that does not apply should still be recorded with the reason it does not apply, so the file shows that the condition was checked.

When the bill and your math disagree

When the bill and your math disagree, the first step is to find which input differs, not to change the bill from memory. The inputs are the unpaid tax, the months the tax stayed unpaid, the payment dates, the filing date, the plan status, and the notice dates.

Start with two things: which rate the bill used and how many months it counted. Then check the cap. If the difference is in the unpaid tax, go back to the notice and the return, because the penalty is a percentage of the taxes that were not paid. A correct rate applied to the wrong base still gives a wrong penalty.

Keep a short note of every input you changed and why. If you cannot match the bill after checking all the inputs, say so to the client. Do not present a number you cannot trace.

Mistakes to avoid

The main mistake is applying a rate before checking its condition. Applying either the lower or higher rate without checking the condition makes the explanation hard to defend.

A second mistake is using the wrong base. Check which amount the bill used before you check anything else.

A third mistake is counting months loosely. Write down the start and end dates you used for the count, so the client can check them.

A fourth mistake is quoting the 25% cap as if it were the rate. Keep the monthly rates and the cap separate in your explanation.

Explain the penalty to the client in plain terms

Lead with the basic idea: the penalty is a percentage of the taxes the client didn't pay. The IRS page says exactly that, which gives the client a starting point to check against the notice. A client who sees one large number without knowing what it was built from is left guessing, so start with the base and then add the rate.

A short script can keep the explanation in order. Say which rate your bill used, how many months it counted, and what the resulting amount is.

Be clear about which of the four figures applied and why. If a lower or higher figure might apply, say which condition decides it and what you need from the client to check that condition. Do not promise a result before the check is finished. Tell the client what you are checking and when you expect to report back.

Plan the next conversation

Plan the next conversation around the condition the client can still affect. For a client who filed on time as an individual and has an approved payment plan, 0.25% applies only during that plan, so confirm its status. If the client has not yet received a notice of intent to levy, the 1% rate cannot apply on the page's wording until that notice is received and the 10 days have passed.

Set out the next steps in writing. List what you have confirmed, what you still need from the client, and which figures remain open. A short written list gives the client something to act on and gives your team a record of what was checked.

Be careful not to overstate what the page allows. The IRS page sets the rules described here, and the figures can be checked against it at any time. When the client asks where a number came from, point to the page rather than to memory, and check the page again before you rely on it.

Today, put the notice beside the client's payment records and identify the first missing date or document to request.

Related guides: Late filing penalty rates: 4 agency figures on tax due · Apply the 22% flat rate before a client bonus payroll · Client payroll employee file: 4 checks before pay.

Questions to answer before the call

What determines the monthly rate?

Check whether the tax was paid when due, how many months or partial months it stayed unpaid, whether an approved payment plan applies to an individual who filed on time, and whether the client received a notice of intent to levy and then did not pay within 10 days. Check the cap separately.

What if an answer is missing?

Get missing answers from the client before you give a final explanation. Ask each question in that order, and write the answer next to the notice. A partial answer is enough to start the conversation, but it is not enough to close it.

Where can you check the figures?

The IRS page is the source for every figure in this post. Use the links above when you need the exact wording, and treat this post as a guide to checking a bill, not a replacement for the page.

Sources