Before a firm signs off on a Form 1040, someone other than the preparer should check the lines where the return's amounts, credits, withheld tax, and payments are reported. This post covers 6 of those lines: 12, 19, 25d, 26, 28, and 29. Each one is a Form 1040 line that the IRS instructions for Form 8379 name as a reporting place. The line-reporting quotes below come from those IRS instructions, and the two signing quotes come from The Tax Adviser article, which is not an IRS source. Where the post gives general review advice, it is advice about process, not a rule taken from a source.
Key takeaways
- Trace each of the 6 lines to its support and write the source beside the figure in the review file.
- For lines 19, 25d, 26, 28, and 29, check the amount in both places the instructions name.
- Confirm the signature and identity verification before you compare any figure.
- Record every question to the preparer and its answer in writing before sign-off.
- Leave no entry blank: a line still open is recorded as open, not skipped.
Partners and operations leads use the review for different reasons. A partner signing off needs to know that each line was checked against its support. An operations lead keeping the file needs a record that shows the checking was done, what was asked, and what was answered. The steps below are written so that one review produces both.
Read each line section with your own copy of the instructions open beside it, so you can compare the quoted wording with the document in your file. The quotes in this post are short reporting statements. A line section is not a substitute for the full instructions.
Why these 6 lines come from the Form 8379 instructions
The 6 lines in this post are the ones the IRS instructions for Form 8379 name as reporting places. The instructions are titled "Instructions for Form 8379 (11/2024)," so the line numbers here match that revision. If the copy in your review file carries a different revision, compare each line number against it before you rely on this list.
The 6 lines are 12, 19, 25d, 26, 28, and 29. The instructions name line 12 for amounts, lines 19, 28, and 29 for credits, line 25d for withheld tax, and line 26 for payments. They say where specific items are reported. They do not describe how to review the rest of the return, and this post does not claim that they do.
Signing: confirm who signed before checking the numbers
Confirm the signature before you compare any figure, because that check is about the signer, not the numbers. The Tax Adviser's article on tax return signatures reduces the signing question to two parts: "taxpayers and tax professionals need to know only two of the components to understand signing a tax return: Verification of the signer's identity and the creation of the signature." ( The Tax Adviser, "Navigating the tax return signature maze")
For the reviewer, those two parts become two questions. Who is the signer, and does the file show how that identity was verified? Does the signature exist on the version of the return that will be filed? Write both answers in the review file rather than leaving them to memory, so a partner who was not in the room can see what was checked.
The same article says that navigating the various e-signature requirements to successfully e-file a tax return "can seem byzantine, even for tax professionals." If your firm e-files, do not assume the signature step is simple. Ask the preparer to show the signature record before the return leaves the firm, and keep a copy of that record in the file.
Before the signature step, check that the version of the return on screen is the same version the signer will sign. Record the file name or version identifier in the review notes. If the return changes after the signer has reviewed it, the review notes should show which version each step covered.
Set up the review file before you open the return
Set up the review file with one entry for each of the 6 lines before you open the return. That gives every figure a place to be recorded, and it shows at the end which lines were checked and which were left open.
Each entry needs three things: the source you traced the figure to, the amount on the return, and whether the two agreed. Keep the return and its support in the same file so the reviewer is not moving between folders to answer one question. A typed figure can differ from its support by a single digit, so read each figure against the support itself, not against what you remember the support said.
For operations leads, the file is also the record of the conversation with the preparer. Note the date of each question, what was asked, and the answer. If a question is answered by phone, write down what was said and who said it, then ask the preparer to confirm the answer in writing before sign-off.
If the preparer and the reviewer are the same person, the file should say so. The review then does not have a second person looking at the same figures, and the partner signing off should know that when reading the notes. Where two different people do the work, the file should record who did each step, so the record shows the separation.
Comparison of the 6 lines at a glance
The table below lists each of the 6 lines, the item the instructions name for it, and the second place the same quote names, so you can see which entries need a second look.
| Form 1040 line | Item the instructions name | Second place the quote names |
|---|---|---|
| Line 12 | Amounts | None named in the quote |
| Line 19 | Credits | Part I of Schedule 3 (Form 1040) |
| Line 25d | Tax withheld | Schedule 3 (Form 1040), line 11 |
| Line 26 | Payments | Schedule 3 (Form 1040), line 10 |
| Lines 28 and 29 | Credits | Part II of Schedule 3 (Form 1040) |
The table is a checklist. Read each line's section below for the wording of the instruction and the review steps that follow from it.
Line 12: trace each amount to its support
The IRS instructions for Form 8379 say these amounts will be reported on Form 1040 or 1040-SR, line 12. ( IRS instructions for Form 8379) The same line number is named for Form 1040-SR, so a reviewer checking a 1040-SR can use the same reference.
The quote does not say what the amounts are, so the review step for this line is about tracing, not classifying. Find the figure on line 12, find the statement or workpaper that produced it, and confirm that the two agree. Write the source beside the figure in the review file, including the page or schedule it came from, so the next reviewer can find it without asking.
If the figure and its support differ, send the question to the preparer in writing and hold the sign-off until the answer is in the file. Do not change the figure in review on your own. If the preparer confirms a correction, record the correction, the reason for it, and the date it was made.
Ask the preparer where the figure on line 12 came from for this return, and record the answer beside it. The reviewer's job is to confirm that the support matches the figure, so the answer tells the reviewer which document to start from.
Line 19: check the credits in both places
The instructions say these credits are reported on Form 1040 or 1040-SR, line 19, and in Part I of Schedule 3 (Form 1040). ( IRS instructions for Form 8379)
Because the instructions name two places, the reviewer checks the amount on line 19 against the amount in Part I of Schedule 3 and records whether they agree. Work through the credits one at a time. For each credit, find the support the preparer kept, check the amount against that support, and then confirm the same amount appears in both places. Do not check only the total. A total can match while one credit is in the wrong place.
The support for a credit may be a document the firm did not prepare. Note its source in the file, so the reviewer knows where to look if the figure is questioned later.
A credit that appears in one place but not the other is a question for the preparer. The review file should show the question, the answer, and the final entry in each place once the answer is in.
Line 25d: match the withholding to its statements
The IRS instructions for Form 8379 say the tax withheld will be reported on Form 1040 or 1040-SR, line 25d, and Schedule 3 (Form 1040), line 11. ( IRS instructions for Form 8379)
Here the reviewer compares the total on line 25d with the statements of withholding in the file, then compares that same total with the Schedule 3 entry on line 11. Add the withheld amounts from the statements yourself rather than copying the preparer's total, and record both totals in the file.
Check that each statement in the file belongs to the tax year of this return. If a statement is for a different year, set it aside, note that in the file, and do not include it in the total.
If the statement total and line 25d differ, the difference is a question for the preparer, not a figure to adjust in review. Keep the statements with the return so the next reviewer can repeat the comparison without rebuilding it from the preparer's notes.
Line 26: confirm each payment has support
The instructions say these payments will be reported on Form 1040 or 1040-SR, line 26, and Schedule 3 (Form 1040), line 10. ( IRS instructions for Form 8379)
List each payment on its own row in the review file, with its support beside it. Add the list yourself and compare the total with line 26. Then compare the same total with the Schedule 3 entry on line 10. Record the result of each comparison, including the case where both agree, so that a clean result is visible in the file and not just assumed.
When a payment has no support in the file, mark it as open rather than leaving the row blank, so the gap is visible at sign-off. Keeping the support in the file at review time means the next person does not have to search for it.
Lines 28 and 29: review the credits as a pair
The instructions say these credits will be reported on Form 1040 or 1040-SR, lines 28 and 29, and in Part II of Schedule 3 (Form 1040). ( IRS instructions for Form 8379)
Treat lines 28 and 29 as a pair in the review file, with a separate row for each. For each one, note which credit sits on that line, the support for its amount, and its entry in Part II of Schedule 3. The instructions name the same places for both lines, so one checklist can cover both if each line keeps its own record. Keep the two entries apart in the file so a later reviewer can tell which amount belongs to which line. If the return shows an amount on one of these lines with no matching entry in Part II of Schedule 3, record it as an open question for the preparer rather than as a settled item.
Related guides
Questions to put to the preparer
The useful questions for the preparer are the ones that ask where each figure came from and whether the support was kept. Ask for the source of every figure on the six lines, and ask for the support in the same request, so the answer comes back complete.
Ask the preparer to explain any entry that appears in one place on the return but not in the place the instructions name for it. Ask the preparer to say what changed since the last draft, if the return has been revised. Write each question and its answer in the review file, and mark the question closed only when the answer and its support are both in the file.
How to close out the review
Close the review by writing one entry for each of the 6 lines that shows the source you traced the figure to and whether it agreed. A line that agreed with its support, and a line that needed a correction, both get an entry. Each entry should be complete enough that someone reading the file later can see what was checked without asking.
If any line is still open, say so in the file and do not sign off until the question is answered in writing. A file that records an open question is easier for the next person to pick up than a file that looks finished but has no record behind it.
Before the partner signs, the operations lead should check that the file has an entry for each of the 6 lines and that no entry is blank. A partner who signs against an incomplete file is signing against a record that does not show what was checked.
Before sign-off, check the line references against the revision date in your copy of the instructions, as noted at the start. The line numbers in this post come from the 11/2024 revision, and the review file should show which revision was used.
General information, not legal or tax advice.