Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Common representation: 3 checks for 2 joint tax clients

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 10 min read

Common representation is manageable if you run three checks before signing the second engagement: confirm you can give competent and diligent representation to each affected client, obtain written informed consent from all affected clients, and map your privilege and confidentiality plan in advance. The IRS rules and the AICPA standards differ, so you are running two checklists, not one.

  • Check 1: Ask whether you reasonably believe you can give competent and diligent representation to each affected client — if the positions are genuinely mutually exclusive on the central issue, no consent cures it.
  • Check 2: Get written informed consent from every affected client under Section 10.29 — a handshake does not cover it, and one refusal ends the common representation.
  • Check 3: Decide before the first document arrives how you will handle Section 7525 practitioner-client privilege and ET Section 301 confidentiality, including what happens when one client hands you a document the other needs to see.
  • Run the consent conversation before the engagement letter goes out, and give each client their own copy of the disclosure and signature.
  • Walk away if the conflict is not waivable, a client will not consent, or your firm's systems make it likely one client's material reaches the other without authorization.

It is also a source of lost sleep. The IRS rules and the AICPA standards do not match each other, and neither is simple.

What common representation is in a federal tax matter

Common representation is the firm representing two or more clients whose interests are adverse or may become adverse, in the same federal tax matter. Read the full column before you rely on any part of this page.

Check 1: Can you be competent and diligent to both? The column states that a practitioner may keep the engagement only if they reasonably believe they can give competent and diligent representation to each affected client, and only if every affected client signs a written informed consent. Ask that question out loud, in the matter, before you promise anything. Two owners of a company both need you to push hard on the characterization of a payment. One answer helps one and hurts the other. You cannot give your best work to both once the facts turn.

Check 2: Does the consent exist in writing? Under Section 10.29, the waiver has to be in writing, and The Tax Adviser notes the writing also "impress[es] upon the clients the seriousness of the decision and to avoid disputes or ambiguities that could occur later." Two names on a page, dated, describing what you disclosed. A handshake does not cover this.

Check 3: Have you mapped the privilege and confidentiality problem? The Tax Adviser lists three things you weigh: integrity and objectivity; the Sec. 7525 practitioner-client privilege plus ET Section 301 confidentiality; and the advantages and risks of the common representation. ET Section 301 sets the confidentiality floor. Decide, before the first document arrives, how you will handle a document one client hands you that the other needs to see.

Those three checks match the title. Everything below is detail for running them, and what to do when one of them fails.

How the IRS rule and the AICPA rule differ

The two rulebooks are not the same. The Tax Adviser 's title says it: "Conflicts of Interest: IRS Rules Differ from AICPA Professional Standards." The IRS lets you continue with written informed consent if you reasonably believe you can give competent and diligent representation to each affected client. The column explains that 7525 "must be anticipated and provided for with respect to the other client being commonly represented." That sentence has a job: name, in advance, how the privilege will work for each side.

Practical translation for a partner meeting: you are running two checklists, not one. The IRS side cares about informed consent and your own reasonable belief. If you satisfy one and skip the other, you are exposed on the side you skipped.

State law adds a third layer for lawyers. The Texas Center for Legal Ethics describes an arrangement that must conform to Rule 1.05 on confidentiality and Rule 1.06 on conflicts of interest — under Texas's rules. If your firm includes lawyers licensed in a state like these, pull that state's rules and read them next to the federal ones. This post does not carry them for you.

The three considerations line up on the questions you actually have to answer:

QuestionIRS / federal tax practiceCommon-representation considerations
What ends the conflict? Written informed consent from all affected clients, plus your reasonable belief in competent, diligent representation Weigh integrity and objectivity, privilege and confidentiality, and the advantages and risks of the common representation
State law overlay This post reads federal tax practice rules If a lawyer in your firm is licensed where the Texas Center for Legal Ethics describes, that arrangement must conform to Rule 1.05 and Rule 1.06

The written consent is the artifact you will be asked for later.

Start with what you disclosed. Tell each client that you represent the other one, in this matter, on this issue. Tell them what kind of conflict it is. Tell them what could go wrong for each of them. Tell them what could go right. The Tax Adviser's list — integrity and objectivity, privilege and confidentiality, advantages and risks — is a good agenda for the meeting.

Then ask, in the room, whether they understand. You are looking for informed consent in the everyday sense of the phrase before you look for it in the rulebook sense. A client who nods at a two-page document they did not read has not given you much. A client who asks a sharp question about what happens if the two of you end up on opposite sides has.

The Tax Adviser's note on Section 10.29 is worth remembering when someone in the firm says the consent is just paperwork. The writing is there to make the seriousness land, and to keep later disputes and ambiguities from starting. Sign both sides. Date both sides. Keep the disclosure description with the signature.

Two practical points that fall out of this:

  • Run the conversation before the engagement letter goes out. The consent lives alongside the engagement, not after it. If a client will not sign, you know before you have staff hours in the file.
  • Give each client their own copy. Common representation means two relationships. Each client should hold a record of the disclosures and their agreement.

The consent is a moment, not a document. Friendly clients are exactly the ones who later say nobody explained it.

Confidentiality and the Section 7525 problem

ET Section 301 sets the confidentiality requirements on the AICPA side. The Section 7525 position is a separate job, and common representation sits on top of both.

Think about how a joint client matter actually moves. One owner emails you a draft agreement. The other owner calls you with a different recollection of the same meeting. Both emails are in your file. Whether each is privileged depends on the Section 7525 position you arrange in advance for this matter.

The Tax Adviser tells you to anticipate and provide for the Section 7525 position with respect to the other client being commonly represented. Anticipating it means deciding, before the first document arrives, what the sharing rule is. Some firms draw a bright line: information from one client stays with that client unless the client authorizes release. Some use a joint-file model with a log. Either can work. What does not work is discovering your model the day you are asked to forward a draft.

If your matter turns on whether a specific document must be produced to the other client, ask the firm's ethics counsel or your state bar's ethics hotline before you forward anything. The scope of Section 7525 belongs in that same conversation, since the column does not set it out.

The integrity-and-objectivity consideration also does work here. A practitioner weighing the advantages and risks of common representation is asking whether the setup lets them think straight. If the answer depends on your ability to keep a hard fact from one client while advising both, your objectivity is already under load.

When to walk away

Three signals, and each one is a stop, not a pause.

The conflict is not waivable in the way you need. The consent route exists only if your reasonable belief in competent and diligent representation to each affected client is real. If the positions are genuinely mutually exclusive on the central issue, no signature cures it.

A client will not consent. The written informed consent has to come from all affected clients. One refusal ends the common representation, whichever side refused. Handle that refusal as a client service moment: explain what you will and will not do next, and get it in writing.

You cannot run the confidentiality plan. If the firm's systems, staffing, or habits make it likely that one client's material reaches the other without authorization, the setup is not ready. The advantages and risks analysis under The Tax Adviser's list tips negative fast when the risk is operational rather than theoretical.

Walking away is cheaper than a disciplinary inquiry. It is also cheaper than the internal fight that starts when one partner remembers the consent conversation differently from the other.

What operations leads should put in the file

The file is the defense.

  • Disclosure record: what you told each client, when, and in what words.
  • Signed consent: from every affected client, describing the conflict, the risks, the advantages, and the alternatives you explained.
  • Privilege plan: your written position on Sec. 7525 and ET Section 301 as applied to this matter, including how joint documents are handled.
  • Confidentiality setup: who on the team sees what, and how access is restricted between the two client sides.
  • Engagement scope: the matter you are jointly handling, stated narrowly enough that it does not accidentally swallow later disputes.
  • State-law overlay: if any lawyer in the firm is licensed where rules like the Texas Center for Legal Ethics describes under Rule 1.05 and Rule 1.06, or the Pennsylvania Disciplinary Board describes under Rule 1.0(e), note which state rules you checked.

The federal tax rules do not replace a lawyer's state duties. They run alongside.

Worked example

Two owners of a company both need you to push hard on how a payment is characterized. Before you accept: run Check 1 and decide whether you still reasonably believe you can be competent and diligent to each; run Check 2 and hold a consent conversation with each owner, then collect two dated signatures on their own copies; run Check 3 and write down that information from one owner stays with that owner unless released. If either owner declines to sign, the common representation ends before staff hours reach the file.

Frequently asked questions

Do both clients have to sign? Yes. The Tax Adviser describes the route as available when all affected clients waive the conflict by giving their written informed consent. One signature is not a waiver of the other client's side of the matter.

What if the two clients later disagree about what you disclosed? That is the exact scenario Section 10.29's writing requirement is described as protecting against. Your disclosure record and the dated signatures are what you point to as proof.

Does Section 7525 cover everything I tell both clients? Scope questions should go to ethics counsel, since the column's point is that the Section 7525 position must be anticipated and provided for with respect to the other client being commonly represented.

Our matter involves a lawyer in Texas — does this post cover that? No. This post reads federal tax practice rules. Read those before you open the file.

What should the first partner meeting on a joint matter cover? Three things, in this order: whether you can be competent and diligent to each affected client; whether you are ready to collect written informed consent from all of them; and how you will hold Section 7525 and ET Section 301 in the plan. Everything else on this page is detail under those three.

Before you open the file today, draft the consent disclosure for one live matter and put it in front of a partner: what you will disclose, the two signature blocks, and a date line, so the conversation is scheduled rather than improvised.

General information, not legal or tax advice.

Sources