Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Profit motive: 6 client intake evidence checks

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 14 min read

The Journal of Accountancy published an archived item in 2013 titled "Business or hobby? The nine factors," according to Journal of Accountancy.

Verify profit motive using six core activity factors

Consider six items for your client intake checklist: time and effort, profit history, loss causes, asset value, occupation shift, and activity scope. The Journal of Accountancy published an archived article titled "Business or hobby? The nine factors" in 2013, according to Journal of Accountancy. Record the publication year in your client files to contextualize any older guidance you reference.

Time and effort requires documenting the specific hours a client spends on the activity. The Journal of Accountancy notes that the economy plays a big role in how much business J, the hypothetical janitor, can generate and keep, according to Journal of Accountancy. This economic context affects the volume of work available, which in turn influences the time and effort required to maintain the activity.

Profit history involves reviewing past financial performance. The Journal of Accountancy gives a payment example involving an unidentified person: "He is not paid when school is not in session," according to Journal of Accountancy. This seasonal income pattern is a specific indicator of income consistency that you must record in the client’s file.

Loss causes require identifying why losses occurred. The Journal of Accountancy describes J’s janitorial service as entailing cleaning grills, mopping floors, and scrubbing public bathrooms, according to Journal of Accountancy. Understanding the specific nature of the work helps you distinguish between losses caused by market conditions and those caused by a lack of business intent.

Asset value considers the potential for appreciation. The Journal of Accountancy identifies J’s prime contract as being with a fast-food chain, according to Journal of Accountancy. For asset value, consider appreciation in assets such as land used in the activity.

Occupation shift examines changes in the client’s primary employment. The Journal of Accountancy identifies J as managing a janitorial service, according to Journal of Accountancy. If a client shifts their primary occupation to this activity, it supports the profit motive test.

Activity scope defines the breadth of the business operations. The Journal of Accountancy notes that J manages a janitorial service, and his prime contract is with a fast-food chain, according to Journal of Accountancy. The scope of this specific contract and service type defines the boundaries of the activity for your verification purposes.

Review the client’s last three years of financial statements and interview notes to document time and effort spent on the activity.

Key takeaways for how to verify profit motive for client activities

  • Verify if the taxpayer devotes much personal time and effort to the activity, particularly if it lacks substantial personal or recreational aspects, as this may indicate an intention to derive a profit according to Legal Information Institute.
  • Review financial records to identify if the activity is profitable in specific years, such as years 2, 4, and 5, as documented in the case study by The Tax Adviser.
  • Determine if losses stem from things beyond the taxpayer's control, like drought, disease, fire, theft, weather damages, or depressed market conditions, as outlined by the Internal Revenue Service.
  • Note that the term profit encompasses appreciation in the value of assets, such as land, used in the activity, according to Legal Information Institute.
  • Consider if the taxpayer withdrew from another occupation to devote most of their energies to the activity, which may be evidence that the activity is engaged in for profit according to Legal Information Institute.
  • Assess the scope of the activity, such as managing a janitorial service with a prime contract with a fast-food chain, as an example provided by Journal of Accountancy.

A filled reference table for profit motive evidence

The following table pairs the six checklist items with named publishers and quotes illustrating each item. Use this reference during client intake to ensure every factor is grounded in a named source before you allow loss deductions.

FactorPublisherEvidence Quote
Time and effortLegal Information Institute "The fact that the taxpayer devotes much of his personal time and effort to carrying on an activity, particularly if the activity does not have substantial personal or recreational aspects, may indicate an intention to derive a profit." Legal Information Institute
Profit historyThe Tax Adviser "The activity is profitable in years 2, 4, and 5." The Tax Adviser
Loss causesInternal Revenue Service "Are the taxpayer's losses because of things beyond their control, like drought, disease, fire, theft, weather damages or depressed market conditions?" Internal Revenue Service
Asset value Legal Information Institute"The term profit encompasses appreciation in the value of assets, such as land, used in the activity." Legal Information Institute
Occupation shiftLegal Information Institute "A taxpayer's withdrawal from another occupation to devote most of his energies to the activity may also be evidence that the activity is engaged in for profit." Legal Information Institute
Activity scopeJournal of Accountancy "J manages a janitorial service, and his prime contract is with a fast-food chain." Journal of Accountancy

Verify each row against the client’s file before signing off.

Time and effort indicators in client files

Documenting the hours a client spends on an activity is a primary method for verifying profit intent. The Legal Information Institute notes that the fact that the taxpayer devotes much of his personal time and effort to carrying on an activity may indicate an intention to derive a profit according to Legal Information Institute. This indicator carries more weight particularly if the activity does not have substantial personal or recreational aspects according to Legal Information Institute. When reviewing client files, look for records that show consistent engagement rather than sporadic, leisure-driven participation.

To capture this evidence, ask clients to log specific hours dedicated to business operations, maintenance, and administrative tasks. If the activity involves significant personal or recreational elements, the time spent may not strongly support a profit motive according to Legal Information Institute. You should distinguish between time spent on the business and time spent on hobbies within the same activity. For instance, if a client spends weekends on the activity for enjoyment, that time may not count toward the profit motive test in the same way as weekday operational work.

Consider the client’s other employment when assessing time allocation. The Legal Information Institute provides an example where the taxpayer is employed as a skilled machine operator in a nearby factory, for which he is paid approximately $8,500 per year according to Legal Information Institute. In such cases, the available time for the secondary activity is constrained by the primary job. If the client still devotes substantial hours to the activity despite full-time employment elsewhere, this can strengthen the argument for profit intent. However, the mere existence of other employment does not negate the profit motive if the client manages to dedicate significant effort to the activity in question.

When documenting this factor, note the total hours per week or month and the nature of the tasks performed. If the client cannot provide a reasonable estimate of time spent, request a retrospective log covering the last three months. This data helps establish a pattern of regular engagement. Remember that time and effort is one of several factors, and it should be evaluated alongside financial history and other indicators. If the activity lacks substantial personal or recreational aspects, the time spent is more likely to be viewed as business-oriented according to Legal Information Institute.

Financial history and loss context analysis

Review the client’s financial statements to establish a baseline of profitability before evaluating current losses. The Tax Adviser notes that in a specific scenario, the activity is profitable in years 2, 4, and 5, according to The Tax Adviser. Use this pattern to identify intermittent profitability within the client’s history. Document the client’s actual profitable years to assess the activity’s financial history alongside the most recent loss year.

When analyzing losses, determine if they stem from external factors outside the taxpayer’s control. The Internal Revenue Service asks whether the taxpayer's losses are because of things beyond their control, like drought, disease, fire, theft, weather damages or depressed market conditions, according to Internal Revenue Service. If the client’s losses align with these specific external events, record the dates and nature of the events in the intake file. This distinction helps separate operational failure from market or environmental disruption, which is critical for establishing business intent.

Consider how investments interact with occasional profits. The Internal Revenue Service inquires if the taxpayer occasionally has a small profit from the activities that is offset by large investments they have made or suffering large losses, according to Internal Revenue Service. A small profit that is dwarfed by significant capital investment or subsequent large losses is a specific indicator to verify. If the client has made substantial investments in the activity, document the amount and timing of those investments. Assess occasional profits alongside the amounts invested in the activity and the losses incurred.

Long-term loss patterns also require specific documentation. The Legal Information Institute provides an example where a farm has not been profitable for the past 15 years because of rising costs of operating farms in general, and because of the decline in the price of the produce of this farm in particular, according to Legal Information Institute. When a client presents a long history of losses, identify the specific industry-wide cost increases or market price declines that contributed to the result. Do not accept a general statement of "bad luck"; require evidence of the specific economic pressures, such as rising operational costs or declining commodity prices, that drove the losses over that extended period.

Integrate these financial history findings with the other factors to form a complete picture. The presence of profitable years, as noted by The Tax Adviser, combined with losses caused by external factors as defined by the Internal Revenue Service, creates a stronger case for business status. The offset of small profits by large investments, also a question posed by the Internal Revenue Service, adds depth to the financial analysis. Finally, understanding the specific causes of long-term losses, as illustrated by the Legal Information Institute, ensures that the firm’s documentation reflects the actual economic reality of the client’s activity.

Asset appreciation and occupation shifts

When reviewing a client's activity for profit motive, look beyond current-year cash flow. The term profit encompasses appreciation in the value of assets, such as land, used in the activity, according to Legal Information Institute. For assets used in the activity, profit encompasses appreciation in value under 26 CFR § 1.183-2. You should document this appreciation in the client file even if the activity shows a net loss on the income statement for the year.

The taxpayer inherited a farm of 65 acres from his parents when they died 6 years ago, according to Legal Information Institute. This detail illustrates how asset value changes over time can serve as evidence of business intent. If the 65 acres have appreciated in value since the inheritance six years ago, that increase is part of the profit calculation. When you interview the client, ask about the original value of the assets and their current estimated value. Record both figures in your workpapers to support the profit motive claim.

Occupation shifts also provide strong evidence of intent. A taxpayer's withdrawal from another occupation to devote most of his energies to the activity may also be evidence that the activity is engaged in for profit, according to Legal Information Institute. If a client has left a steady job to focus primarily on the activity, that shift supports the argument that the activity is a business. Document the date of withdrawal and the amount of time now devoted to the activity. This evidence complements the time and effort indicators discussed in other sections of this guide.

To apply these factors, review the client's asset records and employment history. Confirm whether any assets used in the activity have appreciated in value. Note if the client has withdrawn from another occupation to focus on the activity. These two factors, combined with the others, help verify that the client is engaged in the activity for profit.

Blank worksheet for documenting client activity

Create a client intake worksheet with Client Evidence and Notes columns and six rows: time and effort, profit history, loss causes, asset value, occupation shift, and activity scope. The Journal of Accountancy illustrates how activity scope and economic context shape a business case, noting that J manages a janitorial service with a prime contract with a fast-food chain according to Journal of Accountancy. The same source describes the business nature, stating J’s janitorial service entails cleaning grills, mopping floors, and scrubbing public bathrooms according to Journal of Accountancy. A separate payment example concerns an unidentified person: "He is not paid when school is not in session," according to Journal of Accountancy. Finally, the source notes the economy plays a big role in how much business J, the hypothetical janitor, can generate and keep according to Journal of Accountancy.

Fill in the Client Evidence column with specific dates, dollar amounts, or documented hours. For the Notes column, record any external factors affecting the activity. Document whether the client’s income fluctuates due to seasonal or external conditions; an example involving an unidentified person states, "He is not paid when school is not in session," according to Journal of Accountancy. Ensure the Activity scope row captures the specific services provided, similar to how J’s janitorial service entails cleaning grills, mopping floors, and scrubbing public bathrooms according to Journal of Accountancy. This documentation supports the firm’s position by linking the client’s specific actions to the broader economic reality. Keep the entries factual and tied to the client’s actual operations. Avoid generalizations that do not appear in the client’s records. The goal is to create a clear paper trail that distinguishes business intent from hobbyist activity. Review the completed worksheet before allowing loss deductions on the return.

FAQ: How to verify profit motive for client activities

Does the IRS consider asset appreciation as profit?

Yes. The Legal Information Institute defines the term profit to encompass appreciation in the value of assets, such as land, used in the activity Legal Information Institute. This definition applies specifically to assets utilized within the activity in question.

Can a taxpayer's withdrawal from another occupation prove profit intent?

The Legal Information Institute notes that a taxpayer's withdrawal from another occupation to devote most of his energies to the activity may also be evidence that the activity is engaged in for profit Legal Information Institute. This shift in professional focus serves as a potential indicator of business intent.

Do losses from events beyond control affect the profit motive test?

These external factors are part of the inquiry into the nature of the losses.

Is a small profit offset by large investments a valid indicator?

The Internal Revenue Service inquires whether the taxpayer occasionally has a small profit from the activities that is offset by large investments they have made or suffering large losses Internal Revenue Service. This specific financial pattern is one of the questions raised during the review.

Does the rule apply to corporations other than S corporations?

No. The Internal Revenue Service states that the hobby loss rules do not apply to corporations other than S corporations Internal Revenue Service. This exclusion limits the scope of the rule to specific entity types.

Sources