Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

3 duties to screen a new hire with a client conflict

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read

Screen the new hire by putting them out of the matter entirely: no work, no file access, no fee tied to it, and the affected client told in writing. The duties run in three moves, starting the moment you learn the tie exists.

  • Surface the conflict as soon as you know it, before any file assignment: name the disqualified person, scope the matter, and ask what confidential information they hold
  • Put the screen up quickly and in writing to both the new hire and the client, describing their prior representation and the screening procedures, and keep it running for the life of the matter
  • Control money and systems so the screen is real: no compensation directly related to the matter, access revoked the same day, and an access report kept on file
  • Build a screen file holding the trigger record, scope note, screen memo, client notice, and access report
  • Set a recurring reminder so the screen does not lapse, and do a final check at close before archiving

Why a conflict conversation belongs in your onboarding

A new hire shows up with client ties you did not know about. Someone from their old firm is now your prospect. Or your new senior worked on files for a company you are about to take on. You have to act before that person touches the work.

Screening is how you handle it. In your own words to the partner, a screen means the disqualified person sits out of the matter. They get no part in the work, no file access, and no fee tied to it. The firm tells the prospective client about the screen in writing. You keep it running for as long as the matter runs.

The duties below come from the rules cited here. Same-day access revocation, the access report, the screen file, and the reminder are firm practice built on those rules. Rules in one state apply in that state. Where a rule sits differently, I say so. Your first job is to check which authority your firm is actually working under, because these duties are not one national standard. Ask your ethics counsel or your state bar if you are not sure.

The shape of the duties:

Duty one is to find the conflict at the moment you learn of it, before onboarding slips into staffing.

Duty two is to put the screen up quickly, in writing, to both the new hire and the client, and to keep it running.

Duty three is to control money and systems, so the screen is real and not just a memo.

Duty one: surface the conflict before you staff the work

The first duty is to surface the conflict as soon as you learn of it, not when the file is assigned.

Pennsylvania Rule 1.0's terminology makes that timing explicit: screening measures must be implemented as soon as practical after a lawyer or law firm knows or reasonably should know that there is a need for screening ( Pennsylvania Rule 1.0). The trigger is knowledge: the firm knows, or reasonably should know, that there is a need for screening. Not a memo, not a review date, not a partner meeting three weeks out.

Practically, this puts three questions on your desk right when you learn the tie exists:

  • Who exactly is disqualified? Name the person, not just the team.
  • What matter does the tie touch? One file, one client family, one deal.
  • What confidential information might they already hold about it?

On the last point, Pennsylvania's terminology defines the purpose of the screen plainly: to assure the affected parties that confidential information known by the personally disqualified lawyer remains protected. That is the bar you are trying to clear. Not "looks clean." The affected party has to walk away believing the information is safe.

North Dakota's version of the prospective-client rule offers an alternative route: imputation can be avoided if the conditions of paragraph (d)(2) are met and notice is promptly given to the prospective client ( North Dakota Rule 1.18). The D.C. Bar states the screen condition the same way: the disqualified lawyer is timely screened from any participation in the matter ( D.C. Bar, Duties to Prospective Client). Timely. That is the word that governs your first week with the hire.

What this looks like at your firm. Your new tax senior mentions she handled files last year for a company you are courting. Do not wait for her start date paperwork to close. Log the tie today. Flag the partner who owns that relationship. Do not assign her to anything in that client family until you have finished duty two.

Ask these questions early, in the offer conversation if you can:

  • Which clients did you serve in the last two years?
  • Which matters are still open anywhere you worked?
  • Are you personally disqualified, or aware of a screen, from any matter?
  • What confidential information do you hold about any of them?

Keep the answers on file. They are the record that you checked.

Duty two: screen fast, in writing, to both sides

The second duty is to run the screen quickly, in writing, to both the new hire and the prospective client, and to keep it running.

Pennsylvania's rule on prospective clients sets out the alternative path: imputation may be avoided if the conditions of paragraph (d)(2) are met and all disqualified lawyers are timely screened and written notice is promptly given to the prospective client ( Pennsylvania Rule 1.18, paragraph 7). The screen and the prompt written notice are the parts this post covers. Check the full conditions of paragraph (d)(2) against the rule text itself.

Timing of that notice has its own line in the rule. Notice, including a description of the screened lawyer's prior representation and of the screening procedures employed, generally should be given as soon as practicable after the need for screening becomes apparent. So the letter carries two things. It says what the person did before. It says what you have done to wall them off.

Your notice to the client, in plain words:

  • The name of the screened person.
  • What they did on the other side, in enough detail that the client can judge it.
  • The screening procedures you have put in place.
  • Who to call at your firm with questions.

Your instruction to the screened person, also in writing:

  • They are out of the matter.
  • They get no file, no calendar entry, no chat thread on it.
  • They do not discuss it with anyone at the firm who is on it.
  • They sign an acknowledgment that they read this.

Now the money question, because partners ask it first. Paragraph (d)(2)(ii) does not prohibit the screened lawyer from receiving a salary or partnership share established by prior independent agreement, but that lawyer may not receive compensation directly related to the matter in which the lawyer is disqualified. Your offer letter, fixed before you knew the tie, is fine. A bonus, a referral credit, or a raise that tracks the screened matter is not. Fix that now, not at review time.

Here is how the two off-ramps compare in the rules cited here:

RouteWho must consent or be toldTiming
Informed consent routeBoth the prospective and affected clients Stated in the rule as a consent requirement; no separate timing is given
Screen routeAll disqualified lawyers screened; written notice to the prospective client Screen timely; notice as soon as practicable after need becomes apparent

Both routes live in Pennsylvania's rule on prospective clients. The consent route requires informed consent of both the prospective and affected clients. The screen route requires the screen and the written notice. Pick one. Do not drift between them while a matter sits open.

Two more things the screen does not do. It does not let the disqualified person dip in for "just a look." And it does not end itself. You keep it running for the life of the matter, with your own calendar reminder to check it.

For the D.C. firm, the screen condition reads the same in substance: the disqualified lawyer is timely screened from any participation in the matter. North Dakota's rule, when you take the notice route, calls the notice prompt. The words differ. The pressure on your calendar does not.

Duty three: control money, systems, and the audit trail

The third duty is to control money and access so the screen is real, and to keep a record that shows it was.

Start with compensation, since that is where a screen quietly fails. Under the Pennsylvania rule, the screened person cannot receive compensation directly related to the matter they are disqualified from. A salary set by a prior independent agreement is allowed. Anything that scales with that matter is not. Your payroll line and your bonus plan have to reflect that boundary the moment the screen goes up.

Then systems. If the person can still open the file from a shared drive, from a chat channel, or from an old project folder, you do not have a screen. Revoke access the same day. Remove them from the client's channel. Close their seat on the document workspace. Ask your IT lead for a report, in writing, showing what they can no longer reach. Keep that report with the screen file.

A screen file, in your own practice, holds five things:

The trigger record. When you learned of the tie, from whom, and what the person did on the other side.

The scope note. Which matter, which client family, and which team members are covered.

The screen memo. Who is disqualified, what they may and may not do, and the date it took effect.

The client notice. The letter you sent, with the description of prior representation and the screening procedures, plus proof you sent it promptly.

The access report. What the person can no longer reach, dated.

Notice that none of these are a one-time event. The screen lives until the matter closes. Put a quarterly reminder on it. At close, you do a final check and then archive the file.

For D.C., the same discipline applies to the participation question: the disqualified lawyer is screened from any participation in the matter. For North Dakota, if you chose the notice route instead, you give the notice promptly and meet the conditions of paragraph (d)(2). Either way, your record shows when you did it.

Where the sources leave a question open, such as how long a screen file must be kept after the matter closes, ask your state bar or your ethics counsel. That answer can differ, and you do not want to guess.

Running this inside your onboarding process

You do not want the conflict check to be a conversation you remember to have. Put it in the onboarding sequence as a gate the hire cannot pass until it is cleared.

A workable order, for your operations lead:

  • Before day one, collect the client and matter list from the hire.
  • Log each tie as soon as it is known, including before day one, and notify the partner who owns that relationship.
  • Before any file assignment, close duty one: disqualified person named, matter scoped, information question answered.
  • Within days, not weeks, close duty two: screen memo to the person, written notice to the client with prior representation and procedures, signed acknowledgment on file.
  • Same week, close the rest of duty three: compensation boundary confirmed with payroll and the access report saved.
  • Set the reminder that keeps the screen alive for the life of the matter.

If you are the partner reading this and the hire starts Monday, you can still run all three duties in the first week. What you cannot do is let the person sit in a live file while you "figure out the details." The clock in these rules runs from when you know.

Also decide, in advance, who at your firm owns the answer. One person should hold the conflict file, send the client notice, and keep the reminder. Split ownership is how a screen lapses.

Common mistakes that break a screen

These are the four that most often undo a careful first week.

Noticing the client late. The rule says notice generally should be given as soon as practicable after the need for screening becomes apparent. A screen with no letter, or a letter sent after the work has started, misses the point.

Telling the client too little. The notice should include a description of the screened lawyer's prior representation and of the screening procedures employed. "We have addressed it" is not that.

Leaving the file open. If the person can still read it, the screen is decorative. Revoke the access and keep the report.

Tying pay to the matter. The screened person cannot receive compensation directly related to the matter. A bonus tied to that matter falls outside the rule's limit on compensation directly related to the matter.

Each of these is fixable the day you catch it. None of them is fixable if you find it at the end of the engagement.

What to tell the partner when you recommend a screen

Partners want three things in the update: what happened, what you did, what it costs.

Say what happened. The new hire has a tie to a current or prospective client, and you learned it at a specific point.

Say what you did. You named the disqualified person, scoped the matter, put the screen up, sent written notice to the prospective client with the prior representation and the screening procedures, and revoked systems access. You recorded a compensation boundary that keeps any fee tied to that matter away from the screened person.

Say what it costs. In time, not just money. The person sits out one matter. Your notice letter goes out promptly. Your systems work lands in the first week. That is the price of keeping confidential information protected in the eyes of the affected parties, which is what Pennsylvania's terminology says the screen is for.

If you are running under a different state's rules, the words and the exact conditions will shift. The shape of your partner update will not.

FAQ

Do I have to screen, or can I ask for consent instead? Both routes appear in Pennsylvania's rule on prospective clients. The screen route requires all disqualified lawyers to be screened and written notice to the prospective client. Which one fits depends on your facts and your governing rules. Ask your ethics counsel before you choose.

What if the hire mentions the tie only after starting? The clock runs from when you know, not from the start date. Pennsylvania's rule points to the moment you know or reasonably should know there is a need for screening. Move that day. Log the trigger, scope the matter, and start the screen notice.

Does the screen let the person keep working on the file if they are careful? No. The condition in the D.C. Bar's statement is that the disqualified lawyer is timely screened from any participation in the matter. Careful is not a category the rule uses. Out means out.

How much detail goes in the client notice? Pennsylvania's rule asks for a description of the screened lawyer's prior representation and of the screening procedures employed. Give enough on both that the client can judge the situation themselves. If you are unsure how much detail your governing rules require, ask your state bar.

Does the screen end when the matter ends? The rules cited here set the start of the screen and the content of the notice. The cited rules do not address record retention, so ask your ethics counsel or your state bar how long to keep the file. Ask your ethics counsel or your state bar for the retention answer in your jurisdiction.

What if the person's prior firm objects? The rules describe written notice to the prospective client, including a description of the screened lawyer's prior representation and the screening procedures. If another party raises an objection, that is a conversation for your ethics counsel. Do not negotiate it yourself through the new hire.

Sources