For a shared client inbox, Microsoft 365 offers two main options: a shared mailbox and a Microsoft 365 group.
Client email has a habit of landing in one person's inbox. A question about a return arrives on a partner's phone, the partner is in meetings for two days, and the team member who could answer never sees the thread. For a small accounting firm, that is an operations problem, and a shared inbox is the usual fix.
Key takeaways
- Count the people who need the inbox; the page says a group suits more users.
- To restrict deletion, look first at a Microsoft 365 group.
- For a larger archive or a litigation hold on a shared mailbox, confirm the license combination the page names.
- Name one person to check the inbox each day before you pick a tool.
In Microsoft 365, a shared inbox can be built in more than one way. This post compares the two options most firms look at first: a shared mailbox and a Microsoft 365 group. We cannot pick the winner for you, because the right answer depends on how many people need access, whether you need to restrict deletion, and which licenses you already pay for. What we can do is set out what Microsoft's documentation says about each option and mark the points that still need checking elsewhere. The main source is the guidance on shared mailboxes, linked wherever we use it.
What a shared mailbox does
A shared mailbox is an address that several people can work from, so client questions go to one place rather than to individual staff. A typical use in a firm is a general address that clients already know, for document requests, payment questions, or appointment changes.
The practical questions are less about the technology than about habits. Who checks the inbox each morning? Who replies, and how does the client know who is handling their matter? Who is allowed to remove a message? Answer those before you choose a tool, because the tool will not answer them for you.
The guidance on shared mailboxes covers the detail, and two points from that page matter for a firm. The first is about size. The page states that "All unlicensed shared mailboxes created before July 2018 have a size of 100 GB." If your firm already has an older shared mailbox of this kind, check its size before you plan around it. Do not assume it applies to a newer one.
The second point concerns licenses, which we cover in a later section. For now, note that the page treats a shared mailbox as a different model from a Microsoft 365 group. That distinction shapes the whole comparison.
What a Microsoft 365 group does
A Microsoft 365 group is the second option. The page describes it in one sentence that is worth reading slowly: "A Microsoft 365 group in Outlook provides shared access to email and a calendar, but it uses a different model than a shared mailbox."
For a firm, the shared calendar can matter as much as the email. If the team coordinates client meetings, filing deadlines, or document signing, a calendar that everyone can see is part of the same problem. Calendar behavior for a shared mailbox needs a direct check before you choose, if the calendar is part of your need.
The page points to further reading for groups: "To learn more about groups, see Learn about Microsoft 365 groups." For setup, it says: "To learn more, see Create a Microsoft 365 group in the admin center." Treat these as the next reading, not as a substitute for the shared mailbox page. Read both before you decide, because the comparison only makes sense once you know what each option does.
The page also gives one plain reason to choose a group, which we return to below: "If you need more users, use a Microsoft 365 group instead."
Compare them side by side
| Point | Shared mailbox | Microsoft 365 group |
|---|---|---|
| Need for more users | The page says to use a group instead | The option the page recommends |
| Restricting deletion | Not the option the page recommends | The option the page recommends for restricting deletion |
| Larger archive mailbox | Needs Exchange Online Plan 2, or Plan 1 with the Exchange Online Archiving add-on | Check Microsoft's group guidance |
| Litigation hold | Needs Exchange Online Plan 2, or Plan 1 with the Exchange Online Archiving add-on | Check Microsoft's group guidance |
| Older unlicensed mailboxes | 100 GB for those created before July 2018 | Check Microsoft's group guidance |
Every cell in the table comes from the Microsoft page. Where a cell says to check Microsoft's group guidance, treat that point as open rather than as a yes or a no.
Read the table as a list of questions to answer, not as a score. A shared mailbox does not win on archive size just because it has a row for it, and a group does not win on deletion just because the page recommends it for that job. The useful question is which of your needs each option handles, and the table shows where the page makes that clear.
Routing client email to the team
Choosing the tool matters less than the route client email takes to reach it. Clients write to whatever address they already have. In many small firms, that is a partner's personal work address, because it appears on the engagement letter or because it was the contact a referral gave them. A shared inbox only works when that habit changes.
Several routes are common. The first is to publish the shared address everywhere the firm already shows a contact: the website, the engagement letter, and invoices. The second is to ask partners to copy or forward client messages to the shared address whenever the team needs to act on them. The third is to agree on how partners reply, so that each reply keeps the thread visible to the team and does not leave the conversation in one person's inbox.
Each route has a cost. Forwarding depends on someone remembering to do it, so a missed forward leaves a client's message in a personal inbox. Publishing the address changes what clients expect, and the team then has to answer within a time the firm can keep. Setting a response time is a decision for the partners, and this post will not set one for your firm.
Write down one rule for what goes to the shared address and who owns it on a given day. A simple rota works well for a small team: one named person checks the inbox at the start of each day, and a second person covers when the first is away. The rota matters more than the tool, because an inbox that nobody owns brings back the original problem. For the intake side of this, see Accounting Client Intake Checklist for a Clear Handoff.
Licenses, archiving and litigation holds
Licensing shapes two features on the page, and both apply to shared mailboxes. The first is archiving. The page says that to increase the size of the archive mailbox, an Exchange Online Plan 2 license or an Exchange Online Plan 1 license with an Exchange Online Archiving add-on license is required ( Microsoft's guidance). The second is litigation hold. To place a shared mailbox on litigation hold, the page says the mailbox must have the same license combination ( Microsoft's guidance).
Both features name the same license combination, so one license check covers both.
Why does this matter to a small firm? A firm may need a longer archive for an inbox that holds years of client correspondence, or it may need to preserve messages when a matter is disputed. Whether and when your firm needs either is a question for your own obligations and your advisors, and this post does not answer it.
The page also points to more guidance: "For more information, see Microsoft 365 licensing guidance for security & compliance." Read it before you commit to a shared mailbox for its archive or hold features. Group licensing is a separate question, so do not carry these rules across in either direction. If you need archiving or a hold on this inbox, get the group answer from Microsoft's group guidance before you choose a group on the strength of this post.
Before you choose a shared mailbox for these features, confirm the license position with whoever manages your Microsoft 365 account. Buying a license to match a feature you have not confirmed is a poor order of work, so confirm first and buy second.
Deletion and team size
Further points on the page bear on control. The first is deletion. The page states: "To restrict deletion, create a Microsoft 365 group instead of a shared mailbox." If your firm wants to limit who can delete messages from the client inbox, the page points you toward a group rather than a shared mailbox. That is the most direct guidance on control, and an instruction rather than a suggestion about style.
Deletion control matters more when the inbox holds records you may need later. What your firm should keep, and for how long, is a question this post will not guess at. Whether your firm has retention obligations for client correspondence is a question for your own advisor. What the page does tell you is which option to look at if you want tighter control over deletion. For how access is set up, see Client data access controls: 4 tools for a firm WISP.
The second point is team size. The more-users rule quoted above applies here. A shared mailbox stops being the right tool at some size, but no exact figure is set out here. A firm with a handful of partners and staff may never reach that point. A firm with a larger team, or with outside people who need access, should check the current guidance before assuming the shared mailbox will serve.
For most firms with many people using one inbox, both points push the same way: the page points toward a group. The licensing section pulls in the other direction, because it describes only shared mailboxes.
Illustrative example for a small firm
Consider a hypothetical firm with a couple of partners, an operations lead, and a few staff. Clients send document requests and payment questions to the partners by email, and the operations lead wants one address for both. The partners want client correspondence kept in an archive, and one partner has raised the possibility of a hold on a disputed matter.
Run the questions from the end of this post. On the second, the partners do not want staff deleting client messages, so restricting deletion matters, and the page points to a group. On the third, the archive and hold needs are real, so the page's licensing rule for shared mailboxes applies. On the fifth, the operations lead wants a shared calendar for client meetings, which the page describes as part of a group.
Where the evidence runs out
Honest comparisons name their gaps, so here are the open points. Group answers on archive size and litigation hold stay open until you check Microsoft's group guidance. How a shared calendar behaves alongside a shared mailbox is also open. No user-count threshold for a shared mailbox is set out here. How long a firm should keep client correspondence is a question for its own advisors, not for a product page.
Those gaps are not reasons to stop. They are reasons to write the questions down before you open the admin center, and to take each one to the right person. The partner decides the response expectations. Whoever runs the Microsoft 365 account confirms the licenses. Your advisor sets the retention position. The Microsoft pages settle the tool questions, but they cannot settle the firm's own rules.
Setting up the address
Whichever option you choose, the setup starts in the Microsoft 365 admin center. For a shared mailbox, the page includes a naming step: "Then in the Microsoft 365 admin center, rename the shared mailbox to what you want it to be." Pick a name for the function rather than for a person, such as a general address for document requests, so the address still makes sense when staff change. That is a judgment call and not a rule from the page, but it keeps the address stable when your team changes.
For a group, follow the page's pointer to its group setup steps when you reach the build step. Use the current instructions on Microsoft's pages rather than a screenshot from a colleague's earlier setup, because screens and menus change over time.
Beyond the admin steps, most of the work is about people. Before you go live, consider the following:
- Write down who is on the inbox and who replies to each type of client message.
- Decide how a partner's direct client emails will reach the shared address, so that nothing stays in a personal inbox.
- Send a short note to current clients with the new address, and update the contact details on engagement letters and invoices to match.
- Test with internal messages first, and check that a reply sent to a client reads correctly from the team's side.
- Set a review date a few weeks after launch to see whether the arrangement is holding up.
The test period is where most of the real problems show up. A message that was forwarded late, or a reply that went out from the wrong person, is easier to fix early than months later.
How to decide for your firm
Work through these questions for your firm, using only the points the Microsoft pages make:
- How many people need the inbox? If the answer is more people than a shared mailbox suits, the page points to a group.
- Do you need to restrict who can delete messages? If yes, the page points to a group.
- Do you need a larger archive or a litigation hold on this inbox? If yes, the page ties both to Exchange Online Plan 2, or Plan 1 with the Exchange Online Archiving add-on, for shared mailboxes. Confirm your licenses, and get the group answer from Microsoft's group guidance.
- Do you already have an older, unlicensed shared mailbox? If yes, check its size against the 100 GB figure for mailboxes created before July 2018.
- Does the team need a shared calendar alongside the email? If yes, the page describes a group as providing shared access to both, and you should confirm the shared mailbox answer separately.
If your answers to the first two questions point to a group, and you do not need archiving or a hold, the page's pointers lead toward a group. If you need archiving or a hold, the answer depends on your licenses and on what Microsoft's group guidance says for your case, and you should not settle it from this post alone.
Your next step today: write down each answer on paper before you touch the admin center. Confirm the licenses with whoever manages your account, and set up a test address first. Once the inbox works for the team and the first few client messages move through it cleanly, tell clients about the new address. A shared inbox is only useful when the team reads it, so the choice of tool should follow the rota, not the other way around.
Frequently asked questions
Is a shared mailbox the same as a Microsoft 365 group?
No. The Microsoft page treats a group as a different model from a shared mailbox.
Which option lets you restrict deletion?
A Microsoft 365 group, which the page recommends for that purpose.