Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

3 state tax questions to ask at client intake

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 15 min read

A first call moves quickly. The client explains the problem, you start asking about returns and deadlines, and the state questions get pushed to the end or dropped. A year later, someone finds an exclusion nobody claimed, a letter from an unclaimed property office, or a sales tax file missing a form the business needed.

This post covers three questions worth asking at intake for clients in New York, Texas, and California. Each question points to a specific rule, and each rule has an official page behind it. The questions won't replace a full review. They are meant to surface the state issues that are easy to miss on a first call, so you know which ones need a follow-up, a document request, or a referral.

Chief takeaways

  • Ask the three questions on every intake, not just on files that look risky
  • Record the answers in the client's own words, including who shares any inheritance
  • Open the linked page for each yes answer before you advise anyone
  • Sort each file into three piles: clear no, needs documents, changes the work

Use these questions as a checklist, not a script. Ask them in plain words, write down the answers, and move on. Where a rule is mentioned, check the linked page for its current version before you advise a client. Official guidance can change, and the figures below are the ones the pages gave when we checked them.

Question 1: Is the client receiving pension or retirement income, including inherited accounts?

Ask New York clients: "Do you receive pension, annuity, or retirement account payments? Did any of them come to you through an inheritance?"

Rule pointValue from the page
Maximum exclusion, all sources combinedMay not exceed $20,000
Example IRA value at inheritance$100,000
Example pension value at inheritance$400,000
John's annual distribution from own pension$15,000
John's maximum allowed exclusion $20,000
SourceInformation for retired persons

The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance publishes guidance for retired persons that covers a pension and annuity income exclusion. The first thing to know is the ceiling. In the page's words, "The maximum exclusion allowable, from the total of all sources that qualify for the exclusion, may not exceed $20,000." ( Information for retired persons)

The phrase "from the total of all sources" matters. The cap applies to the combined total from every qualifying source. It is not a separate cap for each pension, annuity, or account. A client with more than one qualifying source can't read the rule as allowing $20,000 from each one. On the first call, write down every source the client mentions, then check each one against the page.

Inheritance adds a second layer. The page works through an example in which values are set at the time of inheritance: "At the time of inheritance, the value of the IRA and the pension is $100,000 and $400,000 respectively." ( Information for retired persons) The example is useful for intake because it shows the facts that matter: what was inherited, what it was worth when it passed, and who received it.

Shared inheritances need extra care. The page says, "Regardless of the amount of the distribution each beneficiary takes each year, if any, the beneficiaries must allocate the maximum exclusion in the same ratio as the total original inheritance is shared so that the total exclusion of all beneficiaries does not exceed $20,000." ( Information for retired persons) In plain terms, when several people inherit one account, the exclusion is not multiplied by the number of beneficiaries. The beneficiaries split the allowance in the same proportion they split the inheritance, and the combined exclusion stays at or under $20,000. This matters for a family with two or three heirs, because each heir may assume they get a full allowance of their own. Confirm the split with the client before anyone files. Our related post on the NY inherited pension exclusion: 5 allocation steps walks through that split.

The page also covers a client who receives his own pension. Example 3 describes "John, age 60," who "receives an annual pension distribution of $15,000 from his own pension." The example goes on to say that "John includes the total $40,000 of pension distributions in his federal adjusted gross income for the tax year," and that "The maximum pension and annuity income exclusion John is allowed for the tax year is $20,000." ( Information for retired persons)

Be careful with this example. The excerpt doesn't explain where the rest of John's $40,000 comes from, and it doesn't walk through the arithmetic that leads to the final amount. Read the full example on the page before you use it with a client, and don't rebuild the numbers from memory. The age in the example is also a reason to check the eligibility rules on the page before you tell a client they qualify. Intake is the time to gather facts. The eligibility call comes after you've read the rule.

When a client has paperwork, ask for it at the second meeting rather than the first. Annual distribution statements, the account value on the date of inheritance, and the beneficiary designation or probate papers that show who received what are the documents that let you test the page's rules against real numbers. A client who brings a folder of statements makes the next conversation much shorter than one who says "I think it was around that much."

What to write in your intake notes:

  • Each pension, annuity, or retirement account the client receives payments from
  • Whether any of them were inherited, and from whom
  • The value of each inherited account at the time of inheritance, if the client knows it
  • How many people share the inheritance, and the split as the family understands it
  • The amount of each payment during the most recent tax year
  • Any other sources the client might count toward the total

Gather the documents later. The first call only needs the list.

Question 2: Does the business do business with Texans, and does it hold money or property that belongs to someone else?

Ask Texas clients, especially businesses: "Do you do business with customers or vendors in Texas? Do you hold any money or property that belongs to someone else, and has any of it gone unclaimed?"

PointFact from the page
Who is a HolderBusinesses and government entities doing business with Texans
Search site for money owedClaimItTexas.gov
Who can search Business and individuals
SourceAre you an unclaimed property holder?

The Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts states who has to deal with unclaimed property in short terms: "Businesses and government entities doing business with Texans are Holders." ( Are you an unclaimed property holder?) The sentence is short, and it covers more clients than you might expect. A business in New York or California doesn't have to be physically located in Texas to fall within it if it does business with Texans. A business that sells to Texas customers, online or otherwise, and a business that buys from Texas vendors should both be checked.

So the first step for a business client is to establish whether it does business with Texans at all. If it does, the Comptroller's page describes it as a holder, and the next step is a closer look at what the business holds. The page is the authority on the rest. Your job at intake is to find out whether the question applies and who in the client's office can answer it.

Phrase the location question around the customers, not the office. "Are you in Texas?" invites a quick no from a firm that is based in New York but sells to Texans every month. "Where are your customers and vendors?" gets a more accurate answer. If the client says it does no business with Texans, write down the basis for that answer, such as the states its customers are in, so the file shows how the conclusion was reached.

Ask what the business holds. The phrase "money or property belonging to someone else" is a general description, and the business should understand its own records well enough to answer. Ask whether the client keeps track of amounts owed to others, and whether it has a process for returning money when it is owed. You don't need to decide the answer on the first call. You need to know whether the question has to be answered and by whom.

The Comptroller also offers a way to check for money owed to the client. The page says, "Business and individuals can search for their unclaimed property at ClaimItTexas.gov." ( Are you an unclaimed property holder?) That applies to individual clients as well. A sole proprietor, a partner, or an owner may be the person who is owed something, not the business. Ask individual Texas clients whether they have searched the site before you move on.

What to write in your intake notes:

  • Whether the business does any business with Texans, including Texas customers and Texas vendors
  • Whether the client has ever received a notice about unclaimed property
  • Whether the business has searched ClaimItTexas.gov for itself and for its owners
  • Who in the business is responsible for keeping records of amounts owed to others
  • Whether the answer needs a follow-up from a colleague who handles unclaimed property

If the answer to the first question is yes, don't treat the intake note as finished. Open the Comptroller's page during the call or after it, confirm the client's status, and put the follow-up on the calendar. Clients often assume a business located outside Texas has no Texas obligations. The first question is there to test that assumption before it costs them.

Question 3: Does the business buy items to resell, and what resale certificates does it use?

Ask California clients: "Do you buy items you plan to resell? Do you give or accept resale certificates? Do you buy things for your own use from the same suppliers?"

PointFact from the page
Who may issue certificatesPurchasers engaged in selling tangible personal property
Seller duty before accepting Note the general nature of the purchaser's business
Non-ordinary itemRequire a certificate stating the property is for resale
Misuse consequence Penalties and interest
SourcePublication 103, Sales for Resale

The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration publishes Publication 103 on sales for resale. The core rule is simple to say: "Purchasers who are engaged in the business of selling tangible personal property may issue resale certificates when purchasing items they will sell in the regular course of their business operations." ( Publication 103, Sales for Resale)

That sentence has three conditions. The purchaser must be in the business of selling tangible personal property, the item must be something the purchaser will sell, and the sale must happen in the regular course of business. Those three conditions are what you check at intake. A business that sells furniture and buys wood to build furniture is in a different position from a business that buys a printer for its office and treats the purchase as a resale.

Resale certificates work in two directions. A business may be on the buying side, issuing certificates to its suppliers. Or it may be on the selling side, accepting certificates from its customers. Your intake questions should cover both, because the publication places different duties on each side.

If the client is the seller, the publication says, "It's important for sellers to note the general nature of the purchaser's business before accepting a resale certificate." It gives an example: "For example, if a furniture maker attempts to buy office supplies for resale, the seller should ask whether the purchaser intends to sell the office supplies in the regular course of business." ( Publication 103, Sales for Resale) Put simply, a seller shouldn't accept a certificate without knowing what the buyer does. The publication also covers items the buyer doesn't ordinarily sell: "If a purchaser is buying an item that is not something they ordinarily sell, the seller should require a resale certificate that states that the specific property is being purchased for resale in the regular course of business." ( Publication 103, Sales for Resale)

If the client is the buyer, the same publication warns about misuse: "Purchasers are subject to penalties and interest for the misuse of a resale certificate." ( Publication 103, Sales for Resale) The exposure sits with the business that signs the certificate. A client who uses a certificate to buy items for its own office, its own vehicles, or its own equipment is taking that risk. Ask how the client decides which purchases get a certificate, and who makes that decision. A practical check is to pull a few recent certificates and compare each one with the invoice for the item it covers. If the item is something the business sells, the match is easy to explain. If it is office equipment, supplies, or anything the business uses rather than sells, the file needs a note explaining why the certificate was issued at all.

On the seller side, a useful intake question is "When a customer hands you a resale certificate, what do you check before you accept it?" The answer tells you whether the client has a routine or relies on the certificate alone. The publication's furniture example shows why the routine matters: the seller is expected to ask about the buyer's use of what it is buying, not just to file the paper.

What to write in your intake notes:

  • What the business sells, in plain terms
  • What it buys to resell, and from whom
  • Whether it buys items for its own use from the same vendors
  • Whether it issues resale certificates to suppliers, and who signs them
  • Whether it accepts resale certificates from customers, and how it checks what the buyer does
  • Whether there is a written process for deciding when a certificate applies

If the answers suggest that certificates are being used for items the business doesn't resell, flag it. The publication describes penalties and interest for misuse, so raise the issue early, not after the filing season is underway.

Worked example

A first call with a retired client in New York and a small firm in California. You ask question one and learn the client inherited a pension shared with two siblings, so the family's combined exclusion stays under $20,000 rather than giving each heir a full allowance. You note the split as the family understands it. You ask question three and learn the California client buys both resale items and office supplies from the same vendor. You note which purchases get a certificate and who signs it. Both files go into the "needs documents" pile, with the specific papers named.

Putting the three answers into your intake notes

The questions are short, but the notes they generate should be easy to act on. A simple table helps when you are reviewing a file or handing it to a colleague. The rows below restate the figures and facts from the pages cited above, so you can compare them quickly. Check each against the current version of its page before you use it with a client.

State and sourceFact from the source
New York: maximum exclusion, from all qualifying sourcesMay not exceed $20,000
New York: example IRA value at inheritance$100,000
New York: example pension value at inheritance$400,000
New York: John's annual distribution from his own pension (Example 3)$15,000
New York: total pension distributions John includes in federal AGI$40,000
New York: maximum exclusion allowed to John for the tax year$20,000
Texas: who is a HolderBusinesses and government entities doing business with Texans
Texas: where to search for unclaimed property ClaimItTexas.gov
California: who may issue resale certificates Purchasers engaged in the business of selling tangible personal property, for items they will sell in the regular course of business
California: consequence of misusing a resale certificatePenalties and interest

Three habits make these questions work in practice. First, ask them on every intake, not only on the files that look like they need them. A retired client with one pension may not think of an inherited account, and a small service firm may not think of a Texas customer as a Texas issue. Asking every time removes the guesswork.

Second, write the answers in the client's file in the client's own words. If a client says the inheritance was split among three siblings, record that, along with the split as the family understands it. Don't reduce it to "inherited IRA." The rules turn on details like that, and a short summary is hard to check later.

Third, separate the first call from the advice. The intake answers tell you what needs a closer look. They do not decide the outcome. For each yes, open the linked page, test the rule against the client's facts, and then decide whether the client needs a document request, a referral, or no further action.

The three states also ask three different kinds of question. New York's question is about retirement income and how inherited amounts are shared. Texas asks whether the business is a holder of property that may belong to someone else. California asks what the business buys to resell and how it documents those purchases. A general question such as "any state issues?" will get a vague answer. Specific questions get specific answers, and the answers are what let you plan the work.

After the call: sorting your follow-ups

Once the intake notes are written, sort each file into one of three piles. The sorting is not the final answer on any rule. It tells the next person what kind of work the file needs.

The first pile is for clear no answers. A client with no qualifying pension or retirement income, no inherited accounts, no business dealings with Texans, and no purchases for resale has nothing to chase under these three questions. Record the answers and the date, and move on. A short, dated note protects the firm if the question comes up again later.

The second pile is for files that need documents. Pension statements, records of inherited account values, a list of who shares an inheritance, a copy of the ClaimItTexas.gov search results, and sample resale certificates with matching invoices all fall here. Make a specific request for each item, and note which page the document will be tested against. A request that says "send us everything about your pensions" usually produces a stack of paper that someone has to sort again.

The third pile is for files where the answer changes the work. A Texas business that is a holder, a client who has inherited an account shared among several people, or a business that issues resale certificates for items it does not sell should go to the colleague who handles that area. Hand off the intake notes, the linked pages, and the client's own words about what happened. The receiving colleague should not have to repeat the first call.

Whichever pile a file lands in, keep the question list with the file. When the client calls back in a year, the same questions tell you what has changed, and the answers you wrote down the first time make the second conversation faster.

General information, not legal or tax advice.

Sources