Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

1098-T scholarship amount wrong: 2 reasons to check

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read

A 1098-T scholarship amount may look wrong because of payment timing or prior-year adjustments; UMass describes both situations.

Key takeaways

  • Check posting dates against the terms payments cover.
  • Trace Box 6 adjustments to the earlier form.
  • Confirm the form's year and issuer before interpreting a blank box.
  • Ask the school for a written breakdown when amounts remain unclear.

The explanations come from one school's published guidance, the University of Massachusetts Form 1098-T page. Treat them as that school's rules, not as a description of every school. Your client's form may follow the same pattern, or it may not, so the checks below matter more than any single explanation.

This post is written for partners and operations leads who need to explain a student's 1098-T before a client files. It is not a substitute for the school's own statement or for the client's records. Use it to organize the questions you ask and to decide which records you need before you say anything about the number.

The Internal Revenue Service describes why the form matters to a taxpayer: "If you received a Form 1098-T, this statement provides information that will help you figure your credit" ( IRS, Education credits - AOTC and LLC). That is a reason to take the form seriously, and also a reason not to accept a surprising number without tracing it first.

Reason 1: Box 5 can include tuition paid for a later term

At UMass, the scholarship and grant amount in Box 5 can be higher than what the student actually received in the year, when a department or third-party payment provider pays next term's tuition during the current year. The explanation is timing, so it helps to understand the timing rule before you look at any single number.

The UMass page states the rule plainly: "The 1098-T only displays transactions that are posted to a student account within a calendar year, regardless of the year that the transactions affect."

UMass gives a direct example: "For example, your Box 5 value for Scholarships and Grants may be higher than what you actually received in a year if your department or third party payment provider pays your future term tuition in the current year." The page then describes one version of that situation: "This often happens when the tuition for the spring semester of next year is calculated in December of current year, and if the department /3rd party pays that tuition in December of the current year it will appear on the current tax year Form1098-T."

This is where clients get confused. A client who attended classes for the full year may look at Box 5 and see money tied to a term that had not started when the calendar year ended. Their first reaction may be that the school made a mistake, or that the scholarship was counted twice. Before you accept either explanation, check when the payment posted. The year on the form is the posting year, and a client's own sense of "this year" may be a term year. Those two can differ, and that difference may be the whole explanation.

Here is how to check the timing:

  • Get the student's account transaction history with posting dates, not only the charges listed by term.
  • Look for scholarship or third-party payments posted late in the calendar year that match tuition for the next term.
  • Add up those postings and compare the total with the Box 5 figure.
  • If the totals line up, you have a concrete explanation to share with the client.
  • If the trail is unclear, ask the school whether it can provide a written breakdown of what makes up the amount.

When you contact the school, be specific. Name the student's account, the form's year, and the Box 5 amount, and ask which postings make up that amount. A narrow question is easier to answer than a general request for an explanation.

Keep the transaction list in the client file. If the question comes back next year, you will have a record of how the number was traced, and you will not have to rebuild the account history from memory.

Illustrative example: matching postings

A student's account shows two postings in December: a scholarship payment and a third-party payment. Box 5 on the form is larger than the scholarship payment alone. Adding the two postings together matches Box 5, because the second payment covered the coming term's tuition and posted in the calendar year the form reports. The mismatch is timing, not a duplicate count. Tell the client which two postings produced the figure and which term each one covers.

Reason 2: Box 6 can carry adjustments to scholarships from an earlier year

Box 6 can hold adjustments to scholarships and grants that were reported in an earlier year. UMass describes it as working in a way similar to Box 4: "Similar to Box 4, Box 6 reports adjustments to previously reported scholarships and grants from a prior year."

This is the second reason a number can look wrong. A client may compare the scholarship amount with this year's enrollment and conclude the figure is off. But a figure tied to a prior year may not line up with this year's classes at all. The mismatch comes from the year the adjustment belongs to, so the first thing to check is the year of the original scholarship.

UMass also notes that more than one box can carry a value for the same student: "Some students may have box 4 and box 6 populated as well." When both boxes are filled, a client who looks at only one box gets an incomplete picture. Read the two boxes together, and note what each one says on the form before you write anything down about the client's year.

Clients often find this part hard to accept because the adjustment does not feel like something that happened recently. The adjustment is attached to a prior year, so the explanation has to point back to that year. A simple way to say it is that the form includes an adjustment to an earlier amount, and that adjustment can make the figure look unrelated to this year.

When you walk a client through this, separate three things: the year the form covers, the year the original scholarship was reported, and the amount shown in Box 6. Keep those three apart on paper. Mixing them is how a prior-year adjustment can look like an error.

Checks for Box 6:

  • Note whether Box 6 has a value. If it does, do not assume the amount is for this year's enrollment.
  • Note whether Box 4 has a value too, and write down what each box shows.
  • Ask the client for any earlier Form 1098-T they received, and compare the earlier amounts with the adjustment.
  • If the form does not make the prior year clear, ask the school to identify the earlier tax year that the adjustment concerns.

Do not change any figure in the return based on the form alone. First confirm which year the amount belongs to, then decide how it should be handled. The check is about tracing the amount, and tracing takes the client's records and the school's answer.

Separate check: an empty Box 4 on a 2018 UMass form

At UMass, Box 4 is empty on the 2018 Form 1098-T. The page gives the reason: "Note: Since 2018 is the first year of the payment reporting method, Box4 on 2018 1098-T will be empty." That note is about 2018 at UMass only. It does not say what Box 4 shows in other years, and it does not say anything about other schools.

The note is useful for a different reason, too. It shows that a blank box can be tied to the reporting method a school used in a given year.

Record the form's year, the issuer, and the box values before you compare anything. A comparison made without those details can send you to the wrong year's records, which is an easy mistake when several forms sit in one client file. If a client has a 2018 form from UMass and sees an empty Box 4, the blank is explained by the note. If a client has a blank box on a different year or a different school's form, the UMass note does not settle the question. Check the form's own year and issuer before you read anything into a blank box.

Box 1 is a separate figure, and clients can mix it up with the scholarship amount or with what they paid. The IRS explains what Box 1 shows: "The form will have an amount in Box 1 to show the amounts received during the year" ( IRS, Education credits - AOTC and LLC). That is the amount the form reports as received, and it is a different measure from the scholarship boxes covered in the first two sections.

The UMass page also addresses why Box 1 may differ from payment records. Read UMass's section on that question before you conclude the form is wrong. A mismatch between Box 1 and a client's payment records is a reason to trace the difference, not a reason to assume an error.

Checks for Box 1 and the blank Box 4:

  • Write down the payments the client made, with the dates and amounts.
  • Compare that list with the Box 1 figure on the form.
  • Note any difference, along with the dates of the payments involved.
  • Do not change the return until you know which figure the form reports and which year it covers.
  • For a blank Box 4, check the form's year and issuer. A blank box on a 2018 UMass form has a stated reason. A blank box anywhere else needs its own explanation.

How to explain the gap to a client

Explain the gap by showing which transactions produce the number and which calendar year each one posted in. A client who sees a dated list can follow the reasoning, and a client who only hears a general statement about timing may not be able to follow it. The aim is a document the client can read, not a debate about whether the school made a mistake.

Next, cover the adjustment. If Box 6 has a value, explain that it is an adjustment to an amount reported in an earlier year. Point to the earlier form or the school's breakdown so the client can see where the amount came from. If Box 4 is also filled, explain both boxes together, because the UMass page notes that some students have both populated.

Then address Box 1 and the payment records. Walk through the payments with dates and amounts, and show where the totals agree or differ. If the difference cannot be traced yet, say so directly. A clear statement that the source has not been found is more useful to a client than a guess that sounds confident and turns out to be wrong.

Avoid promising more than the records show. You can say what the form reports, what the transaction history shows, and what remains unresolved. You cannot say the school will correct the form, and you should not say the client owes or is owed a particular amount until the trail supports it.

Use plain language. Words like "posting year," "prior-year adjustment," and "amount received" are accurate, but the client may need a sentence of explanation for each one. Give that sentence in writing, so the client can read it again after the call.

Before the client files

Before a client files, hold the return until the scholarship figure is traced to specific transactions and specific years. That means knowing which postings make up Box 5, whether Box 6 or Box 4 carries a value, and how Box 1 compares with the payments the client made. A trace takes time, and it is easier to do before the return is filed than after.

If the work is split between a partner and an operations lead, agree in advance who pulls the transaction history and who contacts the school. Put the request in writing, with the form's year and the boxes in question, so the answer comes back in a form you can file. Use the client intake checklist to organize that handoff, alongside the student 1098 intake form.

A short checklist covers the work:

  • Confirm the form's year and the school that issued it.
  • Pull the transaction history with posting dates.
  • Match late-year postings to the terms they cover.
  • Note whether Box 4 and Box 6 are filled, and what each one shows.
  • Compare Box 1 with the client's payment records, and record any difference.
  • Ask the school for a written breakdown if the trail is unclear.
  • Save the trace in the client file with the date you finished it.

Keep one caution in mind. The two scholarship explanations in this post come from one school's published guidance. UMass's rules are UMass's, and the Massachusetts school's form is not a model for every other school. When the form in front of you comes from a different institution, look for that institution's own explanation before you apply anything from this post.

Today, request the student's account transaction history with posting dates and compare it with the form before contacting the school about any unexplained difference.

Questions before filing

Does a surprising scholarship amount mean the form is wrong?

No; first check payment timing and prior-year adjustments. Trace the amount before deciding whether an error occurred.

What should I ask the school?

Ask which account postings make up the amount in question. Include the form's year and the box you need explained.

Sources