Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Accountable plan tests: 3 rules before a reimbursement

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read

A reimbursement stays off the W-2 only when the arrangement meets all 3 tests, according to Internal Revenue Service.

Key takeaways

  • Business connection: confirm each expense was deductible and paid or incurred while performing services as an employee.
  • Adequate accounting: substantiate expenses to the employer within a reasonable period, with 60 days after the expense is paid or incurred as the safe harbor.
  • Excess return: give back any excess within a reasonable period, with 120 days after the expense is paid or incurred as the safe harbor.

A reimbursement stays off the W-2 only when the arrangement meets all 3 tests

The Internal Revenue Service defines the requirement for an accountable plan. To be an accountable plan, your employer’s reimbursement or allowance arrangement must meet three rules: business connection, adequate accounting to the employer within a reasonable period, and return of any excess within a reasonable period, according to Internal Revenue Service. This definition sets the baseline for how your firm evaluates a client’s expense policy. If the client’s arrangement lacks any part of this structure, it does not meet the accountable plan standard.

The W-2 reporting consequence depends entirely on this classification. Reimbursements treated as paid under an accountable plan, as explained next, aren’t reported as pay, according to Internal Revenue Service. This keeps the amount out of the employee’s taxable wages for that period. In contrast, reimbursements treated as paid under nonaccountable plans, as explained later, are reported as pay, according to Internal Revenue Service. This distinction drives the payroll calculation and the tax liability for the employee.

The regulatory text confirms the gross income treatment. Amounts treated as paid under an accountable plan are excluded from the employee's gross income, are not reported as wages or other compensation on the employee's Form W-2, and are exempt from the withholding and payment of employment taxes (Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA), Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA), Railroad Retirement Tax Act (RRTA), Railroad Unemployment Repayment Tax (RURT), and income tax.) See paragraph (l) of this section for cross references, according to Cornell Law School. This exclusion applies specifically to amounts that meet the accountable plan criteria.

The Cornell Law School source provides the regulatory basis for this treatment. It states that amounts under an accountable plan are excluded from gross income. It also states that amounts under a nonaccountable plan are included in gross income. This binary outcome is clear. The amount is either wages or it is not wages. Your job is to determine which one it is.

The business-connection test

The first requirement for an accountable plan is that the employee’s expenses have a business connection. According to Internal Revenue Service, your expenses must have a business connection—that is, you must have paid or incurred deductible expenses while performing services as an employee of your employer. This definition ties the reimbursement directly to the act of working for the company. The test also requires the expense to be deductible and paid or incurred while performing services as an employee, so timing during job duties alone does not satisfy it.

The legal framework for this requirement is found in the U.S. Code. According to Government Publishing Office, the deductions allowed by part VI (section 161 and following) consist of expenses paid or incurred by the taxpayer, in connection with the performance by him of services as an employee, under a reimbursement or other expense allowance arrangement with his employer. This statutory language confirms that the expense must be linked to the performance of services. The phrase "in connection with" establishes the necessary link between the money spent and the work done.

For an operations lead reviewing a client’s reimbursement voucher, this test asks a specific question: was the expense incurred while the employee was acting in their capacity as an employee? The expense does not need to be a standard business cost like office supplies; it must simply be a deductible expense paid or incurred during the performance of services. If the employee paid for a meal while traveling for work, that expense has a business connection because it was incurred while performing services. If the employee paid for a personal item during that same trip, that item lacks the business connection because it was not incurred while performing services as an employee.

The substantiation test and the 60-day safe harbor

The second requirement for an accountable plan is that the employee adequately accounts to the employer for the expenses. Under the regulation definition provided by Cornell Law School, a reimbursement or other expense allowance arrangement must meet the substantiation requirements found in paragraph (e) of 26 CFR § 1.62-2, alongside the business connection and excess-return rules Cornell Law School. This substantiation is not merely a formality; it is a core component of the arrangement that distinguishes an accountable plan from a nonaccountable one.

The Internal Revenue Service specifies that you must adequately account to your employer for these expenses within a reasonable period of time Internal Revenue Service. The term "adequately account" implies that the employee provides sufficient documentation to prove the expense was incurred and was for a business purpose. The regulation clarifies that the determination of a reasonable period of time will depend on the facts and circumstances Cornell Law School. This means there is no single universal deadline that applies to every situation; the reasonableness of the timing is contextual.

However, the regulation provides a specific safe harbor to remove ambiguity. According to Cornell Law School, an expense substantiated to the payor within 60 days after it is paid or incurred will be treated as having occurred within a reasonable period of time Cornell Law School. This 60-day window is part of a broader safe harbor that also includes advances made within 30 days and returns of excess amounts within 120 days, but for the substantiation test specifically, the 60-day mark is the critical benchmark. If the employee submits the substantiation within this 60-day period, the arrangement is deemed to meet the reasonable period requirement for that specific test.

If the employee fails to substantiate the expense within a reasonable period, the arrangement may fail the substantiation test. While the 60-day safe harbor provides a clear standard, the regulation emphasizes that outside of this safe harbor, the determination depends on the facts and circumstances Cornell Law School. For a small accounting firm reviewing a client’s payroll, this suggests that if a client’s policy allows for a longer or shorter period, the firm should verify whether that period is reasonable based on the specific operational context. The 60-day rule serves as a reliable baseline for compliance.

The excess-return test and the 120-day safe harbor

The third requirement for an accountable plan involves the handling of amounts that exceed the actual business costs. An excess reimbursement or allowance is any amount you are paid that is more than the business-related expenses that you adequately accounted for to your employer, according to Internal Revenue Service. This definition isolates the specific portion of the payment that lacks a matching business expense. If the employee receives a flat allowance that is higher than the documented costs, the difference constitutes the excess.

The regulation requires the employee to give back this surplus. You must return any excess reimbursement or allowance within a reasonable period of time, according to Internal Revenue Service. This return requirement ensures that the employee does not keep money that was not tied to a valid business expense. The "reasonable period" is not a fixed number of days in the general rule; it depends on the specific facts and circumstances of the arrangement. However, the regulations provide a specific safe harbor to simplify compliance for firms that want a clear, objective deadline.

The safe harbor treats the return of excess within 120 days as a reasonable period. If the employee returns the excess amount within this 120-day window, the arrangement meets the return requirement of the accountable plan rules. The 120 days run from the date the expense was paid or incurred, which gives the operations lead a concrete date to track. When the 120-day mark passes, the firm should verify whether the excess has been returned. If the employee has not returned the excess by then, the firm must determine if the facts and circumstances still support a reasonable period or if the plan fails this test.

The consequence of failing this test is significant for the W-2. If the arrangement does not meet the return requirement, the amounts paid generally are not treated as paid under an accountable plan, subject to an exception discussed below. Instead, they are treated as wages subject to income tax withholding and employment taxes. The regulation states that, except as provided in paragraph (c)(2)(ii) of this section, if an arrangement meets the requirements of paragraphs (d), (e), and (f) of this section, all amounts paid under it are treated as paid under an “accountable plan,” according to Cornell Law School. This implies that meeting all three tests, including the return of excess, is necessary for the favorable tax treatment.

Illustrative example: timing of a business lunch claim

An employee pays for a business lunch and submits the claim 30 days later. Because 30 days falls inside the 60-day substantiation window, the timing requirement is met. If the employee returns an excess amount 120 days after the expense was paid, that return also falls within the safe harbor.

Accountable plan rules by publisher

PublisherRule or DefinitionSafe Harbor or Scope
Internal Revenue Service To be an accountable plan, your employer’s reimbursement or allowance arrangement must meet three rules: business connection, adequate accounting, and return of excess. Internal Revenue ServiceThe arrangement must meet all three rules to be an accountable plan. Internal Revenue Service
Cornell Law School An advance made within 30 days of when an expense is paid or incurred, an expense substantiated to the payor within 60 days after it is paid or incurred, or an amount returned to the payor within 120 days after an expense is paid or incurred will be treated as having occurred within a reasonable period of time. Cornell Law School An advance made within 30 days of when an expense is paid or incurred, an expense substantiated to the payor within 60 days after it is paid or incurred, or an amount returned to the payor within 120 days after an expense is paid or incurred will be treated as having occurred within a reasonable period of time. Cornell Law School
General Services Administration We establish the travel rates that federal agencies use to reimburse their employees for lodging and meals and incidental expenses incurred while on official travel within the continental United States. General Services Administration The rates are for federal agencies to reimburse their employees for lodging and meals and incidental expenses incurred while on official travel within the continental United States. General Services Administration

Use this table to see which publisher sets the structural rules, which sets the time limits, and which sets the scope of the travel rates.

What the federal travel rates cover and who sets them

When a client asks which travel rate to use for an employee’s travel, the first question is who is setting that rate. The General Services Administration states that it establishes the travel rates that federal agencies use to reimburse their employees for lodging and meals and incidental expenses incurred while on official travel within the continental United States, according to General Services Administration. This sentence defines the scope of the rates: they are for federal agencies reimbursing their own employees.

The Internal Revenue Service notes that travel rates are listed by the federal government’s fiscal year, which runs from October 1 to September 30, according to Internal Revenue Service. This timing detail helps you match a travel date to the correct rate table, but it does not change who the rates are for. The fiscal year structure applies to the listing of the rates, not to a mandate for private payroll practices.

The General Services Administration also indicates that individual rates apply to about 300 non-standard areas, according to General Services Administration. This means that for most locations, a standard rate applies, while a smaller set of areas has its own specific rate. Again, this structure is for federal agency travel. If a private client wants to use a travel allowance system for its own employees, it must set its own policy. The GSA rates are a reference point that federal agencies use, not a required reimbursement level for private firms.

Your next step today: pull the reimbursement policy your client already has, check it against the 3 tests above, and log each gap in the Accounting Client Intake Checklist for a Clear Handoff. Then compare the payroll file with the Client payroll employee file: 4 checks before pay.

Accountable plan FAQ

What are the three tests for an accountable plan?

According to the Internal Revenue Service, an arrangement must include three specific rules to be an accountable plan. First, expenses must have a business connection, meaning the employee paid or incurred deductible expenses while performing services as an employee. Second, the employee must adequately account for these expenses to the employer within a reasonable period of time. Third, the employee must return any excess reimbursement or allowance within a reasonable period of time.

What happens if one test fails?

If the arrangement does not meet all the rules, it is not an accountable plan. Amounts paid under a nonaccountable plan are included in the employee's gross income. These amounts are then reported as wages on Form W-2. This distinguishes them from accountable plan amounts, which are not reported as pay.

What do the 30, 60, and 120-day figures mean?

The 26 CFR § 1.62-2 regulation provides a safe harbor for what constitutes a reasonable period. An advance made within 30 days of when an expense is paid or incurred is treated as timely. An expense substantiated to the payor within 60 days after it is paid or incurred is treated as timely. An amount returned to the payor within 120 days after an expense is paid or incurred is treated as timely. These specific day counts serve as a benchmark for compliance.

Are those figures the only reasonable period?

No, the 30, 60, and 120-day figures are a safe harbor, not the exclusive standard. The determination of a reasonable period of time will depend on the facts and circumstances, according to Cornell Law School. If a specific situation does not fit these day counts, the reasonableness of the period is still evaluated based on the specific facts and circumstances of that case.

Do federal travel rates set a private client's policy?

No, federal travel rates do not set a private client's policy. These rates apply specifically to federal agencies reimbursing their own employees, not to private employers setting reimbursement policies for their staff.

Sources