A cafeteria plan and a health FSA are not interchangeable at intake. Under IRS Publication 15-B (2026), a cafeteria plan can include benefits such as a qualified 401(k) plan, but it can't include the benefits that section 2 says it can't include. For the federal OPM health care FSA (LEX HCFSA), the key number is $500: OPM says unused balances are forfeited except that qualifying employees may carry over up to $500 to the next benefit year.
> Chief takeaways > > - A cafeteria plan is a plan structure, and IRS Publication 15-B (2026) sets what it can include. > - A qualified 401(k) plan can be a benefit inside a cafeteria plan. > - Check every benefit on a client's cafeteria list against section 2 of the publication. > Health FSA unused balances are forfeited, except that qualifying employees may carry over up to $500 to the next benefit year. > For the federal LEX HCFSA, OPM describes enrollment during open season or within 60 days of hire or eligibility; confirm the client's own plan windows.
What a cafeteria plan is
A cafeteria plan is a plan that lets employees choose from a menu of benefits. At intake, you will usually see it described as the structure, with individual benefits sitting inside it. The IRS explains the rules in its employer's guide to fringe benefits, and the 2026 version is IRS Publication 15-B (2026). The publication states the core point this way: "A cafeteria plan can include the following benefits discussed in section 2."
That sentence is short, but it answers the first intake question. Once you know the cafeteria plan is the wrapper, the next question is which benefits sit inside it. Section 2 of the publication is the reference point for that check. When a client says it has a cafeteria plan, do not accept the label alone. Ask for the list of benefits the plan actually offers and match each one to section 2.
A workable intake routine follows from that. Pull the written plan document and the summary the employer gave employees, then compare the two. Record which benefits are elected through the cafeteria plan and which are provided outside it, because the two groups need separate tracking. Flag any item the client calls part of the cafeteria plan that you cannot tie to a benefit section 2 covers.
At year-end, the same list is the starting point for reconciliation. Elections made during the year should appear in the client's payroll records and in the employee detail you review. A benefit that was offered but is missing from the approved list is a question to raise before filing, not after the return is prepared.
Keep the scope in mind. A cafeteria plan is the umbrella, and the rules for each benefit inside it come from the publication's section 2 list. Reviewing the umbrella alone will miss the item that causes the problem, so the list-by-list match is the step that matters most.
What a cafeteria plan cannot cover
The same publication sets the limits. It says: "A cafeteria plan can't include the following benefits discussed in section 2." In other words, the section 2 discussion works in both directions. Some benefits fit inside a cafeteria plan, and others do not. Your review must check both sides.
Start with the client's list. For each item, ask whether it is one of the benefits section 2 says a cafeteria plan can include or one it says it can't. If an item falls in the excluded group, it cannot sit inside the cafeteria plan, no matter how the client describes it in its handbook. That is a substantive finding, and it changes how the item must be documented and reported.
This is also where intake notes often go wrong. Clients tend to describe every employee perk as "part of our cafeteria plan." A perk that is offered alongside the plan is a different thing from a benefit that is properly elected through it. Write down the distinction for each perk so that the file shows which items were handled inside the plan and which were not.
Excluded benefits can create reporting questions that carry into payroll. The supplemental wage withholding section later in this article covers how that affects withholding. For now, the practical rule is simple: if an excluded benefit appears in the cafeteria plan list, correct the list before you approve the plan in the client's file.
Finally, keep a short memo that names each excluded item you found and the section 2 reference that applies. A memo like this lets a reviewer at year-end see the basis for your intake decisions without rebuilding the analysis from the start.
Side-by-side comparison of the two plans
Partners often ask how a cafeteria plan and a health FSA relate. The two topics are related, but the rules come from different sources. The table below compares them on the same three measures so you can see where each one sets its limits.
| Measure | Cafeteria plan | Health FSA |
|---|---|---|
| Rule source | IRS Publication 15-B (2026) | OPM Health Savings Accounts guidance |
| Named benefit | Qualified 401(k) plan, plus benefits in section 2 | Health care FSA (HCFSA) |
| Main limit | Cannot include the benefits section 2 excludes | Unused balances forfeited, except up to $500 carried over by qualifying employees |
The cafeteria plan row is about scope: what can sit inside the plan. The health FSA row is about money: what happens to an employee's unused balance. Read together, they answer different intake questions. A client may have one, the other, or both, and each needs its own check.
The first two rows describe what each option is and where its rules come from. The third row is where the risk sits. For a cafeteria plan, the risk is including something the publication excludes. For a health FSA, the risk is an unused balance that the employee expected to keep. Both risks show up in the client's paperwork, so both belong on your intake checklist.
When you compare the two in a client file, keep them on separate lines. Combining them can hide which rule applies to which benefit. A clear side-by-side record also makes year-end review faster, because the reviewer can see at a glance whether each element was handled under the right rule.
Where a 401(k) fits inside a cafeteria plan
One benefit that surprises some reviewers is the 401(k). The IRS states: "However, a cafeteria plan can include a qualified 401(k) plan as a benefit." That means a qualified 401(k) plan is not only something an employer offers beside a cafeteria plan. It can be one of the benefits inside it. The source for that statement is IRS Publication 15-B (2026).
For intake, this changes the review. If a client lists a 401(k) as a cafeteria plan benefit, do not stop at confirming the plan exists. Check that the 401(k) is a qualified plan and that it is listed as a benefit in the cafeteria plan documents. The qualified status is the fact that makes the inclusion permitted, so it belongs in your file as its own line item.
The 401(k) also tends to appear in two places in a client's records: the benefit summary and the payroll deduction records. Your review should confirm that both show the same arrangement. A mismatch between the two is a common reason for a follow-up question at year-end.
Keep the 401(k) separate from the health FSA in your notes. The two often appear on the same benefit statement, and their rules differ. The 401(k) question is about whether a qualified plan is included in the cafeteria plan. The health FSA question is about enrollment timing and balances. Mixing them can lead a reviewer to apply the wrong rule to the wrong benefit.
Finally, write down the source you relied on. Citing the publication and its year, as in IRS Publication 15-B (2026), lets the next reviewer confirm the basis for including the 401(k) without repeating your research.
Supplemental wage withholding on taxable benefits
Some items that sit outside a cafeteria plan still reach payroll, and they can change withholding. The Beancount guide on supplemental wages notes that "A commission, overtime payment, prize, or taxable fringe benefit can create the same problem." The source is the Beancount post on supplemental wages in 2026.
The excerpt does not specify what "the same problem" is. For intake, that means you should list every supplemental item a client pays, not just bonuses. A taxable fringe benefit that was elected outside the cafeteria plan belongs on the same list.
This connects to the section 2 review. When you find a benefit the cafeteria plan cannot include, trace where its cost goes. If it is taxable and paid through payroll, it becomes part of the supplemental wage review. Missing that link is how an intake review that looked clean in the plan document still produces a payroll correction at year-end.
A practical checklist for supplemental items has three parts. First, identify every item that is paid outside regular wages, including commissions, overtime, prizes, and taxable fringe benefits. Second, confirm the client's payroll system tags each one as supplemental. Third, check that the year-end totals match what the client reports on its wage records.
Keep the review in the same file as the cafeteria plan analysis. The two checks touch the same benefits from opposite directions, and a reviewer who sees both will catch an item that the other check missed.
How to enroll in a health FSA
Enrollment timing is the first thing to confirm for a health FSA. The OPM guidance for its federal health care FSA, the LEX HCFSA, gives a clear example of the rule. OPM states: "To enroll in a LEX HCFSA (during the annual Federal Benefits Open Season or within 60 days after becoming a newly hired or newly eligible employee), go to www.FSAFEDS.com." The source is OPM's Health Savings Accounts page.
The table below sets out the enrollment routes that the OPM sentence names. Each row is a route an employee can use, and the timing or detail is what you check against the client's records.
| Enrollment route | Timing or detail |
|---|---|
| Annual Federal Benefits Open Season | Once a year, during open season |
| Newly hired or newly eligible employee | Within 60 days after becoming eligible |
| Enrollment site | www.FSAFEDS.com |
The table shows that enrollment is tied to two triggers: the annual window and the 60-day window after a new hire or new eligibility. For intake, record the date each employee became eligible and the date enrollment was completed. If the enrollment falls outside both windows, the client needs to confirm that a different rule applies.
This is a federal example, so apply it with care. The LEX HCFSA is OPM's program for federal employees. A small firm's client may run its own health FSA with its own enrollment rules. Use the OPM sentence to structure your questions, then confirm the exact window in the client's written plan before you rely on it.
Keep the enrollment record separate from the balance and deadline records. Enrollment tells you whether an employee could use the account at all. The balance and claims rules tell you what happened to the money. Each set of facts drives a different question at year-end.
Use-it-or-lose-it balances and the $500 carryover
The health FSA rule that most often surprises employees is what happens to money left in the account. OPM's guidance says: "Unused balances are forfeited except that qualifying employees may carry over up to $500 to an HCFSA in the next benefit year." The source is OPM's Health Savings Accounts page.
The sentence has two parts. The first sets the default: an unused balance is forfeited, so the employee loses it. The second is the exception: qualifying employees may carry over up to $500 into the next benefit year. The carryover is capped at $500, and it applies only to employees who qualify. The sentence does not say every employee keeps every dollar.
At intake, find out whether the client's plan allows a carryover at all, and if it does, who qualifies. The OPM sentence describes the federal program, so do not assume the client's plan matches it. Confirm the carryover terms in the client's written plan before you record a number in the file.
At year-end, compare the amount each employee contributed with the amount reimbursed. Check any remaining balance against the forfeiture default and, if the plan offers one, the $500 carryover. A balance above what the carryover allows is one the employee should not expect to keep under this rule.
Also check what employees were told. If they were told a balance would roll over without limit, the client may have a communication question to review before the next enrollment window. Your memo should record what the plan says, what employees were told, and where the two differ.
Expenses and the 12-month benefit period
The timing of expenses is the next check. OPM states: "Expenses must be incurred by the end of the 12 month benefit period (or by termination of employment, if before the end of the benefit period) and claims must be filed by the deadline." The source is the same OPM Health Savings Accounts page.
The sentence sets two cutoffs for expenses. The first is the end of the 12-month benefit period. The second applies when an employee leaves the job before that period ends: expenses must be incurred by the date of termination. In both cases the test is when the expense was incurred. The sentence also says claims must be filed by a separate deadline, which is covered in the next section.
At intake, ask the client for the start and end dates of its benefit period and write them in the file. Do not assume the period follows the calendar year. If it does not, the expense cutoff falls on a different date than the client may expect, and that should be flagged early.
At year-end, look at employees who left during the year. Under the termination rule, their expense cutoff moved earlier, so expenses incurred after the termination date fall outside the rule. A review that checks only the calendar year-end will miss these cases.
Keep the two cutoffs in separate columns of your checklist. One is the benefit period end and the other is the termination date. Combining them can hide a late expense from the review.
Claims filing deadline after the plan year
OPM sets a separate deadline for claims: "Claims for reimbursement must be submitted by April 30 following the end of the Plan Year." The source is OPM's Health Savings Accounts page.
The sentence gives a fixed date, April 30, and ties it to the end of the Plan Year. The same guidance uses a different term, "12 month benefit period," for the expense cutoff. The two terms are not defined as identical in the quoted text, so record which one the client's documents use and how each is defined. Do not treat them as interchangeable without checking the plan.
The two requirements work independently. An expense can be incurred within the benefit period and still miss the claims deadline if the claim is submitted late. Your checklist should test each one on its own.
For each health FSA client, put the April 30 date on the calendar and confirm it against the client's plan document rather than assuming the federal date applies. Keep a log of claim submission dates so you can show at year-end which claims were filed on time.
Figures to check at intake and year-end
This section gathers the numbers from the OPM quotes into one checklist. Each row is a figure you can check against the client's plan document.
| Figure | What it governs | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $500 | Maximum carryover to the next benefit year for qualifying employees | OPM |
| 12 month | Benefit period by which expenses must be incurred | OPM |
| 60 days | Window after a new hire or new eligibility to enroll | OPM |
| April 30 | Deadline to submit claims after the Plan Year ends | OPM |
All four figures come from one OPM page, so the client's own plan may set different terms. At intake, copy each figure from the client's plan document into the file and mark any that differ from the OPM text. At year-end, confirm that balances are no higher than the carryover allows, that expenses fall within the benefit period, and that claims were submitted by April 30 or the date the plan sets.
Use the same checklist each year. Figures that change between plan years are easy to miss if the file still shows last year's numbers.
Which one should you pick?
The sources define rules, not which benefit a client should adopt. Whether a cafeteria plan, a health FSA, or both fit an employer depends on its benefit goals and workforce, and that decision belongs to the client. Your job at intake is to confirm what the client has and how each piece is governed.
When a client has a cafeteria plan, start there. The IRS publication says a cafeteria plan can include a qualified 401(k) plan and can include the benefits discussed in section 2, but it can't include the benefits section 2 excludes. That check decides what sits inside the plan. Items that fall outside it may still be taxable compensation. Beancount's supplemental wages guide lists commissions, overtime, prizes, and taxable fringe benefits as items that the guide says can create the same problem, so trace those costs through payroll.
When a client has a health FSA, start with the OPM rules on enrollment timing, the $500 carryover, the benefit period, and the April 30 claims deadline. If a client has both, review the cafeteria list first, because a benefit excluded from the plan changes how its cost is reported, and then review the FSA balances and deadlines.
Reader questions
Does a cafeteria plan have to include a 401(k)? No. The IRS says a cafeteria plan "can include" a qualified 401(k) plan as a benefit. That is permission, not a requirement.
Can a cafeteria plan include any benefit an employer offers? No. Section 2 of IRS Publication 15-B lists benefits a cafeteria plan can't include. Check each item on the client's list against that section.
Can an employee carry over every dollar left in a health FSA? No. Unused balances are forfeited, except that qualifying employees may carry over up to $500 to the next benefit year.
What happens to a health FSA balance that is not carried over? Under the OPM default, it is forfeited. Only the carryover described in the OPM sentence is an exception.
When can an employee enroll in a health FSA? For the federal LEX HCFSA, OPM says enrollment happens during the annual Federal Benefits Open Season or within 60 days after becoming newly hired or newly eligible, at www.FSAFEDS.com. A client's own plan may use different windows, so confirm them in its documents.
Does an expense incurred after an employee leaves still count? Under the OPM sentence, expenses must be incurred by the end of the benefit period or by termination of employment, if termination comes first. An expense incurred after termination falls outside that rule. The quoted text does not address whether any balance can be claimed after separation, so check the client's plan document for that point.
Does the April 30 claims deadline apply to every client? The OPM sentence ties April 30 to the end of the Plan Year in OPM's federal program. Do not assume it applies to a client's plan. Confirm the date in the client's own documents.
Not legal or tax advice.