Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Which scans CDTFA excludes from electronic records

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read

CDTFA Regulation 1698 excludes PDF scans and microfilm/microfiche images from the definition of electronic records — they remain hardcopy records, as does original paper. The regulation lists "other media used in electronic imaging," and on this post's reading any further scanned image files fall under that phrase too.

  • Under Regulation 1698, hardcopy includes records created or recorded on paper, or stored in a storage-only imaging system such as microfilm, microfiche, PDF files, or other media used in electronic imaging.
  • If the best you can do is open the file and read the page, it is a PDF scan of hardcopy.
  • Keep the original paper for records that matter, scan only as a companion copy, and pull structured exports from source systems (point-of-sale, accounting software) for a true electronic record.
  • Do not shred on scan alone — until the record exists in an accepted form, the paper is the only record you have.

Why two scan types never count as electronic records

You scan client sales tax paperwork into PDF files because paper is hard to store and easy to lose. That instinct is right for filing. It is wrong for what the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration calls "electronic records."

Under Regulation 1698, a PDF scan is still a hardcopy record. So is anything you shoot onto microfilm or microfiche. The regulation defines hardcopy as records created or recorded on paper, or stored in a storage-only imaging system — and that list includes microfilm, microfiche, PDF files, and other media used in electronic imaging.

In plain words: scanning a sales tax document into a PDF does not convert it into an electronic record. It stays a hardcopy record that happens to live in a file cabinet with a folder name.

The two named exclusions are microfilm/microfiche images and PDF files, alongside "other media used in electronic imaging." Anything else you scan — TIFF, JPEG — is not named by the regulation; treating those as falling under the imaging phrase is this post's reading, not a quoted rule.

This matters because Regulation 1698 draws a hard line between two kinds of records. On one side sit electronic records. On the other sit hardcopy records. If you hand CDTFA a stack of PDFs and call them electronic records, you are using the wrong category.

For an operations lead at a small accounting firm, the practical risk is an audit where a reviewer asks for electronic record production and you cannot produce it — because what you have is a PDF, not an electronic record.

This post walks through the two excluded formats, shows what actually qualifies, and gives you a checklist you can run before your next sales tax filing season.

Who this guide is for

This is written for operations leads at small accounting firms. Your team scans client sales tax paperwork — invoices, cash register tapes, exemption certificates — into PDF files. You store those PDFs in a document management system or a shared drive. You may have told a client that the scan is "just as good as the original."

If you also read general practitioner guidance, you have seen the note that most records a tax practitioner retains will generally not fall into a mandatory retention category, which comes from The Tax Adviser. That advice is about work product and documentation records in general. Sales tax records tied to a client's California returns are different: the CDTFA regulation controls them directly.

Skip this guide if: your firm does no California sales tax work, you already run a purpose-built electronic records system that indexes and retrieves natively, or your client's records are all held as original paper with no imaging workflow at all.

Read it if: you scan to PDF and then treat the PDF as the record, your document management system cannot export to anything but PDF, or you have never checked which category a given document falls into before an audit request arrives.

The two formats CDTFA excludes

The regulation's own words do most of the work here. It states that electronic records do not include hardcopy records that are created or recorded on paper, or stored in a storage-only imaging system such as microfilm, microfiche, PDF files, or other media used in electronic imaging. That sentence, found in Regulation 1698, names the exclusions outright.

Format one: microfilm and microfiche scans. Microfilm was the pre-digital answer to bulky paper. You photograph pages onto film, then read them on a machine. Microfiche does the same with a flat sheet. The regulation treats both as storage-only imaging. The film holds pictures of records. It does not hold records.

Format two: PDF files. This is the one that catches most small firms. You scan a sales tax return, a bundle of invoices, or a cash register tape. The scanner or your document management tool saves the output as a PDF. You file it, name it, and maybe tag it. The regulation still calls it hardcopy.

The phrase "other media used in electronic imaging" is broad enough, on this post's reading, to catch other image formats too — though the regulation itself names none. The format name does not matter. What matters is that the file is a picture of a record rather than the record itself.

Here is how the two excluded formats compare against what the regulation accepts:

ItemCategory under Regulation 1698Counts as electronic record
PDF scan of an invoice Hardcopy (storage-only imaging)No
Microfilm or microfiche imageHardcopy (storage-only imaging)No
Record created in an electronic system, not in a storage-only imaging systemElectronic record (according to this post's reading)Yes
Paper original Hardcopy (created on paper)No

That last row matters more than people expect. An original paper document is also not an electronic record. It is a paper record. The regulation sorts the world into two buckets and only one of them is electronic.

What counts as an electronic record instead

If a PDF scan does not qualify, what does? The regulation's structure gives the answer in reverse. The exclusion covers hardcopy created or recorded on paper as well as hardcopy stored in a storage-only imaging system. So an electronic record has to go beyond storage.

The regulation's own history helps here. The CDTFA replaced the term "machine-sensible" with "electronic" across several subdivisions, including the definition of electronic format. Whether the term change reflected how records are now made is not stated in the amendment history.

A practical test you can run at your desk: can you search the file for a dollar amount, a date, or a vendor name and get a hit? Can you sort a thousand of these records by transaction date without opening each one? If the best you can do is open the file and read the page, you are looking at a PDF scan of hardcopy.

The regulation also lets a taxpayer create files solely for the use of the Board in conjunction with meeting certain requirements. That option exists for producing what an audit asks for. It does not convert your working copies of client paperwork into electronic records.

Where a PDF scan still has a role

None of this means you should stop scanning. Scanning solves a real problem: paper burns, floods, and gets misplaced. A PDF gives you a backup. It gives you a copy to email. It gives you a record you can find when a client calls about last year's filing.

The mistake is stopping there. When a scan is your only copy and a CDTFA reviewer asks for electronic records, you have nothing in the right category. The scan is a convenience copy. It is not the record the regulation means.

Treat every PDF you create as a companion to whatever the real record is — the original paper, or an electronic record generated by the system that made the transaction. Keep the PDF. Keep the original. Know which one you are handing over when someone asks.

What this means for your scanning workflow

Walk your current process end to end. At each step, ask one question: is this the record, or a picture of the record?

Most small firm workflows look the same. Mail arrives. Someone opens it. Someone scans it to PDF. The PDF gets named and filed. The paper gets shredded or boxed. At the moment the paper goes, the only thing left is a picture of a record — which the regulation still treats as hardcopy, and which does not meet the electronic record bar.

The fix is not complicated. It changes where paper stops and what you keep in the system.

Keep originals for records that matter. Sales tax returns, exemption certificates, and anything a client might need to produce in an audit stay as original paper or as an electronic record from the originating system. Box them. Index them. Store them.

Scan as a copy, not a replacement. Your PDF becomes the fast-lookup copy. The original becomes the record of record. Label files so your team knows the difference at a glance. A filename that says "scan — original on file" prevents an entire class of confusion.

Pull exports from the source. Ask the point-of-sale system, accounting package, or payment processor whether it can export transaction data in a structured format. On this post's reading, such an export is a stronger applicant for an electronic record than a scan. Make that export part of your standard package for any client with California sales tax exposure.

Check the system, not the file. Before you tell a client their records are electronic, look at the document management system itself. On this post's reading, if it only stores pictures of pages, it looks like a storage-only imaging system. The regulation names that category directly, and files inside it stay hardcopy no matter how tidy the folders are.

Ask the CDTFA which structured export formats clear the electronic record bar for a given client's records. Ask the CDTFA directly, or ask during the pre-audit conversation, before you commit a client's archive to one format.

Building a file that survives a CDTFA audit

An operations lead's job here is to make sure that when a reviewer asks a question, your team can answer it without a week of digging. That is a filing problem, not a legal problem.

Index everything. A pile of PDFs with generic scan filenames fails the moment someone needs the invoice from a specific transaction date. Every file you keep gets a client name, a transaction date, a document type, and a filing period. Regulation 1698 draws the line between electronic records and hardcopy records, and hardcopy stays hardcopy regardless of how neatly it is filed. Build that ability in from the start.

Separate the two categories physically. Original paper for California sales tax records lives in one place. Scanned PDFs live in another. Electronic records exported from source systems live in a third. When an audit request comes in, you know which drawer to open for which ask. Mixing the three into one folder is how a firm ends up handing over the wrong thing.

Note what you created for the Board. The regulation allows files created solely for the use of the Board alongside other compliance steps. If your team generates a special export or a specially formatted file for an audit, flag it in the file notes. Next time, you will know it exists and you will know why.

Do not shred on scan alone. This is the single most common failure at small firms. The scan feels like a completion. It is not. Until you have confirmed the record exists in an accepted form — original paper or true electronic record — the paper stays.

Run a spot check each quarter. Pick a random client. Pull one California filing period. Ask: can I produce the supporting records in the right category, quickly, without calling the client? If the answer is no, you have found a gap while it is cheap to fix.

Common mistakes we see at small firms

Mistake one: calling the scan the record. A PDF is a picture. The regulation sorts pictures into hardcopy. If your team uses the phrase "we have the record electronically" while pointing at a PDF, the language is wrong before the file is.

Mistake two: shredding the original after scanning. The scan does not replace the original for regulation purposes. Until you have an accepted form in hand, the original is the only record you have.

Mistake three: treating a document management system as magic. Putting PDFs in a system with search, tags, and folders does not change what the files are. The system can index a picture of a page. It cannot turn the picture into a record. The regulation's exclusion is about how the record was made and stored, not how nicely it sits in a folder.

Mistake four: skipping exports from the source system. The software that captured the transaction often has the best version of the record. Ask for the export. Ask the vendor whether one exists.

Mistake five: mixing work product with client records. General practitioner guidance from The Tax Adviser notes that most records a tax practitioner retains will generally not fall into a mandatory retention category, and that guidance focuses on work product and documentation records. Client sales tax records are a different animal. They belong to the client's compliance picture and they answer to the CDTFA regulation. Keep them in their own drawer.

A practical checklist before your next filing season

Run this list once, with your team, before the next California sales tax cycle starts. It takes an afternoon and it catches the problems that turn into audit headaches.

  1. List every document type you scan for California clients. Invoices, certificates, register tapes, returns. Write them down. This is your inventory.
  2. For each type, identify the original. Where does the record come from before anyone scans it? Paper in the mail? A system export? A photo? Name the source.
  3. Check which types have a true electronic version. Anything exported from the originating system likely qualifies. Anything born as paper and only ever scanned does not.
  4. Confirm originals are retained. For every type that lacks an electronic version, confirm the paper is boxed, indexed, and stored somewhere you can reach it.
  5. Fix filenames and folder structure. Every PDF gets client, date, type, and period in the name. Folder names match filing periods, not project code names.
  6. Ask your document management vendor one question. Can this system hold and retrieve structured exports, not just image files? If it cannot, you know where your electronic records will live instead.
  7. Write a one-page note for your team. State plainly which documents you treat as hardcopy, which as electronic, and where each lives. Tape it inside the operations binder.
  8. Dry-run an audit request. Pick a client, pick a period, and try to produce supporting records in the right category within the hour. Time yourself. Adjust the process where it dragged.

Frequently asked questions

Does scanning a sales tax document and emailing it to the client make it a record? No. Emailing a PDF moves the picture around. It does not change what the picture is. Under Regulation 1698, a PDF stays hardcopy regardless of how it travels. If the client needs a copy for their files, send it. Just do not call it the electronic record.

Our document management system has full-text search. Does that make the files electronic records? The regulation's exclusion turns on how the file was made and stored — as a picture of a page in a storage-only system. A system that searches pictures is still holding pictures. If you want to know whether a specific system's native format qualifies, ask the CDTFA directly before you reorganize a client's archive around it.

What if we keep both the paper original and the PDF? Keeping both is the safe posture. The original satisfies the hardcopy side. The PDF gives you a fast copy for lookup and sharing. The risk only appears when the paper is gone and the PDF is all you have.

Do microfilm and microfiche still come up at accounting firms? Rarely, but the regulation names them alongside PDFs for a reason: older client records may still exist on film, particularly at long-running businesses. If a client hands you film or fiche, treat it exactly as you would a PDF scan. It is storage-only imaging under the regulation.

Who do we ask when the regulation does not answer our situation? Ask the CDTFA. A direct question about a specific record type and a specific system gets a clearer answer than any general guide. Ask before you commit a client's archive, not after an audit request arrives.

What is the fastest fix if we have already shredded paper? Start capturing from the source. Request structured exports from whatever system generated the transactions going forward, and ask the client whether they hold originals for the periods you can no longer reconstruct. You cannot un-shred. You can stop the pattern and rebuild coverage from the source systems that still hold data.

General information, not legal or tax advice.

Sources