The IRS names seven groups of practitioners who are subject to Circular 230: attorneys, certified public accountants, enrolled agents, enrolled retirement plan agents, enrolled actuaries, Annual Filing Season Program Record of Completion holders who represent taxpayers, and appraisers engaged in appraising asset values for federal tax purposes. Covered individuals must not knowingly, directly or indirectly, take the prohibited actions the IRS lists, and for incompetence or disreputable conduct they may be disbarred, suspended or censured.
> Chief takeaways > - The IRS lists seven groups under Circular 230, so review each staff member's credential and the work they do on each engagement. > Two groups turn on activity: an Annual Filing Season Program holder must hold the Record of Completion and also represent taxpayers, while an appraiser is covered by appraising asset values for federal tax purposes alone. > - Covered individuals must not knowingly, directly or indirectly, take the prohibited actions, including notarial acts in conflicted matters and negotiating government checks issued to clients for federal tax liabilities. > - The sanctions named by the IRS are disbarment, suspension and censure, tied to incompetence or disreputable conduct.
Seven practitioner groups fall under Circular 230
The IRS publication that explains practice before the agency defines who is covered. According to IRS Publication 947, individuals subject to Circular 230 include any attorney, certified public accountant, enrolled agent, enrolled retirement plan agent, or enrolled actuary engaged in taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity. The same passage adds two more categories: any Annual Filing Season Program Record of Completion holder who represents taxpayers, and any appraiser engaged in appraising asset values for federal tax purposes.
That makes seven groups in total, and the first five share a single test. Each person in those groups is covered when they engage in taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity. The credential alone does not settle the question; the work they do does.
The other two groups are defined by their work as well. An Annual Filing Season Program holder is covered when representing taxpayers, and an appraiser is covered when appraising asset values for federal tax purposes. For a partner, this means a staff member can hold a qualifying credential and still fall outside the list on a particular engagement, while a person with no listed credential can fall inside it if they appraise asset values for a federal tax purpose.
Operations leads should not treat the list as a list of job titles. The rules are written for individuals, so the review has to happen person by person and matter by matter. A firm that checks only whether it employs CPAs would miss the appraisers and the Annual Filing Season Program holders on its roster, and it would also miss any staff member whose work, rather than title, brings them within the list.
Practitioner groups compared side by side
The seven groups share a common structure, but they are not identical. The table below compares them on the same measure: the activity that brings each group under Circular 230, as stated in IRS Publication 947.
| No. | Practitioner group | Activity that brings them under Circular 230 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Attorney | Taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity |
| 2 | Certified public accountant | Taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity |
| 3 | Enrolled agent | Taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity |
| 4 | Enrolled retirement plan agent | Taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity |
| 5 | Enrolled actuary | Taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity |
| 6 | Annual Filing Season Program Record of Completion holder | Representing taxpayers |
| 7 | Appraiser | Appraising asset values for federal tax purposes |
The table makes the pattern plain. Rows 1 through 5 use the same trigger, taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity, and they differ only in the credential held. Row 6 uses representation alone, without the advice-giving element, and row 7 is the only group defined by valuation work tied to federal tax purposes.
For a firm, this comparison suggests a practical record. Staff files should capture two facts for each person: the credential held and the activity performed on each engagement. A credential without matching activity does not place a person in the list for that engagement, and an activity without a listed credential can still do so under row 7. Keeping both facts side by side lets a partner decide quickly whether a given person falls within the rules before work begins.
Notary acts barred in conflicted matters
IRS Publication 947 says individuals subject to Circular 230 "may not take acknowledgments, administer oaths, certify papers, or perform any official act as a notary public" in certain matters. The restriction covers four kinds of act, and it applies to a practitioner who holds a notary commission. Holding the commission does not authorize the practitioner to use it in these settings.
Two conditions define the restricted setting. The first is that the matter is one "administered by the IRS." The second is that the practitioner is employed "as counsel, attorney, or agent" for that matter, or that the practitioner "may be in any way interested" in it. The second condition is broad. The phrase "in any way interested" covers any stake the practitioner has in the matter, not only the formal role of representative.
For a firm, the practical effect is that a staff notary working on a client's IRS matter should not notarize documents for that matter. The same restriction applies to a notary who has a personal or financial interest in the outcome. The rule reaches the notary's relationship to the matter, not only the signature on the page.
Operations leads can reduce the risk by checking notary commissions against the firm's list of open IRS matters before assigning documents. A notary who appears on a matter file in any role should be routed away from notarial work on that matter. A short written assignment rule, applied at intake, is enough to keep a staff member from acting in a restricted setting without realizing it.
Government checks that cannot be endorsed
The rule on checks is among the most concrete in the publication. IRS Publication 947 says individuals subject to Circular 230 "may not endorse or otherwise negotiate any check" issued to a client by the government in respect of a Federal tax liability. Two conditions apply: the check must be issued by the government to the client, and it must relate to a federal tax liability. Both must be present for the restriction to apply.
The rule also reaches the route the money takes. An electronic deposit into a firm-controlled account falls within the same restriction as a paper check endorsed at the front desk.
For operations leads, this means refund and payment workflows need a checkpoint. Any government payment tied to a client's federal tax liability should be identified before anyone endorses, negotiates or directs it.
Procedures should name who reviews incoming government payments and what the reviewer checks: the payer, the client, and the nature of the liability. Flagging these items early keeps the decision with someone who understands the rule, rather than leaving it to whoever opens the envelope.
Discipline for incompetence or disreputable conduct
IRS Publication 947 states that individuals subject to Circular 230 "may be disbarred or suspended from practice before the IRS, or censured, for incompetence or disreputable conduct." The sentence names three sanctions and two grounds. Each sanction is stated as one the IRS may impose, not one it must impose, because the word "may" makes the outcome discretionary.
The table below sets out the three sanctions side by side, using the same measures for each.
| Sanction | Applies to | Stated grounds |
|---|---|---|
| Disbarment from practice before the IRS | Individuals subject to Circular 230 | Incompetence or disreputable conduct |
| Suspension from practice before the IRS | Individuals subject to Circular 230 | Incompetence or disreputable conduct |
| Censure | Individuals subject to Circular 230 | Incompetence or disreputable conduct |
The table shows that the grounds are identical across all three sanctions. What differs is the consequence the text states. Disbarment and suspension are described as removals from practice before the IRS, while censure is listed without that phrase. The publication draws that distinction in its wording, and firms should read the sanctions with it in mind.
For a partner, the important point is that the sanctions attach to the individual. The sentence speaks of individuals subject to Circular 230, so a disbarment or suspension would affect that person's practice before the IRS. A firm's internal discipline, training and supervision should be designed with that individual exposure in view, because the publication does not assign the sanction to the firm.
Solicitation is cross-referenced to section 10.30.
Among the acts the IRS lists for covered individuals is "Soliciting employment by prohibited means as discussed in section 10.30 of Circular 230" ( IRS Publication 947). The publication does not restate section 10.30 in the material available here, so this post does not describe which methods are prohibited. What the publication does establish is that solicitation has its own cross-reference and sits on the same list as the notary, check and conduct rules discussed above.
For a firm, that cross-reference is the starting point for review. Before use, the firm should check whether section 10.30 applies to its marketing, referral and outreach activity. Operations leads should not assume that a practice acceptable in other professional settings is acceptable here. The rule is set by Circular 230, not by general business custom.
A simple control helps. Ask whoever prepares client outreach to record the channel, the intended audience and the person responsible for approval. A partner who is familiar with section 10.30 should review that record before anything is sent. Keep copies of the approved materials, with dates, so the firm can show what was used and when. The same log also shows staff that outreach is a reviewed activity, not a routine one.
Knowing conduct and the duty to check
The publication frames its prohibitions with a knowledge element. Individuals subject to Circular 230 "must not knowingly, directly or indirectly, do the following" ( IRS Publication 947). Two phrases carry the weight. "Knowingly" ties the prohibition to what a covered person knows. "Directly or indirectly" reaches conduct carried out through someone else, so arranging for a staff member, vendor or affiliated entity to do a prohibited act does not take it outside the rule.
This shapes how a firm should run its supervision. A covered person cannot rely on a gap in the paperwork if they know, or have been told, that a prohibited act is happening. When a staff member reports a question about a notary request, a government payment or a marketing plan, the report should reach someone who can decide it, and the decision should be written down.
Partners should also avoid building a process that keeps knowledge away from the people who must act on it. If intake forms, payment logs and engagement files are kept in separate systems that no one reviews together, the firm may create a situation where the people responsible do not know what the firm knows. Routing relevant facts to a single reviewer, who checks them against the list in the publication, is a practical way to meet the knowledge standard the text sets.
Engagement letter terms beyond the rules
The New York State Bar Association observes that "In addition to what is mandated by the rules, there are additional subjects that may be prudent for lawyers to include in their written engagement letter or agreement with the client" ( NYSBA). This is general guidance from a state bar association about lawyer engagement letters. It is not a statement of IRS requirements, and this post does not treat it as one. Its value for a firm is the distinction it draws between terms the rules require and additional terms that are prudent to include.
Applied to a Circular 230 practice, that distinction suggests a practical checklist. An engagement letter could identify the staff members who will work on a matter, and the credential and activity each holds, so that the firm's coverage decisions are visible from the start. It could also say whether a staff notary will be involved, and how government payments on the matter will be routed. These are firm choices rather than rules drawn from the quote, and the firm should confirm each one against the publication before relying on it.
The letter should also be kept consistent with the file. If the letter says one staff member will handle a matter and the intake record shows another, the partner should resolve the discrepancy before work begins. A partner who reviews the letter against the staffing record before work begins catches that gap early.
Key figures and dates from the rules
The counts are taken directly from IRS Publication 947.
| Figure | Value | Where it appears in the text |
|---|---|---|
| Practitioner groups named | 7 | Groups listed as covered individuals |
| Acts in the notary restriction | 4 | Acknowledgments, oaths, certifying papers, official acts |
| Sanctions named | 3 | Disbarment, suspension, censure |
| Grounds named for sanctions | 2 | Incompetence, disreputable conduct |
The second table shows how the seven groups divide by coverage trigger, which is the most useful breakdown for staffing decisions.
| Coverage trigger | Number of groups | Groups |
|---|---|---|
| Taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity | 5 | Attorney, CPA, enrolled agent, enrolled retirement plan agent, enrolled actuary |
| Representing taxpayers | 1 | Annual Filing Season Program Record of Completion holder |
| Appraising asset values for federal tax purposes | 1 | Appraiser |
The publication is dated 02/2018, as its title shows. Before relying on any figure, confirm that the IRS has not issued a newer version, because a dated publication may not reflect later changes.
Which one should you pick?
A firm building its staff review has two broad options for deciding who is covered. The choice matters because the list in IRS Publication 947 is defined by both credential and activity for some groups, and by activity alone for others.
| Option | What it checks | Fit with the list |
|---|---|---|
| A. Credential-only check | Whether each person holds a listed credential | Misses appraisers and does not test the representation activity for Annual Filing Season Program holders |
| B. Credential and activity for each engagement | The credential held, plus the taxpayer representation, advice-giving or appraisal work performed on each matter | Matches the activity-based coverage the list sets out |
Option B is the better choice for most firms. It takes a little more record-keeping, since each engagement needs a note of who did what, but it avoids the main failure of option A. A firm that checks only credentials can miss a non-CPA appraiser who is covered on a federal tax valuation, and it cannot show whether an Annual Filing Season Program holder is representing taxpayers on a given matter. A small matter record that names the person, the credential and the work performed closes that gap.
Option A still has a use as a first screen. Checking credentials at hiring tells a partner who might be covered. The matter-level check then confirms who is covered on each engagement. Partners should not treat a clean credential check as the end of the review.
Reader questions answered
Does the list cover every staff member at a CPA firm? No. Coverage depends on the credential and on the activity. The publication says covered individuals include CPAs engaged in "taxpayer representation or advice-giving activity," so the work matters as well as the title ( IRS Publication 947).
Can a staff member without a listed credential be covered? Yes, in one case. The list includes "any appraiser engaged in appraising asset values for federal tax purposes" ( IRS Publication 947). A staff member with no listed credential who does that work falls within the list for that engagement.
Can a staff notary notarize a client's IRS document? Not in every case. The publication says covered individuals may not perform notarial acts "with respect to any matter administered by the IRS and for which he or she is employed as counsel, attorney, or agent, or in which he or she may be in any way interested" ( IRS Publication 947). A notary on that matter should be routed away from notarial work on it.
Can the firm deposit a client's government tax refund into its own operating account? The publication says covered individuals may not endorse or negotiate a check issued by the government to a client in respect of a federal tax liability. Whether such a refund falls within that restriction depends on whether it is a government check issued in respect of a Federal tax liability; confirm before depositing it into the firm's operating account.
Can a covered person be sanctioned for an error? The publication ties the sanctions to "incompetence or disreputable conduct" and says individuals "may be disbarred or suspended from practice before the IRS, or censured" ( IRS Publication 947). The word "may" makes each sanction discretionary. The text does not define incompetence, so a firm should not assume that every mistake falls within it.
Does the rule apply to the firm itself? The sanction sentence speaks of individuals subject to Circular 230, so the firm's own exposure is not stated in this passage. The firm's obligations to its staff are a separate question that the quoted text does not answer.
Is the publication current? The publication is dated 02/2018 in its title. Confirm the current version on the IRS site before relying on any figure or cross-reference in this post ( IRS Publication 947).
Not legal or tax advice.