Under IRS Circular 230, a presumption that due diligence was exercised applies when you rely on another person's work, but only if reasonable care was used in engaging, supervising, training, and evaluating that person. A separate prerequisite sits alongside them: prove authority before anyone speaks for the client.
This post is written for partners and operations leads who review staff work. It shows how each step becomes something you can point to in the file.
The four steps the presumption depends on
Circular 230 sets the standards for people who practice before the Internal Revenue Service, and its due diligence duty is the starting point for anyone who signs off on work they did not personally produce. The IRS publication on practice before the IRS and powers of attorney states that individuals subject to Circular 230 must exercise due diligence when performing the following duties. Due diligence is judged by what you actually do. A reviewer who accepts a staff member's draft with no steps behind it has not shown the care the standard expects.
The same publication describes a route that matters for busy offices. A presumption that due diligence has been exercised applies when you rely on another person's work product, provided reasonable care was used in four activities: engaging, supervising, training, and evaluating that person. Each one is a step you can complete and record before the deliverable goes out.
The presumption is conditional. It does not say that relying on staff is automatically safe. It says that if you took reasonable care in those four areas, the reliance is presumed to meet due diligence. A reviewer who hires a preparer without checking, never explains the job, and releases the output unread has no basis for the presumption, however polished the final file looks.
The rule also asks you to take proper account of the nature of the relationship between you and the person doing the work. A salaried employee you train every week and an outside contractor engaged for one project stand in different relationships, so the care you take should differ. The operations lead decides how much supervision and evaluation each arrangement warrants, and then writes that decision down.
Step one: engage the person with a clear scope
The first step happens before any work begins. The presumption rests on reasonable care in engaging the person, and the engagement is where you define what that person is responsible for, what they may not do, and who signs off on the result.
Cost is one reason to be exact about scope. South Carolina's rule for lawyers on fees states that a lawyer should not exploit a fee arrangement based primarily on hourly charges by using wasteful procedures. That rule governs lawyers, but the lesson carries over to any office that bills staff time by the hour. When the scope is vague, work tends to pick up extra steps, repeated reviews, and drafts nobody needed. A written scope that names the deliverable and the review points keeps the hours tied to the job.
Paperwork matters as well. The New York State Bar Association's guidance on engagement agreements notes that there are also several rules in the New York Rules of Professional Conduct that apply to attorneys' engagement agreements. In New York, then, the engagement agreement sits under professional conduct rules as well as firm practice. A firm that brings in a paralegal, an outside preparer, or a contract reviewer for client work should treat those written terms with the same seriousness, because they define the work and become part of the file.
A clear scope covers four things: the task, the materials the person may use, the point at which the work returns to you, and the person accountable for the final product. Put these in a short written statement that the person acknowledges before starting. A verbal understanding leaves nothing to point to later, and the presumption is only as strong as what you can show you did.
Step two: check authority before anyone speaks for the client
The second step is proof of authority. It applies to the special-relationship individuals the publication lists when they represent a taxpayer before the IRS, except for the category in item (1). The publication explains that because of their special relationship with a taxpayer, the following individuals may represent the specified taxpayers before the IRS, provided they present satisfactory identification and, except in the case of an individual described in (1) below, proof of authority to represent the taxpayer.
That sentence contains two requirements. The first is identification: the person must present satisfactory identification. The second is proof of authority, which applies to everyone except the one category the publication labels item (1). Asking every representative for both items goes beyond the rule for an individual in item (1). One that waives the requirement because the person is familiar to the team takes the risk the rule exists to prevent.
The two routes differ in ways that matter at intake:
| Measure | Special-relationship representative | Form 8821 preparer |
|---|---|---|
| Who qualifies | Individuals with a special relationship with the taxpayer | Preparers who are unenrolled and do not meet the limited representation requirements |
| What it allows | Representing the taxpayer before the IRS | Inspecting and/or requesting the taxpayer's tax information |
| Paperwork | Satisfactory identification and proof of authority, with one exception | Form 8821 submission |
Keep copies of the identification and proof of authority in the client file, linked to the engagement from step one. If the proof lives only in a staff member's inbox, the reviewer cannot show it when the file is examined.
Not everyone who handles a client's tax matter can represent the taxpayer, and a narrower authorization exists for preparers who do not qualify for representation. The publication explains that if an unenrolled return preparer does not meet the requirements for limited representation, you may authorize the unenrolled return preparer to inspect and/or request your tax information by filing Form 8821. That authority is narrower than representation. It lets the preparer inspect or request tax information, and the provision says nothing about speaking for the taxpayer before the IRS. The first intake question is therefore which route the person is on, since the paperwork and the permitted activity both follow from that answer.
Consider a staff preparer who needs prior-year information to finish a client's return. If that preparer does not meet the limited representation requirements, a Form 8821 filing supports access to the information. If the same preparer later needs to deal with an IRS representative for the client, the question becomes whether the special relationship applies and whether identification and proof of authority are already in the file. Record which route applies in the engagement file, because mixing the two in one matter causes confusion later.
The exception in the representation rule also needs a decision at intake. The reviewer should identify whether the person falls into item (1) before requesting documents, so the request is neither excessive nor missing anything the rule requires.
Step three: supervise and train the people doing the work
The third step is supervision and training. The presumption applies only where reasonable care was used in supervising and training the person whose work you rely on. The IRS publication places those activities beside engaging and evaluating, so they cannot be treated as optional extras. Relying on a draft from someone who has never been shown the firm's standards is hard to defend.
Supervision means a named reviewer knows the work is in progress, sees drafts at agreed points, and can stop a job early if it goes wrong. Training means the person has been shown the firm's standards for the specific work before handling it alone: which filings they may handle, which sources to use, and which situations must go back to a reviewer. The rule asks for reasonable care rather than a prescribed format. The presumption language requires proper account of the nature of the relationship between the person relying and the person doing the work.
The publication also addresses who may assist, and it warns against accepting assistance from any former government employee where provisions of Circular 230 or any federal law would be violated. Treat that as a reminder to check conflicts before work starts. A hiring or engagement screen should ask whether a person's prior government role raises a Circular 230 or federal law issue before that person touches client files. Record the answer, since a reviewer who never asked cannot later show reasonable care in engaging the person.
Training records do not need to be elaborate. A dated list of what the person was shown, who showed it, and what the person was cleared to do is enough to show that training happened before the person worked alone on client matters.
Step four: evaluate the work before it leaves the office
The fourth step is evaluation. The presumption depends on reasonable care in evaluating the person, and the review before release is where errors get caught before they reach a client or the IRS. Evaluation is the step most often reduced to a quick glance, which is why it needs a defined method.
Evaluation means reading the output against the scope fixed in step one, the materials the person was cleared to use, and the standards covered in training. It also means confirming that the authority from step two is on file for anyone who will speak for the client. A reviewer who signs the final work is relying on the staff member's output, and the same reasonable-care standard applies to that reliance.
The four activities line up with the rule's wording as follows:
| Activity | Wording in the presumption |
|---|---|
| Engaging the person | Reasonable care in engaging the person |
| Supervising the person | Reasonable care in supervising the person |
| Training the person | Reasonable care in training the person |
| Evaluating the person | Reasonable care in evaluating the person |
Evaluation should be recorded as a decision, not an impression. The reviewer's note should say what was checked, what was changed, and whether the work was released. A signed page with no content gives the file little to show. A short dated note that names the checks performed shows the evaluation actually happened.
Keeping review on schedule without unreasonable delay
Staff work sitting in a review queue is not neutral. A draft waiting for a reviewer can hold up a client's filing, a response to an IRS notice, or a payment decision. The IRS publication addresses this directly: individuals subject to Circular 230 must not unreasonably delay the prompt disposition of any matter before the IRS. It asks the responsible person to move matters along promptly and to avoid holding them without reason.
For an operations lead, scheduling becomes a compliance question. If the reviewer is the bottleneck, the delay belongs to the firm, not to the staff member who finished on time. Set review dates when the engagement is written in step one, so the reviewer knows when work is due and the client knows when to expect it. When a review slips, record why: the draft needed more information, the reviewer was out, or the issue required research. A dated note of the cause shows the delay was managed rather than ignored.
Delay runs the other way too. Staff may hold a draft because they are unsure it is ready, and that hesitation can push a matter past the point where it helps the client. Set a clear rule for when a draft goes back for changes and when it moves forward. A question raised early is better than a file that stalls quietly.
Build the prompt-disposition duty into the same calendar that tracks client deadlines, and review that calendar at regular intervals. A matter that has been open for a long time with no recorded reason is the gap a reviewer should be able to explain.
Choosing the right route for each person
Start with what the person needs to do, because that decides which option applies. The publication describes two routes for a staff member involved in a client's tax matter: representation by a person with a special relationship with the taxpayer, or a Form 8821 authorization for an unenrolled return preparer who does not meet the limited representation requirements. Internal work with no authority to speak for the client sits outside both routes.
| Option | Who it fits | What it permits | What the file needs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Representation | An individual with a special relationship with the taxpayer | Representing the taxpayer before the IRS | Satisfactory identification, plus proof of authority except for the category in item (1) |
| Form 8821 authorization | Preparers who are unenrolled and do not meet the limited representation requirements | Inspecting and/or requesting the taxpayer's tax information | The Form 8821 filing |
| Internal work only | Staff who support the work but do not deal with the IRS for the client | Work inside the firm within the engagement's scope | The written engagement from step one |
Read the table as a sequence of questions. First, does the task require speaking for the client before the IRS? If so, and the person has a special relationship with the taxpayer, the representation route covers that activity: identification must be in place, and proof of authority must be in place unless the person falls in item (1). If the person does not qualify, arrange a qualifying representative or a different route instead. Second, if the task is limited to seeing or requesting tax information, and the preparer does not meet the limited representation requirements, Form 8821 is the fit. Third, if neither applies, keep the person on internal work under the engagement.
Write the choice into the engagement file and revisit it when the task changes. A preparer who starts on internal work and is later asked to contact the IRS has moved into a different option. The file should show when that change happened and what paperwork followed it.
Documenting each step so the file shows reasonable care
The presumption applies to reliance on another person's work product when reasonable care was used, and a written file is a practical way to evidence that the care was used. The file itself should carry the evidence, so a partner or examiner can follow the sequence without anyone reconstructing it from memory.
| Step | What the file should show |
|---|---|
| Engagement | The written scope, the materials allowed, the return point, and the accountable reviewer, with the person's acknowledgment |
| Authority | Satisfactory identification and proof of authority, or the Form 8821 filing for a preparer on that route |
| Supervision and training | Dated notes of what the person was shown, who showed it, and what the person was cleared to do |
| Evaluation | A dated reviewer note recording what was checked, what changed, and whether the work was released |
| Handoffs | A note at each transfer naming the sender, the receiver, the scope, what was checked, and what remains open |
Each row in the table is evidence for one of those activities, plus the handoffs that connect them.
Keep the records in one matter file, arranged in the order of the steps. Use one consistent form of record for every engagement. When a record is created after the fact, label it as created later and give the actual date. A file that looks assembled at the time of the work, when it was not, undermines the care it is meant to prove.
Due diligence at each handoff
Staff work usually changes hands several times before it reaches a client or the IRS. Intake passes the file to a preparer, the preparer passes it to a reviewer, and the reviewer passes the result to the client or to someone who will speak to the IRS. Each transfer is a point where a duty can slip, so each deserves a check. The due diligence duties listed in the IRS publication set the baseline, and the firm's handoff checklist should be built from that list rather than from memory.
Think of a handoff as the moment responsibility moves. At intake, the question is whether the scope and the authority are in place. At the preparer stage, the question is whether the person was engaged, supervised, and trained as the presumption requires. At the reviewer stage, the question is whether the output was evaluated against the scope before it moved on. At release, the question is whether the person signing the work has exercised due diligence across the listed duties, not merely on the parts of the file that were easy to check.
A short handoff note makes this concrete. It names who sent the work, who received it, what the scope was, what was checked, and what remains open. The receiver signs or initials it, and the note becomes the record that the duty was performed at that stage.
Handoffs also happen outside the firm. If a file goes to an outside preparer or comes back from one, the same questions apply. Reliance on that person is still reliance on another person's work product, and the presumption depends on reasonable care in engaging, supervising, training, and evaluating the outside person.
Not legal or tax advice.