Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

3 fee items to state in writing when an engagement starts

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read

Put three fee items in writing when an engagement starts: the rate, the expenses the client pays, and what happens to advance or non-cash payments. A partner quotes a number on a call, an operations lead copies it into an engagement letter, and months later nobody can say whether the rate covered the research memo, whether travel was billable, or whether a deposit could come back.

Key takeaways

  • Write the billing method, role rates, and billing increments into the letter before work starts.
  • List each expense the client pays, with approval rules, and say those costs are owed whatever the outcome.
  • Spell out how deposits are held and returned, and whether non-cash payment is accepted.
  • Set a written process for rate and scope changes.

This post covers those three items: the basis or rate of the fee, the expenses the client will pay, and what happens to money paid early or paid in something other than cash. The examples come from professional conduct rules in three states, Utah, South Carolina, and Pennsylvania. Those rules are written for lawyers, so the wording is legal, but the drafting problems are the same for consultants, accountants, and other firms that quote fees for new client work. Treat the quotes as a checklist of questions to take to your own rules and your own risk reviewer.

Item one: the basis or rate of the fee

Start with the most basic term, which is how the fee is calculated. The Utah rule says that the scope of the representation and "the basis or rate of the fee and expenses for which the client will be responsible" should be communicated "preferably in writing, before or within a reasonable time after commencing the representation" ( Utah Courts, SCRP Rule 3-1.05). The same rule carves out a regularly represented client who will be charged on the same basis or rate. That carve-out is why a long-standing client may not need a fresh statement, and a new client does.

Pennsylvania's rule describes the same gap from the other side. When a lawyer has regularly represented a client, "they ordinarily will have evolved an understanding concerning the basis or rate of the fee" ( Pennsylvania Code & Bulletin, 204 Pa. Code Rule 1.5). A new client has no shared history with the firm. The understanding is best built on paper, because nobody can assume the client remembers what was said on the first call. A verbal quote may have been clear to the person who gave it and still leave the client with a different picture of what they agreed to pay.

For most engagements, the letter should state at least four things:

  • The billing method, such as hourly, fixed fee, retainer, or a mix of these.
  • The rate for each role that will work on the matter. One blended number hides who does what and makes later questions harder to answer.
  • Billing increments and how time is recorded, so the client can read a line item and know what it means.
  • For a fixed fee, what it covers and what would start a new quote. A fixed fee that does not say what it excludes will be read as covering everything.

The letter should also say how changes will be handled. The Utah rule is direct: "Any changes in the basis or rate of the fee or expenses shall also be communicated to the client" ( Utah Courts, SCRP Rule 3-1.05). Decide now how and when a rate change reaches the client, such as a written notice that goes out before the first invoice using the new rate.

Fee size belongs in this item too. The Pennsylvania text describes a total fee that is "not illegal or clearly excessive" for the legal services rendered ( Pennsylvania Code & Bulletin, 204 Pa. Code Rule 1.5). Section four returns to that point, because the check should happen before the letter goes out, not after the client objects.

Item two: the expenses the client will pay

Expenses are where letters tend to go vague. The Utah rule is blunt about it: "The agreement must clearly notify the client of any expenses for which the client will be liable whether or not the client is the prevailing party" ( Utah Courts, SCRP Rule 3-1.05). The phrase "prevailing party" comes from litigation, where cost shifting depends on who wins. The drafting lesson applies to any engagement. The letter should list which costs the client bears, and it should say that those costs are owed no matter how the matter turns out.

Put names to the categories. Common pass-through costs include:

  • Filing, registration, or government fees.
  • Travel, lodging, and meals, with the approval rules for each stated.
  • Outside vendors such as experts, couriers, translators, or data providers.
  • Copying, printing, and research database charges, if the firm bills them at all.

For each category, the letter should answer three questions. Is the cost billed at actual cost or with a markup? Does the firm need the client's approval before the cost is incurred, and above what amount? When is it invoiced? You choose the answers. What matters is that the client reads them before work starts, not after a vendor invoice arrives in the middle of the matter.

Vague expense wording also creates a second problem, which is a mismatch between what the client expects and what the team actually does. Some firms absorb small costs as overhead, while others pass every line through. The trouble starts when one side assumes the other. If the firm absorbs routine copying and postage, say so. A sentence such as "routine copying and postage are included in our rates" settles the question in advance.

Item three: refunds, advance payments, and property

The third item covers money that moves before the work is finished, and money that is not cash. Here the sources are especially useful, because they address all three cases.

Start with refunds. The South Carolina rule states that the client may be entitled to "a refund of all or a portion of the fee if the agreed-upon legal services are not provided" ( South Carolina Judicial Branch, Rule 1.5). The letter should say what that refund looks like in your engagement, such as how work already done is valued if the matter stops early. Leaving the client to guess is the weak point, because the first time the question comes up, both sides will remember the arrangement differently.

Advance payments come next. The South Carolina comment on terms of payment says a lawyer "may require advance payment of a fee, but is obliged to return any unearned portion" ( South Carolina Judicial Branch, Rule 1.5). If you take a retainer or deposit, the letter should say how the money is held, what it is applied to, and how any unused balance comes back. Calling a deposit "nonrefundable" in a conversation and leaving it out of the letter is exactly the kind of gap that produces a dispute at the end of a matter.

Fixed fees raise a separate concern. Pennsylvania's rule says that "An agreement may not be made whose terms might induce the lawyer improperly to curtail services for the client or perform them in a way contrary to the client's interest" ( Pennsylvania Code & Bulletin, 204 Pa. Code Rule 1.5). For a fixed fee, that is the test to apply. If the number is so tight that the natural pressure is to cut scope or hurry, the terms are a problem even when the client has agreed to them. The letter should also say what happens when scope grows, so the team is not tempted to absorb extra work quietly and resent it later.

Non-cash payment is the last case. If the firm will accept shares, equity, or other property, the Utah rule notes that a fee paid in property "may be subject to the requirements of Rule 1.8(a) because such fees often have the essential qualities of a business transaction with the client" ( Utah Courts, SCRP Rule 3-1.05). The South Carolina comment is similar and gives the example of "an ownership interest in an enterprise" ( South Carolina Judicial Branch, Rule 1.5). The practical step is to decide whether non-cash payment is on the table at all. If it is, the letter should not treat it as an ordinary invoice. It should send the arrangement for separate review before anyone signs.

The three items side by side:

Fee item What the letter should stateWhat the quoted rules point toWhen to revisit
Basis or rate Billing method, rates by role, increments, invoice timing, fixed-fee scopeUtah: basis or rate communicated, preferably in writing, at the start; Pennsylvania: regularly represented clients ordinarily already have an understanding of the fee, so written terms matter most for new clients Any change in rate or billing method
ExpensesWhich costs pass through, any markup, approval rules, billing regardless of outcome Utah: expenses the client will be liable for must be clearly stated, whether or not the client prevails A new type of vendor or a new travel pattern
Refunds, advances, property Refund basis, how deposits are held and applied, whether non-cash payment is accepted at all South Carolina: possible refund if services are not provided, unearned advance returned; Pennsylvania: terms must not induce curtailed services; Utah: property fee may fall under Rule 1.8(a) A scope change, or any offer to pay in property

Check the fee before it goes out

A letter is only as accurate as the numbers behind it. For the intake side, see the Accounting Client Intake Checklist for a Clear Handoff. Before anything goes to the client, have someone other than the author check the fee terms against the firm's current rate card and billing setup. The operations lead is usually the right person, because they know what the billing system will actually do and where the rate tables live.

Check for contradictions next. The proposal email, the quote, and the engagement letter often get written at different times by different people. If the email says the work is "all-inclusive" and the letter lists four categories of expenses, the client can reasonably rely on the email. Pick one version as the source of truth, and make the others match it or point to it. A short note that the letter controls in case of conflict is a reasonable backstop, but it works best when the documents already agree.

Check the overall fee against the work. The Pennsylvania wording, that a total fee should not be "clearly excessive" for the services rendered, is a useful test even outside that state, because it asks a question partners rarely ask out loud: does this number fit this scope? If the number and the scope pull in opposite directions, fix the scope description or the number before the client signs.

Check the expense and refund sections against actual practice. If the firm does not bill for copying, do not write that it does. If the firm can return part of a deposit, say so and say how the amount is calculated. An accurate but plain letter is more useful than a polished one that promises what the billing team will not deliver. The first invoice is where a mismatch becomes visible, and by then the client has already decided how much to trust the firm.

Finally, check who can approve exceptions. A partner may agree on a call to waive a markup or extend a fixed fee to cover a small change. That agreement should be recorded and reflected in the letter or in a short follow-up, or it will be forgotten by the time the first invoice goes out. Write down who has authority to change the terms, so that a helpful concession does not quietly become a precedent for the next client.

Update the letter when the terms change

A matter that began as a contract review may grow into litigation support, and the rate and expense rules for that work may be different. The Utah rule's requirement that changes be communicated applies here just as it did at the start, so the update should never be an informal message passed along in a hallway or a quick chat thread.

Use a short written amendment or change notice. It should name the matter, state what changed, give the new terms, and say when they take effect. Ask the client to acknowledge it in writing. Keep the signed original and each amendment together in the matter file, so anyone who opens the file later can see which terms were in force at each point in the work. That record is what settles a dispute quickly, and it is also what protects the team when a new person picks up the matter in the middle.

Decide who owns the update. In many firms the partner decides the terms and the operations lead records them, and that split should be explicit. When a change is entered in the billing system but never reaches the client's letter, the invoice and the letter disagree, and the client will notice before the team does. The same is true in reverse, where the letter is amended and the billing rate is not. Check both after every change.

Deposits need attention as well. If the scope changes, an advance may need to be reapplied, topped up, or partly returned. If your letter already explains how the deposit works, the amendment can simply point to that section. If it does not, the amendment has to explain the mechanics from scratch, which is harder to do cleanly while the client is waiting for an answer.

Put the first letter in order

The order of the letter matters, because clients tend to read the top of a document more carefully than the bottom. A workable order for the fee portion looks like this:

  1. The scope of the work, stated in a few sentences that give the fee a clear subject.
  2. The billing method and rates, with the role list and billing increments.
  3. The expenses, with the approval rules and the invoicing timing.
  4. Deposits, refunds, and how unused money is returned.
  5. The change process, including how rate changes and scope changes are communicated.
  6. Any non-cash payment terms, or a plain statement that the firm does not accept them.
  7. Signature lines and the date the terms take effect.

Scope comes first because a fee is only meaningful against a defined piece of work. A fee with no scope is an open invitation to argue about what it covered, and every later section of the letter depends on that definition being clear. Put the scope in plain terms, and avoid a long list of exclusions buried in a footnote.

Use plain language throughout. Avoid defined terms the client has to look up, and read the fee section aloud once before it goes out. If a sentence can be read two ways, the client will find the reading that suits them, so rewrite it until only one reading is possible.

Use these examples with your own rules

The quotes in this post come from Utah, South Carolina, and Pennsylvania, and each state's rule has its own wording, comments, and exceptions. Nothing here says what your state or your profession requires. Read the current text of your own rules, check whether your regulator or professional body has added guidance, and have a reviewer look at the letter before it is sent. Those checks are small compared with the cost of a fee dispute that starts with a sentence nobody wrote down.

Next step: pull your latest engagement letter and check that it states all three items above.

Related guides: Bank feed checks: 8 items for client reconciliation · Entity classification: 8 client intake items.

Frequently asked questions

Do regular clients need a new letter?

Not necessarily: the Utah rule makes an exception for a regularly represented client who will be charged on the same basis or rate.

What should a deposit clause say?

It should say how the money is held, what it is applied to, and how any unused balance comes back, because the South Carolina comment requires return of any unearned portion.

Sources