Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

3 tests for a former-client conflict before an engagement

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 14 min read

Before you take a new engagement, run it against your firm's past-client file. This guide gives you three tests, in plain wording, drawn from official rules you can link and show a partner.

The stakes are simple. Once a client leaves, your duties do not end at the final invoice. A former client can still come back and say your new work hurts them. If they win that argument, the new engagement stops. You have wasted partner time, lost the fee, and damaged two relationships at once.

Three tests will catch most problems before the engagement letter is signed. Test one asks whether the new matter is the same as, or substantially related to, the old one. Test two asks whether your new client's interests are materially adverse to the old client's interests. Test three asks whether anyone at your firm holds information that would give the new client an unfair edge, or whether the lawyer who did the old work can be walled off.

These tests come from the professional-conduct rules used in the jurisdictions whose texts are linked below. The wording differs a little between states. A partner who can explain these three tests in a meeting can defend the decision to take, or to turn down, the work.

How to read the rules behind these tests

The core former-client duty sits in Rule 1.9 of the professional-conduct rules. The District of Columbia's version states the rule directly: a lawyer who has formerly represented a client in a matter shall not thereafter represent another person in the same or a substantially related matter in which that person's interests are materially adverse to the interests of the former client unless the former client gives informed consent. You can read the full text on the D.C. Bar's page on Conflict of Interest: Former Client.

The same page carries a comment noting that Rule 1.9 is intended to incorporate District of Columbia and federal case law defining the "substantial relationship" test. That sentence matters. It tells you the test is not just the words on the page.

The same D.C. page states that the question of whether a lawyer is personally disqualified from representation in any matter on account of successive government and private employment is governed by Rule 1.11 rather than by Rule 1.9. That is a carve-out for lawyers who move between government service and private practice. If you are screening a lateral hire from a regulator, look at the government-transition rules, not the ordinary former-client test.

Pennsylvania has its own version of Rule 1.9, published in the Pennsylvania Code, Rule 1.9, Duties to Former Clients. Where Pennsylvania's text adds a definition, we use it below and say so.

Nevada publishes its rules through the Nevada Legislature's page on the Nevada Rules of Professional Conduct. Its text on imputed disqualification states that "1.10 is inapplicable to a representation governed by this Rule." That is a Nevada-specific carve-out.

The first test asks whether the new engagement is the same matter as something you did before, or whether it is substantially related to it. Pennsylvania's Rule 1.9 gives the cleanest published definition: matters are "substantially related" for purposes of this Rule if they involve the same transaction or legal dispute or if there otherwise is a substantial risk that confidential factual information as would normally have been obtained in the prior representation would materially advance the client's position in the subsequent matter. That wording is in Rule 1.9 in the Pennsylvania Code.

Break that definition into two paths. Path one: the same transaction or dispute. Path two: a risk that what you learned in the old job would materially advance the new client's position.

For an accounting firm, path one is usually obvious. You prepared a set of accounts, or ran a diligence scope, or audited a fund. The new client is on the other side of that same deal, that same dispute, or that same set of accounts. Same transaction. The test is met.

Path two is where firms get caught. Consider a mid-year review you did for a private company two years ago. You are now asked to sign off on the buyer's quality-of-earnings report in that company's sale. The documents are different, the deliverable is different, but what you learned about revenue recognition, customer concentration, and add-backs sits in your head. That is a risk that the prior representation's confidential facts would materially advance the new client's position.

The D.C. comment adds a practical wrinkle: the lawyer's involvement in a matter can also be a question of degree. A partner who signed the report sits closer to the work than a junior who pulled a sample. The closer the involvement, the easier it is to argue a direct link.

When you run test one, ask three questions of the file, and write the answers down:

  • What was the old engagement? Name the client, the period, and the deliverable. If you cannot find the engagement letter, find the last invoice.
  • What is the new engagement? Name the new client, the subject, and what they will do with your work.
  • What did the old team know that helps the new client? Be specific. Transaction structure, working-capital adjustments, related-party balances, and management representations are common items in accounting files.

If the answer to the third question is "nothing they could not get from public records," you are in weaker territory for a finding of substantial relation. If the answer is "a whole binder of management's private numbers," you are in stronger territory against taking the work.

Test two: are the new client's interests materially adverse to the former client's

The second test asks whether your new client's interests are materially adverse to the former client's interests.

"Materially adverse" is doing real work in that sentence. A new client who wants the same thing as the old client is not adverse at all. Two buyers bidding on the same asset are adverse. A seller and a buyer are adverse. A creditor and a debtor in a workout are adverse.

Run this test by asking what the new client wants to happen and what the old client wants to happen. Write both in one line each. If the two lines point in opposite directions on the same subject, you are materially adverse.

Common pairings an accounting firm sees:

  • You did the seller's quality-of-earnings. Now the buyer's lender asks you to review it.
  • You audited a fund. Now an investor in that fund wants you to support a redemption claim against the manager.
  • You advised a company on its bank covenant package. Now the bank asks you to assess whether the company complied.

Each of these is a live adversity on the same subject matter as your old file. The first and third pairings also trip test one. A pairing can fail both tests at once, and that is normal.

Consent is the exit door. The D.C. rule allows the new representation if the former client gives informed consent. For a small firm, that means a signed letter from the former client, kept with the file, not an email thread with an ambiguous "sounds fine."

A further note for firms that take on government-adjacent work: the D.C. comment says the successive government-and-private-employment question is governed by Rule 1.11 rather than Rule 1.9. Ask which rule applies before you start the screen.

Test three: does anyone at the firm hold protected information from the old file

The third test asks whether anyone at your firm holds confidential information from the old file that would harm the old client if used for the new one. You can read that wording in Pennsylvania's Rule 1.9.

Actual knowledge is the trigger. A lawyer who ran the fieldwork, or who read the file during a quality review, does.

The firm-level question is different from the individual question. When one lawyer at the firm is conflicted, can the rest of the firm still act? The D.C. imputed-disqualification comment gives a conditional yes: where an individual lawyer could not effectively represent a given client because of an interest described in the conflict rule, but that lawyer will do no work on the matter and the disqualifying interest will not adversely affect the representation by others in the firm, the firm should not be disqualified. Read it in full on the D.C. Bar's Imputed Disqualification: General Rule page.

The D.C. page also notes that this aspect of the problem is governed by the principles of the former-client rule. In other words, the same substantive test applies to the individual, and the imputation question is separate.

Pennsylvania points to its own screening provisions: see Rule 1.10(b) for the restrictions on a firm once a lawyer becomes associated with a firm, including screening provisions. That is the page where Pennsylvania's firm-level machinery lives.

Here is a compact view of how the three tests work together before an engagement.

TestCore questionKey source
One: substantial relation Is the new matter the same, or does it carry a real risk the old file's facts help the new client?Pennsylvania Rule 1.9
Two: material adversity Do the new client's interests run against the former client's on the same subject?D.C. Conflict of Interest: Former Client
Three: information and screening Does anyone at the firm have actual knowledge from the old file, and can that person be walled off?D.C. Imputed Disqualification

Running the three tests on a live opportunity

Take a live opportunity and walk it through. A buyer's lender sends you a draft quality-of-earnings report prepared by another firm. The lender asks you to review it before funding. Your firm did the seller's quality-of-earnings eighteen months ago.

Test one: is the new matter substantially related to the old one? Yes. Same transaction. The same periods, the same add-backs, the same customer lists. Same transaction, full stop.

Test two: are the interests materially adverse? Yes. The seller wanted the highest supported number. The buyer's lender wants a defensible number before it funds. A higher number benefits one side; a lower number benefits the other. The two lines point opposite ways on the same subject.

Test three: does anyone at the firm hold protected information from the old file? Almost certainly. Your partner signed the report. Your manager ran the fieldwork. Their actual knowledge of the seller's private numbers is what makes the new assignment dangerous. A screen only helps if the partner and manager do no work on the new job and their knowledge does not reach the others.

Now change one fact. The buyer's lender asks you to review a report on a different target company, one you have never touched. Test one fails, because there is no prior matter and no substantial risk. Test three fails for the same reason.

The point of writing this out is that the three tests are a sequence. If test one says "not related," the engagement is clear. If test one says "related," you go to test two. If test two says "not adverse," you are clear. If test two says "adverse," you go to test three. Test three tells you whether you can proceed with a screen or whether you must decline.

Documenting the screen when one lawyer is walled off

If test three says one lawyer has actual knowledge and the rest of the firm does not, the screen is your path forward in jurisdictions that allow it. The D.C. comment gives the conditions: the conflicted lawyer does no work on the new matter, and the disqualifying interest does not adversely affect the representation by others in the firm.

Build the screen as a file, not a promise. The file should hold four items:

  • Screen notice. A short memo, dated, naming the conflicted lawyer and the matter they are walled off from.
  • Access log. A record showing the conflicted lawyer has no access to the new engagement's workpapers or workspace.
  • Team list. The names of everyone on the new engagement, with a line confirming none of them read the old file.
  • Informed-consent letters, if any. Signed letters from any former client who was asked to consent, kept with the engagement file.

Pennsylvania points readers to its own screening provisions in Rule 1.10(b) for the restrictions on a firm once a lawyer becomes associated with a firm. If your screen involves a lateral hire rather than a conflict inside an existing team, read that section alongside Rule 1.9.

The D.C. comment conditions the firm's freedom on the lawyer doing no work on the matter. A partner who signs the report is doing work on the matter.

The D.C. rule allows the new representation if the former client gives informed consent. An email saying "no objection" without a description of what is being objected to is thin.

A consent letter for this purpose should contain:

  • The old matter. What we did for you, and when.
  • The new matter. What we are being asked to do now, and for whom.
  • The risk. What we learned in the old matter that could be used, or seen to be used, in the new one.
  • Your choice. A statement that you may decline to consent and we will respect that.

Consent from the former client closes tests one and two together. Read the two rules together before you rely on a consent letter to carry the whole decision.

Whether consent can cure a screen-related problem, or a screen can substitute for consent, is not settled in the texts linked here. Ask your state's bar ethics hotline or your firm's outside ethics counsel before you take that step.

Questions a partner should ask in the screening meeting

Sit down with the partner who wants the work and ask these, out loud:

  • What did we do for the old client, and what was our deliverable?
  • Is the new client on the other side of that same deal, dispute, or set of accounts?
  • What does the new client want that the old client does not want?
  • Which people on our team touched the old file, and what do they remember?
  • Can the people who touched the old file be fully walled off from the new work?
  • Has the former client been asked to consent, and do we have a signed letter?
  • Which state's rules govern this engagement, and are we reading the right version?

That last question matters more than firms admit. If the engagement spans two states, ask which bar's rules apply to each piece of the work, and read both.

When the screen is not enough

A screen is not a universal fix. Three situations usually end in a decline rather than a screen.

First, the conflicted lawyer is the only person at the firm with the skill to do the new work. If they must do the work, the D.C. condition fails, because they would be doing work on the matter.

Second, the new matter is the same transaction as the old one, and both clients expect you to act as a neutral. A firm that valued a business for the seller cannot be hired to value the same business for the buyer on the theory that a screen protects the seller. The same-transaction path of the Pennsylvania definition is built for exactly this.

Third, the former client has not been told and would reasonably object. If you find yourself hoping the former client never finds out, decline.

A one-page screening checklist for your next engagement

Print this and run it on every new opportunity that touches a past client:

  1. Name the old client, the old deliverable, and the old period.
  2. Name the new client, the new deliverable, and the new period.
  3. State in one sentence whether the new matter is the same transaction or dispute as the old one.
  4. State in one sentence whether there is a real risk the old file's private facts would help the new client.
  5. State in one sentence how the new client's interests run against the former client's on the same subject.
  6. List every person at the firm who touched the old file, and what they actually know.
  7. Decide: proceed clean, proceed with a screen, request informed consent, or decline.
  8. File the decision memo with the engagement letter, dated, with the partner's name on it.

Keep the memo even when you decline. If the former client later asks why you turned the work down, the memo is your answer.

Frequently asked questions

Does this rule apply to my firm if I am not a law firm? The texts linked here are professional-conduct rules for lawyers. The exact wording that binds your firm depends on the body that oversees it. Ask your regulator or your professional-body contact which text governs you, and read that one.

What if the old engagement was years ago? Time does not close the test by itself. The Pennsylvania definition turns on the risk that facts from the old representation would materially advance the new client's position. If those facts are still useful, the age of the file does not help you. If the facts have become public, the risk falls, and you should say so in the memo.

Can I rely on a screen if the partner who did the old work is also the relationship partner on the new one? No. The D.C. comment conditions the firm's freedom on the conflicted lawyer doing no work on the matter. A relationship partner signs things. That is work.

Does consent from the old client let me do anything? Consent lets you proceed where the obstacle is the former client's own objection. Read the rule that applies in your state before you rely on it.

Where do I find the rule for my state? The pages linked above are the D.C., Pennsylvania, and Nevada texts, which are the ones this guide draws on. If your state is not one of those, find your state's version of the former-client rule and read it against these three tests.

Sources