Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

2 mid-engagement changes that create a client conflict

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 14 min read

A conflict can appear after the work has started

A mid-engagement conflict is a conflict that surfaces after a firm has already accepted work for a client. It usually comes from a change in the client's ownership or connections, or from a change in someone on the team who works on the file.

Key takeaways:

  • Re-run the conflict check when a client's ownership, parent company, or major affiliates change.
  • Ask staff about outside roles at onboarding and whenever their roles change.
  • Treat "not sure" as a flag for review, not as a clear result.
  • Pause affected work while a possible conflict is reviewed, then get jurisdiction-specific advice.

Most conflict checks happen at intake. A firm looks at a prospective client, compares the names against its current and past engagements, and then accepts the work. The engagement may run for months or years after that, and the facts behind the check can change while nobody re-runs it. A check that was clean in January can be wrong by July.

This post covers two changes that often show up mid-engagement and that small firms tend to miss. The first is a change in who the client is connected to. The second is a change in who on your team is connected to the client. Both can create a conflict, and both are easier to handle when you catch them early.

The goal is not to end relationships at the first sign of trouble. The goal is to notice the issue while you still have choices. You can document it, talk with the people involved, change who does the work, or decide with the client how to proceed. A conflict found in the second month of an engagement leaves more room to act than one discovered during the busiest weeks of the year.

Partners and operations leads share this job. The partner usually knows the client's story and what has changed in its business. The operations lead usually knows what the conflict system holds, when it was last updated, and which staff have been added to the file. Neither can reliably catch a change alone. A partner who relies on memory and an operations team that relies on a record nobody updates will both miss things. The two roles need a shared routine.

Change one: the client's circle moves

A client is not a fixed box. Its owners sell shares, its parent company is bought or sold, it merges with another business, it forms a new subsidiary, or it becomes part of a dispute involving someone else. Any of these events can bring a second party into the picture. That party may already be your client, a former client, or someone you are working against on another matter.

Trigger eventRisk createdFirst question to ask Source
Company B agrees to buy Company AAdvice for A may hurt BAre both parties our clients? Pennsylvania rules
New owner appears on a lender formNew owner may be a client or former clientWho now owns or controls the client?Pennsylvania rules
Client merges or forms a subsidiaryInformation flow crosses client linesWhich duties now cover this information? Minnesota rules
Litigation party realignment Unforeseeable mid-representation conflictHas a party on the other side changed?Pennsylvania rules

Why does this matter so much? The Pennsylvania rules of professional conduct state the principle directly: "(1) Loyalty and independent judgment are essential elements in the lawyer's relationship to a client." When a new owner or a sister company brings a competing interest into the file, the question is not only whether a rule was broken. The question is whether the firm can still give the client the undivided loyalty and judgment it was hired to provide.

Here is a hypothetical example. Your firm prepares the tax returns and reviews the monthly bookkeeping for Company A. Months into the work, you learn that Company B, which your firm serves on a separate matter, has agreed to buy Company A. Now the work for A and the work for B sit inside one corporate family. Advice that helps A in a negotiation may hurt B. Information you hold for one client may be relevant to the other. You did not cause this situation, but you now have to decide what to do about it.

Small firms often miss this because the change happens outside the firm. The client may not think to mention that its new owner is also a client, because it may not know your firm serves the owner. You may hear about it from a news item, a bank request, a comment during a meeting, or a staff member who noticed a familiar name on a document. That is why the check has to look at the client's circle, not only at the client's name.

It also helps to think about information flow. Ask where the facts you hold about one client could travel once the two businesses are linked. Financial statements, pricing details, plans for a sale, and notes from a difficult meeting can all become relevant to someone else. Even if no one at your firm intends to share anything, a conflict can arise simply because the same people now receive documents about two linked businesses.

The Minnesota rules show how seriously this flow of information is treated. Once two businesses are linked, the information in your files may fall under more than one set of duties at the same time.

The same Minnesota provision also recognizes that changes in the composition or ownership of a firm need attention. It permits a limited disclosure where the lawyer "reasonably believes the disclosure is necessary to detect and resolve conflicts of interest arising from the lawyer's change of employment or from changes in the composition or ownership of a firm." That exception is narrow, and it is not a general license to share files.

When a client's structure changes, ask these questions:

  • Who now owns, controls, or is affiliated with this client?
  • Is any of those parties a current client, a former client, or someone whose matter we are handling?
  • Are any of those parties on the other side of a transaction, dispute, or negotiation we are working on?
  • Does the information we hold for one client matter to another client, and would using it for either one raise a problem?

Write the answers down. If the answer to any question is yes, or you are not sure, treat it as a flag and move to the steps in the section on what to do once you find a conflict.

Update the conflict record at specific moments, not just once a year. Good triggers include a new engagement letter, an announced transaction, a request from the client to add a related entity, a new owner appearing on a bank or lender form, and any time a client gives you an updated organization chart. If your firm has a renewal process, add the conflict check to that renewal so it happens without anyone needing to remember. A record that is refreshed only when someone happens to think of it will drift out of date.

Change two: someone on your team takes a second role

The second change is about people. A staff accountant joins the board of a nonprofit client. A manager's spouse takes a job at a company your firm serves. A partner is named as a trustee for a family that is also a client. Some of these roles are unpaid, some are informal, and some are disclosed only in a personal conversation. Each one creates a connection that may matter to how the work is done.

Second role takenWhy it mattersReview needed Source
Manager's spouse works at a served companyPersonal interest may limit judgmentMaterial limitation question Pennsylvania rules
Partner named trustee for a client familyDuties to a third person competeBoth questions in writingPennsylvania rules

The question is not only whether a rule has been broken. It is whether the person can still do the job with the objectivity and attention the work requires, and whether the clients involved are being served fairly. A person can be fully honest and still find that a second role makes it hard to see the facts clearly, or hard to give one client the time it needs. Good intentions do not settle the question on their own.

A useful example comes from a Tax Adviser article on practical approaches to common conflicts of interest. It works through a case in which a practitioner, identified as H, serves in two roles at once. The article frames the problem this way:

> "H needs to determine whether she can maintain her objectivity while serving in both these roles (ET §102-2) and whether she is materially limited from being able to provide competent and diligent representation to XYZ and J (and J's spouse) (Circular 230, §10.29)."

The passage contains two separate questions, and it is worth treating them separately. The first is objectivity: can the person keep an independent view while wearing both hats? The second is material limitation: is the person's ability to serve the affected clients competently and diligently limited by the second role? A person can pass the first test and still fail the second. Someone may be entirely honest and still lack the hours to give two clients the care each one needs. The reverse can also happen, so the firm should ask both questions every time.

The sections the passage cites are ET §102-2 for objectivity and Circular 230, §10.29 for material limitation. Confirm the current text of each provision with your professional body and your firm's counsel before relying on it. The passage above is quoted from a 2014 article, and it does not describe what those sections require in full.

Second roles also reach beyond individual staff. A partner who sits on the board of a lender, a family member who holds a stake in a vendor, or a manager who has invested in a client's competitor can each raise the same two questions. Your conflict process should ask about these interests directly. Staff are often unsure whether a role counts as a conflict, and many will not volunteer it unless asked.

Comparing the two tests

The table below sets out the two questions side by side, so you can use them as a checklist for anyone with a second role:

QuestionWhat it asksSource the passage ties it to
ObjectivityCan the person keep objectivity while serving in both roles?ET §102-2
Material limitation Is the person materially limited from providing competent and diligent representation to the clients involved?Circular 230, §10.29

For each person with a second role, write both questions, answer each one in writing, and record who made the decision and when. A yes or a not-sure answer to either question is a reason to pause, not a reason to panic. It means someone with authority should review the facts before the person continues on the affected work. The answer depends on the facts of each role, so avoid settling it with a general policy alone.

Keep the review proportionate. A volunteer role on a school board that has nothing to do with any client's matter may need only a short note in the file. A role that gives a team member influence over decisions a client relies on needs a fuller review and may need a different staff assignment. The written record should show that the firm looked, what it found, and what it decided.

What to do once you find a conflict

Finding a conflict in the middle of an engagement is stressful, especially when the work is already underway. A calm, ordered response protects the clients and the firm. The steps below are a general sequence, not a legal procedure. Adjust them to your firm's policy and to the rules that apply where you practice.

StepActionOwner
1Pause new work on affected mattersPartner on the matter
2Write down facts, dates, and sourcesOperations lead
3 Bring in conflict decision partnerConflict owner
4Get rule-specific adviceOutside counsel
5 Record the chosen path and reasoningPartner on the matter
6Tell affected parties accurately and timelyPartner on the matter
7 Fix the gap that let it slip throughConflict owner
  1. Pause new work on the affected matters. You do not need to stop everything. You should, however, avoid starting new steps that depend on the unresolved issue until you understand it.

  2. Write down the facts. Record who is involved, what changed, when you learned about it, which clients are affected, and what information each client holds that could matter. Dates and sources matter, so note where each fact came from.

  3. Bring in the right people. The partner responsible for conflict decisions and the person who owns the firm's conflict policy should both see the facts. Keep the circle small. Do not share one client's confidential details with another client while you sort out the issue.

  4. Get rule-specific advice. This post cannot tell you which rule applies to your firm. Check your firm's policy and the requirements of your professional body. Where the issue is complex, bring in an outside adviser or counsel who knows the rules where you practice.

  5. Choose a path and record why. Common options include reassigning staff, limiting the scope of the work, obtaining the informed consent of affected clients where the rules allow it, or ending an engagement. Each option has tradeoffs for the clients and for the firm. Write down the reasoning, not only the decision.

  6. Tell the affected parties what they need to know. Explain the issue in terms the client can act on. Make sure the message is accurate, timely, and consistent with what your policy and rules require.

  7. Update the record and the process. Once the issue is resolved, fix the gap that let it slip through. If the conflict came from a missed trigger, add that trigger. If it came from a staff member who did not disclose a role, change how roles are collected.

Building a check that catches changes

An intake check is a starting point, not a finished control. A firm that wants to catch mid-engagement conflicts needs a routine that runs throughout the life of each client relationship. The routine does not have to be complicated, but it does need an owner, a schedule, and a single place where records are kept.

The table below maps common events to what should be checked and who should own the check:

EventWhat to checkWho owns it
New engagement letterCurrent owners, parents, and affiliatesPartner on the matter
Announced transaction Buyer, seller, and any party on the other sidePartner and conflict owner
New owner on a bank or lender form Whether the new owner is a client or former clientOperations lead
Staff member takes an outside roleObjectivity and material limitation questions Conflict owner, with partner review
Renewal of an ongoing engagementWhether the client's structure has changed since the last checkOperations lead

Start with the client side. Tie a conflict refresh to each renewal, each new engagement letter, and each announced change in ownership or structure. Ask clients to tell you when they are buying, selling, merging, or adding an entity, and make it easy for them to do so. A short, standard question in the renewal letter can surface changes that would otherwise stay hidden until they cause trouble.

Then cover the people side. Ask staff to disclose outside roles when they join, and again when they are asked to work on a new client. A simple annual form can ask about outside boards, trusteeships, family members who work for clients, and financial interests in clients or their competitors. Make it clear that disclosure is expected, that the firm will review what is disclosed, and that staff should tell operations promptly when a role changes.

Finally, keep the record in one place. When the conflict list lives in several spreadsheets, email threads, and people's memories, the firm cannot tell whether a check is current. One system, with clear fields for related parties and staff roles, makes it possible to search for a name and see every affected matter at once. Review active engagements on a fixed schedule, such as at each quarter-end, and look for any client whose record has not been touched in a long time.

A short checklist

  • Write down answers to both questions for anyone with a second role.
  • Pause affected work while a possible conflict is reviewed.
  • Get advice specific to your jurisdiction before choosing a path.
  • Record who decided, what they knew, and why they chose the path they did.

Do this today

Pick one active engagement and write down its current owners, parents, and major affiliates, then do the same for every staff member assigned to that file. Any name you cannot place is a question to answer this week, and the answers go straight into your conflict record.

Closing thoughts

Mid-engagement conflicts are not a sign of carelessness. They come from the fact that clients, businesses, and people change while the work is underway. A firm that plans for change, asks the right questions at the right moments, and writes its answers down will catch most of these issues while there is still room to act. The partner and the operations lead do not have to be experts in every rule. They do have to share a routine that keeps the record current and makes it normal to raise a concern early.

Sources