Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

Non-credentialed preparer representation: 4 IRS exam rules

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 12 min read

Whether a preparer without a CPA, attorney, or enrolled agent credential may represent a client in an IRS exam depends on four rules. The rules are summarized below, followed by an intake process you can apply when the exam is assigned.

Key takeaways

  • Check the credential of the proposed representative first. A CPA, attorney, or enrolled agent keeps full representation rights.
  • For a non-credentialed preparer, check the prepared and signed date of the return under exam.
  • For returns prepared and signed after December 31, 2015, confirm a program participation record for that tax year.
  • Confirm the person prepared or signed the return, and record the decision in the file.

Why this check belongs in every exam assignment

When the IRS opens an examination of a return your firm prepared, someone has to answer the examiner's questions and speak for the client. Operations leads often make that assignment based on who is free and who knows the file. Availability and familiarity are useful, but they do not decide whether a person is allowed to represent the taxpayer. Representation rights depend on the person's credentials, on the date the return was prepared and signed, and, for some preparers, on whether they took part in an IRS program for the relevant tax year.

This post walks through four rules drawn from the sources we checked. They are written for partners and operations leads who decide who handles an exam. They are not legal or tax advice, and they do not replace the current IRS guidance. The changes described here began on January 1, 2016. Rules can change, so confirm the current position before you rely on any of this for a live case.

Rule 1: credentialed professionals keep full representation rights

The simplest test comes first. Attorneys, certified public accountants, and enrolled agents keep full representation rights for all clients before all IRS offices, according to the National Society of Accountants' federal tax preparer information page. The Journal of Accountancy reported the same point in 2014, noting in a parenthetical that CPAs, attorneys, and enrolled agents continue to have unlimited representation rights ( Journal of Accountancy, "IRS reveals details of voluntary preparer certification program").

For staffing, the first question is about the person, not the file. If the person assigned to the exam holds one of these three credentials, the representation question is generally answered, and the team can move on to the other practical parts of the exam. If the person does not hold one of these credentials, the rules that follow apply. A job title does not count, and neither does a long working relationship with the client. Check the credential itself, and keep a record of how you confirmed it.

The credential question also belongs to the partner or operations lead who makes the assignment. Staff who are asked to step in during a busy season may assume they are covered when they are not. Settling the question before the file moves avoids that conversation later.

Rule 2: the cutoff is the date a return was prepared and signed

Before the change, unenrolled preparers could represent certain clients under older guidance. The Journal of Accountancy's 2014 article on the complete program rules describes guidance known as 81-38, which permitted unenrolled preparers to represent before the IRS taxpayers whose return or claim for refund they prepared ( Journal of Accountancy, "Complete rules for the IRS's voluntary return preparer certification program are released").

The IRS describes the change on its Annual Filing Season Program page. It says that beginning January 1, 2016, there were changes to the representation rights of return preparers. It also says that for returns prepared and signed after December 31, 2015, "they will not be allowed to represent clients before the IRS" ( Internal Revenue Service, "Annual Filing Season Program"). The National Society of Accountants also states in plain terms that the rules about who may represent clients before the IRS changed beginning January 1, 2016 ( National Society of Accountants).

The test in these sources is the date a return was prepared and signed. Check that date on the file rather than inferring it from the tax year the return covers. Returns prepared and signed before the cutoff may still raise questions under the older guidance, such as 81-38. Whether that guidance still applies to a particular file is a question for current IRS guidance and your counsel, not a settled answer.

A useful habit is to sort open exam files by signing date before you assign them. The split is simple to state and easy to lose track of when files pass between staff or between seasons. Files on the later side of the line need the program check in Rule 3. Files on the earlier side need the older-guidance review in Case C below. Sorting first saves time, because the staff member who receives the file often cannot see the signing date without opening it.

Rule 3: program participation and the tax year at issue

The Journal of Accountancy's 2014 report on the voluntary certification program said that the guidance was expected to specify that only tax return preparers who have a record of participating in the program for that tax year will be able to represent their clients before the IRS during an examination of a return that they signed or prepared ( Journal of Accountancy, "IRS reveals details of voluntary preparer certification program"). That was the expected design at the time. The later sources describe the changes that took effect, so use them for the operative rule and the 2014 article for background.

The National Society of Accountants states the other side of this rule. Other tax return preparers who do not participate in the Annual Filing Season Program will not be permitted to represent any clients before the IRS for tax returns and claims for refund prepared and signed after December 31, 2015 ( National Society of Accountants).

Put the two together. The 2014 article expected the guidance to tie participation to the tax year; the later sources do not state that limit, so confirm the current wording before relying on it. Until you have done so, do not assume that participation in one year covers the year under exam. Do not accept a general statement that a preparer is in the program. Ask for the participation record for the tax year of the return in question, and check that the record matches the return.

When you ask for that record, be specific. Name the client, the return, and the tax year. A record for a different year, or a general statement of status, does not answer the question the sources ask. Keep the record with the file so that a reviewer or a later examiner can see what the firm relied on.

Rule 4: for non-credentialed preparers, authority attaches to the return

Both the older guidance and the program rule tie a non-credentialed preparer's representation to specific returns. The 81-38 guidance covered taxpayers whose return or claim for refund the preparer prepared. The 2014 description of the program covered examinations of a return the preparer signed or prepared. In each case, the question is which return is under exam and what role the person played on that return. Credentialed professionals are covered by Rule 1 and do not need this link.

This matters for firms with long client relationships. A staff member who knows a client well may still lack authority on the year under exam if they neither prepared nor signed that year's return. Knowing the client's history is useful for the exam, but it does not stand in for the link between the person and the return. Check, for each return under exam, who prepared it and who signed it.

Put the four rules into an assignment process

Use the four rules as a short intake check before anyone is named as the representative. The steps below work for a partner or operations lead who is assigning a case, and they can be handed to whoever runs intake. For the wider intake steps, see Accounting Client Intake Checklist for a Clear Handoff.

  1. Confirm the credential of the person proposed as representative, and record how you confirmed it.
  2. If that person holds a CPA, attorney, or enrolled agent credential, Rule 1 applies and the representation question is generally answered. Stop there for the rights question.
  3. If not, pull the prepared and signed dates for the return under exam.
  4. If the return was prepared and signed after December 31, 2015, the person needs a program participation record under Rule 3, checked against the tax year under exam. Without one, the person may not represent on that return, and the case goes to a credentialed professional.
  5. If the return was prepared and signed before the cutoff, do not assume either way. Check the older guidance and current IRS guidance, and involve counsel if the file is unclear.
  6. If the person is not credentialed, confirm the person prepared or signed the return under exam. If the person did neither, do not name them as representative on that return.
  7. If any answer is no, or you cannot get a clear one, reassign the exam and note why.
  8. Record the decision, as described below.

The partner or operations lead should own this decision, not the staff member who will do the work. That keeps the representation question separate from the workload question, and it gives the firm one person to answer for the assignment.

Five worked cases

These hypothetical cases show how the rules fit together. They are illustrations, not rulings, and each one still needs the current guidance check described above.

Case A: a staff member who is not credentialed prepared and signed a return after the cutoff, and holds a program record for that tax year. The 2014 Journal of Accountancy report said the guidance was expected to allow representation by a preparer with a matching record. The later IRS and NSA sources only exclude non-participants for returns prepared and signed after December 31, 2015. Confirm current guidance before the first call, and confirm that the record covers the tax year under exam.

Case B: the same staff member prepared and signed a return after the cutoff, with no program record for that tax year. The National Society of Accountants says preparers who do not participate in the program will not be permitted to represent clients for returns prepared and signed after December 31, 2015. Route this exam to a credentialed professional and say why in the file.

Case C: a non-credentialed preparer prepared and signed a return before the cutoff. The older guidance once let unenrolled preparers represent taxpayers whose returns they prepared. Whether that guidance governs this file is not settled. Treat the case as unclear and check current IRS guidance and counsel before assigning it.

Case D: a non-credentialed person signed a return that someone else prepared. The 2014 description of the program covers a return the preparer signed or prepared, so signing alone can bring a return within the rule. Whether this person can represent on that return still depends on the signing date under Rule 2 and the program record under Rule 3.

Case E: a CPA who did not prepare the return is assigned to represent the client. The National Society of Accountants says attorneys, CPAs, and enrolled agents keep full representation rights for all clients before all IRS offices. The credential answers the rights question. The firm should still confirm its own engagement terms and the client's authorization under its own procedures.

Illustrative example: one file from intake to reassignment

A firm has an exam file for a return the proposed representative prepared and signed in 2026. That person holds no CPA, attorney, or enrolled agent credential, so step 2 does not apply. A return signed in 2026 is after December 31, 2015, so step 4 applies. The person has no program participation record for that tax year. The person may not represent on this return, so the partner reassigns the exam to a credentialed professional and records the reason in the file.

Document the decision

Write one short note in the file. Include the person assigned, the credential or program status and the tax year it covers, the prepared and signed dates on the return, who prepared and who signed it, the sources you checked, and the date you checked them. Name the person who approved the assignment. A note like this helps you explain the decision if the examiner, a client, or a reviewer asks about it later.

Talking with the client

Clients often ask who will speak for them. Tell them the truth. The person assigned to the exam must have the right to represent them on that return, and the firm will confirm that before the first call. For handoff errors to avoid, see IRS contact authorization: 4 mistakes in firm handoffs. If a credentialed professional has to take over, explain the reason in plain terms and say what the change means for timing and cost. Avoid promising an outcome. Do not present a staff member as the representative until the check is complete.

Common mistakes

The mistakes below are easy to make when a case is busy.

  • Treating a long relationship with the client as authority. Familiarity is not one of the tests.
  • Accepting a verbal statement that a preparer is in the program, without the record for the tax year.
  • Assuming an older rule still governs a return signed after the cutoff.
  • Checking only the person's general standing instead of the return under exam.
  • Letting a job title stand in for a credential.
  • Waiting until the examiner calls to check who is allowed to speak. Check at assignment, when there is still time to reassign.

Open questions to confirm

Several questions remain open, and you should say so when you brief a team.

  • Check current IRS guidance for what each kind of representative may do during an exam before you set expectations with the client.
  • State rules and other proceedings fall outside this topic, so check them separately.
  • Guidance described in 2014 was expected at the time. Confirm the final text that is in force now.
  • Treatment of older returns beyond the 81-38 guidance needs a separate check with current IRS guidance and counsel.

Bottom line

Check the credential first. Then check the signing date, the program record for that tax year, and whether the person prepared or signed the return under exam. If any answer is unclear, route the exam to a credentialed professional, write down why, and confirm the current guidance before the first call with the examiner.

Next step today: sort your open exam files by signing date, as described under Rule 2, and mark each file that needs the program check in Rule 3.

Frequently asked questions

Can a preparer without a credential ever represent a client in an IRS exam?

Only in some cases. Whether it is allowed depends on the date the return was prepared and signed and on a program participation record for that tax year, as set out under Rules 2 and 3.

Does a CPA who did not prepare the return need the same checks?

No. The credential answers the rights question, because the National Society of Accountants says CPAs, attorneys, and enrolled agents keep full representation rights for all clients before all IRS offices.

Which date decides whether the older guidance matters?

The date the return was prepared and signed decides it. The IRS page ties the change to returns prepared and signed after December 31, 2015, and Rule 2 explains how to check that date.

Sources