Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

3 payroll filing mistakes that can lead to notices, delays

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read

A payroll filing mistake can reach your firm in one of two ways: a notice from a tax agency, or a return or correction that takes longer to process than the client was told. Neither is easy to explain to a client. The cause can be a step skipped during a busy week, or a form chosen from memory instead of from the instructions for that period.

This post covers three mistakes that official guidance on payroll forms points to. Two come from IRS instructions for federal forms, and one comes from Pennsylvania's employer withholding guidance. Where a rule applies to one agency or one state, the post says so. The links go to the official pages, which hold the full text, and nothing here replaces those pages.

Each mistake below is tied to a source you can read yourself. This post does not try to cover every payroll rule, and it does not advise on any particular client's filing. Treat it as a set of checks to add to your own review routine, and confirm each point against the page it cites before acting on it in a client file. If you are new to a client's filing history, start with the prior year's file before opening the current one.

The three mistakes differ in form, but they share a root. Each one comes from a filing that is not matched to the right return, form, or period.

Partners and operations leads who file for several clients will recognize these situations. Each of the three sections below starts with the answer the source gives, then explains what it means for the people doing the filing work.

Chief takeaways

  • Filing a Form 944-X before the original Form 944 for the year may result in errors or delays in processing the correction, as IRS instructions state.
  • Pennsylvania employers could face non-filer notifications or misapplied payments from using the wrong form, and returns are due whether or not taxable transactions occurred in a period.
  • Prior-period adjustments reported on Form 945-X, CT-1 X, or 944-X should not be taken into account when figuring current-year tax liability on Form 945-A.
  • The shared root of all three mistakes is a filing not matched to the right return, form, or period, so confirm all three before anything goes out.

Sending a correction before the original return

The IRS instructions for Form 944 say that filing a Form 944-X before filing a Form 944 for the year may result in errors or delays in processing the 944-X. The warning is about order: the 944-X is the form that should not be filed before the Form 944 for the same year.

FormRole in the correction sequenceSource
Form 944Annual return filed for the year firstIRS
Form 944-XCorrection that should not precede the 944IRS
ErrorsPossible result of filing 944-X firstIRS
Delays Possible result of filing 944-X firstIRS

The source is careful about its wording. It names two possible results, errors and delays, and it says they may happen. It does not say a correction will be rejected, and this post does not say that either.

The risk is easiest to see in one situation. A client calls about an error on last year's return, and the team starts the correction before anyone has checked whether the original filing for that year is on file.

Here is how that can look in practice. Suppose a client asks in the spring to fix an amount on last year's annual return. The preparer has the correction form open and the figures ready. Before anything is sent, the reviewer asks one question: is the original Form 944 for that year on file? If the answer is no, the correction is not sent yet, and the team deals with the original return first. That order is what the IRS warning describes.

Sequence problems slip through because a correction can look finished on its own. The figures are right, the form is complete, and the file appears ready. The missing piece is the original return, which may sit in another folder, in another system, or with a prior preparer.

A short check before work starts can prevent that. Confirm that the Form 944 for the year has been filed, and note the filing date in the client file before the 944-X is prepared. If the original return is not on file, the correction question should wait, because the instructions point to filing the Form 944 for the year first. Once the original is filed, keep a copy with the correction file so the reviewer can compare the two without asking for it again.

Operations leads can build this into the handoff. Whoever prepares the correction should see the status of the annual return on the same screen, and the reviewer should sign off on the file only after that status is confirmed. Put the tax year on every correction file as well. When several years are open for one client, a file labeled only with the client's name is easy to match to the wrong return.

Explaining the order up front also helps when you talk with the client. It gives the client a reason for any wait that is tied to the filing sequence, rather than to the figures themselves. Ask the client which return the error came from, which tax year it covers, and who filed the original, since those answers show whether the original return is in your files.

Using the wrong form or skipping a period with no activity

Pennsylvania's Department of Revenue, on its employer withholding page, says that the use of other tax forms could result in non-filer notifications and/or the misapplication of the tax payment, and that returns are to be filed whether or not taxable transactions occur in a period.

Pennsylvania filing pointStated outcomeSource
Use of other tax formsNon-filer notifications PA DOR
Use of other tax forms Misapplication of the tax paymentPA DOR
Period with no taxable transactionsReturn is still to be filedPA DOR

Both statements come from that page, and both are about Pennsylvania. The page does not say what other states require, so a firm with clients in other states should check each state's own guidance.

Wording matters too. The page says the use of other forms "could" result in those outcomes, so they are possible results, not certain ones. A firm should still treat them as worth preventing, since any notice takes time to answer.

Wrong form. The page names two possible results of using other tax forms. The first is a non-filer notification. The second is the misapplication of the tax payment, meaning the payment may be applied in a way it should not be. For the people doing the work, the practical step is to confirm the form before the return is prepared, not after a notice arrives. Write the form number in the client file next to the period it covers. If a saved default points to a form that does not match the filing, correct it before the next cycle.

Suppose a firm prepares filings for two Pennsylvania clients and one client in another state. The Pennsylvania filings follow the Department of Revenue page. The other client's filing follows that state's own guidance, which this post does not cover. Keeping the two sets of checks apart in the file makes it clear which rules were applied to which return.

No taxable transactions. The second point is narrower but just as direct. Returns are to be filed whether or not taxable transactions occur in a period. Under that wording, a period with no taxable transactions still calls for a return, and a quiet period is not a reason to skip the filing.

Suppose a client had no payroll activity in one filing period. The file still needs a record of that period, and under the page's wording the return for that period is still to be filed.

For a client with irregular activity, build the filing calendar from every filing period, not only the periods with payroll activity. For a Pennsylvania client with irregular activity, build the filing calendar from every filing period, not only the periods with payroll activity, and keep a short note for each period that says whether taxable transactions occurred, then file the Pennsylvania return either way; for other states, check that state's own guidance. That note also helps if a notice arrives, because the file will show which return was filed for which period.

A file note is short and written in plain words, so a reviewer who did not prepare the return can follow it. It should name the form used, the period, the date filed, and whether there were taxable transactions in that period.

If a notice does arrive, read it against the file rather than from memory. Compare the form and period it names with your own record, and keep a copy of both with the client file before anyone replies.

Changing current-year liability with a prior-period adjustment

Under the IRS instructions for Form 945-A, you should not change the current year's tax liability by adjustments reported on a Form 945-X, CT-1 X, or 944-X when you file Form 945-A with your Form 945, CT-1, or 944. The table pairs each original return with its correction form.

Original returnCorrection form Current-year liability on Form 945-A
Form 945Form 945-XAdjustments are not taken into account for the current year
Form CT-1Form CT-1 XAdjustments are not taken into account for the current year
Form 944Form 944-X Adjustments are not taken into account for the current year

The instructions state the rule behind this in one sentence: prior-period adjustments are reported on Form 945-X, Form CT-1 X, or Form 944-X, and they aren't taken into account when figuring the tax liability for the current year.

For a firm, the practical point is that an adjustment for an earlier period and the current-year liability are separate figures on separate forms. A correction should not be used to move the current year's number, and the current-year Form 945-A should be checked against the current-year figures.

When one person prepares the correction and another prepares the current-year return, the handoff should say which figures belong to which year. A reviewer can then check the Form 945-A against the current year's records without wondering whether an earlier correction has been folded in.

The same instructions also point readers elsewhere for detail on the correction forms: "See the Instructions for Form 944-X or the Instructions for Form CT-1 X for more information." If a client's file includes one of those corrections, read the matching instructions before the correction is prepared or filed.

Suppose a client's current-year return and a prior-period correction are prepared in the same week. The preparer may want the total to look cleaner by netting the earlier adjustment into this year's figure. The instructions say that adjustments reported on those correction forms are not taken into account for the current year, so netting them into the current-year liability is the step to avoid.

When you explain the change to a client, describe it as two items. One is the current-year liability on Form 945-A. The other is the earlier-period adjustment, reported on its own correction form. Presented that way, the client can see which number belongs to which year.

A reviewer can check this in a few steps. Read the Form 945-A and the correction side by side. Confirm that the current-year liability is built from current-year amounts only. Confirm that the correction names the year it corrects. If any of those checks fails, the file goes back to the preparer.

Keep a copy of the table with the file for the year. When a client asks why a correction is filed on its own form instead of in the current-year return, the answer is on hand.

Where to check for updates

The IRS directs readers to IRS.gov/Form945A for the latest information on developments related to Form 945-A and its instructions, including legislation enacted after they were published.

Update sourceWhat it coversSource
IRS.gov/Form945ALatest developments on Form 945-AIRS
Form 944-X instructionsDetail on the correction formIRS
Form CT-1 X instructionsDetail on the correction formIRS
PA employer withholding pagePennsylvania filing guidancePA DOR

The Form 945-A instructions used in this post are dated 12/2025. If your team keeps a saved copy, compare it with the current version before using it on a client filing. The Pennsylvania points in the second section come from the Department of Revenue's employer withholding page, so check that page directly before a Pennsylvania filing goes out.

The three mistakes share one habit. Before a payroll return or correction goes out, confirm which return it belongs to, which form it uses, and which year or period it covers. That check applies to each of the three problems in this post.

A notice from an agency is easier to answer when the file already shows the form, the period, and the order of filing. Build that into the routine, and the next notice has less to search for.

To use this in a team setting, read the three sections aloud at the start of a filing cycle, and ask each preparer which of the checks they already do. Any check that nobody can describe is a good place to start.

This post covers the federal payroll forms named in the IRS sources and Pennsylvania's employer withholding guidance. It does not cover the rules of other states. Check each state's own agency page for those.

Not legal or tax advice.

Questions readers ask

What happens if I file a Form 944-X before the original Form 944?

The IRS instructions for Form 944 state that filing a 944-X before the Form 944 for the year may result in errors or delays in processing the correction. The instructions say 'may,' so rejection is not guaranteed, but the order is still the original return first.

Do I still need to file a Pennsylvania return if there were no taxable transactions in the period?

Yes. Pennsylvania's Department of Revenue states that returns are to be filed whether or not taxable transactions occur in a period. A quiet period is not a reason to skip the filing.

What can go wrong if I use the wrong form on a Pennsylvania withholding return?

The PA DOR employer withholding page says the use of other tax forms could result in non-filer notifications and/or the misapplication of the tax payment. These are possible outcomes, not certain ones, but they are worth preventing by confirming the form before preparing the return.

Can prior-period adjustments be netted into the current-year liability on Form 945-A?

No. The IRS instructions for Form 945-A say not to change your current year tax liability by adjustments reported on any Form 945-X, CT-1 X, or 944-X. Prior-period adjustments are reported on their own correction forms and are not taken into account for the current year.

Which correction form goes with which original return?

Form 945 pairs with Form 945-X, Form CT-1 pairs with Form CT-1 X, and Form 944 pairs with Form 944-X. In each case the adjustment is reported on the correction form and excluded from the current-year Form 945-A liability.

Where do I find the latest updates on Form 945-A?

The IRS directs readers to IRS.gov/Form945A for the latest information on developments related to Form 945-A and its instructions, including legislation enacted after publication. The instructions used in this post are dated 12/2025, so compare saved copies with the current version.

Sources