At intake, a predecessor fee dispute brings two duties: check for a conflict and get consent, and hold disputed recovery money in trust. A new client often arrives with a fight already in progress. They hired a firm, the work went partway, and then the relationship ended. Now the prior firm says it is owed a fee, and the client wants you to deal with it. That request can look like a small add-on to the matter. Usually it is not.
Once your firm agrees to take the case, your lawyers may end up negotiating a number with the prior firm, and your trust account may end up holding money that two firms claim. Those are the points that can cause trouble later. They are much easier to handle before the engagement starts than after.
This post covers two duties that appear in the Pennsylvania version of the fee rule for lawyers who take over a matter from another lawyer. The Pennsylvania text calls that lawyer "successor counsel" and the earlier lawyer "predecessor counsel," and this post uses the same terms. Your state may word its rule differently, and your firm's ethics counsel or malpractice carrier may have its own guidance. Treat what follows as a checklist to bring to those conversations, not as a replacement for them.
Why intake is the time to act
Intake is the one point where your firm has full leverage over the terms. Before you accept the matter, you can decline, set conditions, decide who will talk to whom, and ask for documents. After you accept and money starts moving, many of those options narrow, and some cost more to undo.
The dispute itself usually predates you. You may not know the prior firm's position, the size of its claim, or whether the client already agreed to anything in writing. That gap is why intake needs a structured conversation rather than a quick yes at the front desk.
Operations leads should treat intake as a file-building exercise. The responsible lawyer decides whether to take the case. The operations lead makes sure the file shows what the firm knew on the day that decision was made. When someone asks about the fee months later, a clean intake file is the answer, and a memory of a hallway conversation is not.
Duty one: check for a conflict, then get consent
The first duty concerns your firm's relationship with the client once it starts dealing with the prior firm. The Pennsylvania text says that if successor counsel will be involved in negotiating fees with predecessor counsel on the client's behalf, successor counsel should evaluate whether the circumstances give rise to a conflict of interest with the client. If they do, successor counsel must obtain appropriate informed consent to the conflict, as set forth in Rule 1.7. See 204 Pa. Code Rule 1.5, Fees.
Notice the two verbs. "Should evaluate" asks for a real look at the facts before anyone calls the prior firm. "Must obtain" applies only once that look shows a conflict. A firm that skips the evaluation because it cannot think of a conflict is making the same assumption the evaluation exists to test.
What does the evaluation look at? The questions below are general starting points. Ask whether your firm has a financial stake in how the prior fee is resolved, such as a share of a recovery that would shrink if the prior fee grows. Ask whether your firm has any relationship with the prior firm that the client would want to know about. Ask whether any decision you would make in the negotiation would favor your firm over the client. Write the answers down, with the date and who reviewed them.
Who should run this check? Usually the responsible lawyer, with a second lawyer reviewing it if the firm has one. An operations lead cannot make the conflict call, but can make sure the question gets asked and recorded before the first phone call to the prior firm. If the answer is still unclear after the review, that uncertainty is itself something to raise with ethics counsel before anyone negotiates.
Consent: get it in writing, even where the rule may not demand it
Consent is where many small firms are casual, and that is a mistake. The Pennsylvania text points to ABA Formal Opinion 487 (June 18, 2019), which relates to successive contingent fee agreements. The text then explains that while part II.A of that opinion would require the client's written informed consent, Rule 1.7 does not require a writing. Two sources of guidance can point in different directions on form, and the practical answer is to look at both.
The same text adds the point that matters for daily work. If informed consent is needed, written consent may benefit both the client and successor counsel, for the reasons set out in Explanatory Comment (20) to Rule 1.7. In plain terms, a signed consent protects the firm if the client later says they did not understand what they agreed to, and it protects the client by putting the trade-offs on paper while they are still deciding.
A consent letter should say a few things in simple words. It should explain that your firm will talk to the prior firm about its fee. It should describe your firm's own interest in how that talk comes out. It should say what the client can do, including getting another lawyer's view before signing. And it should be dated and filed with the intake documents. For the fee terms that belong in that paperwork, see 3 fee items to state in writing when an engagement starts.
Operations leads should watch the timing. A consent letter handed over at the end of the first meeting, when the client is still reacting to the prior firm's bill, is not really informed. Give the client a copy, give them time to read it, and answer their questions in writing if they ask. Then file the signed version and note the date it came back.
Duty two: hold the disputed money in trust
The second duty concerns money. The Pennsylvania text says that if a dispute arises regarding distribution of the recovery, successor counsel must hold the disputed portion of the funds in trust pending resolution, in accordance with Rule 1.15(f). See 204 Pa. Code Rule 1.5, Fees.
Three parts of that sentence matter at intake. The trigger is a dispute about how the recovery is distributed. The thing held is the disputed portion, not the whole recovery. And the hold lasts pending resolution of that dispute. Each part changes what your intake file should say.
Start with the trigger. If the matter has no recovery yet, the duty may not be running at intake, but the file should still say so. It should also say what would start it: a settlement or judgment that produces money, and a claim from the prior firm against that money. This duty covers a dispute over distribution of a recovery, so if your matter does not involve a recovery, it does not apply on its face, and you should check which rule does.
Next, the disputed portion. The text speaks of the disputed portion, which means someone has to decide what part of the money is actually in dispute. Write both numbers down at intake: the amount the prior firm claims and the amount the client agrees is owed.
Finally, the hold runs until the dispute is resolved. The text ties the hold to resolution, so the disputed portion stays in trust until the dispute is settled. A payment to the client or the prior firm from that portion, before resolution, is the step to avoid. Make sure everyone who can approve a disbursement knows that before the first check comes in.
Before any money arrives, decide how the trust account will handle the disputed portion. Who approves disbursements from the trust account? How will the disputed portion be labeled in the trust records so that it cannot be confused with the undisputed portion? Where and how will the client see the split? Put the answers in the file. The operations lead usually owns these details, and they are easier to set up in advance than to reconstruct later.
The detailed trust-handling requirements come from the rule the text cross-references, Rule 1.15(f). Pull that text and walk through it with your accounting staff before the first intake, rather than relying on this post for the mechanics.
Tell the client, in writing, what happens to the money if the dispute stays open. Clients often assume that money in the firm's account is theirs to request, or that the firm will simply pay whoever calls first. Say plainly that the disputed portion stays in trust until the dispute is resolved, and name the person the client can call with questions about the account. A short paragraph in the intake letter does this job well.
Comparing the options at intake
Most small firms end up choosing among a handful of paths when a predecessor fee is in dispute. The table sets the main paths side by side. The last column is the one that is easiest to skip, and it is the one that helps most if the file is reviewed later.
| Option at intake | When it tends to fit | What the Pennsylvania text says | What to record in the file |
|---|---|---|---|
| Take the matter and handle fee talks with the prior firm, with consent confirmed orally | The conflict review found a possible conflict that the client was told about in conversation | Evaluate whether a conflict exists; if one does, obtain appropriate informed consent under Rule 1.7 | Conflict review, date, and a note of what the client was told |
| Take the matter and handle fee talks with the prior firm, with written consent signed first | Same as above, where the firm wants a signed record before any call | Rule 1.7 does not require a writing, but written consent may benefit both client and successor counsel; ABA Formal Opinion 487 part II.A would require written consent | Signed consent letter, the date it came back, and the questions the client asked |
| Take the matter and hold any disputed recovery in trust until resolution | A recovery is expected and the split is contested | Hold the disputed portion in trust pending resolution, under Rule 1.15(f) | Disputed and undisputed amounts, the trust approval steps, and who can release funds |
| Decline the matter at intake | The conflict cannot be managed, or the terms cannot be agreed | Firm judgment, with ethics counsel input | The reason for declining and the date the client was told |
The first two rows are the same path with different paperwork. Row one is what happens when the firm treats consent as a conversation, and row two is what happens when it treats consent as a document. The Pennsylvania text makes clear that the rule itself does not insist on a writing, but it also says written consent may benefit both sides. For that reason the second row is usually the sturdier record.
The third row applies only once there is a recovery and a real dispute over how it is split. It can sit alongside either of the first two rows. A firm that takes the matter with consent can still need the trust steps later, so the intake file should note both.
The fourth row is the fallback. Declining is a choice that rests on your firm's own judgment and on any advice from ethics counsel. Whatever the reason, record it when you make the decision, not later, and tell the client promptly in plain words.
A worked example
Consider an illustrative case. A client comes to a small firm after a dispute with another firm over a contingency matter. The prior firm says it is owed a share of any settlement and has sent a letter asserting that claim. The client wants the new firm to take over the case and to deal with the prior firm's fee.
Run intake the way the duties suggest. The operations lead collects the engagement terms and the prior firm's letter, and records the dates. The responsible lawyer completes the conflict review. The review notes that the new firm would be negotiating a fee that comes out of the same recovery the new firm stands to earn, so the question of a financial stake is real. The lawyer decides the firm will talk to the prior firm and sends a consent letter that explains the firm's own interest and the client's option to consult another lawyer. The client signs a few days later, after reading the letter at home.
The file then notes that no recovery exists yet, so the trust duty is not running. It says what would start that duty, and it lists the amount the prior firm claims alongside the amount the client believes is owed.
Compare that with a version where the firm starts calling the prior firm on the first day, relying on the client's verbal okay. That file has no review date, no signed consent, and no figure for the disputed amount. If a settlement later arrives with a split nobody agrees on, the firm has to reconstruct what it knew and when. The second version is not a disaster, but it is much harder to explain, and the difference came down to a few hours of paperwork at intake.
Building the intake file
The table tells you which path to take. The file tells you that you took it correctly. For a broader intake routine, see Accounting Client Intake Checklist for a Clear Handoff. These steps keep the file in shape without turning intake into a long project:
- Collect the documents. Ask the client for the engagement terms they signed with the prior firm, any bill or demand from that firm, and anything they signed about the fee. Keep copies, and note anything the client cannot find.
- Write down the dates. Record when the client first engaged the prior firm, when the work stopped, when the fee dispute began, and when your firm first heard about it.
- Record the client's account in the client's own words. Mark which parts you have verified and which parts are only what the client believes.
- Complete and sign the conflict review before the first call to the prior firm. Put the signature date on the review itself.
- Decide the consent approach. Name who drafts the letter, who explains it to the client, and when the client is expected to sign it.
- Set the trust plan. Note whether a recovery is expected, the disputed and undisputed amounts if they are known, and who approves any movement out of trust.
- Name one person to speak with the prior firm, and tell the client who that person is. If two lawyers at the firm give the client different answers, the file becomes much harder to defend.
- Put plain-language scope terms in the engagement letter. Say what the firm will do about the fee dispute and what it will not do. Do not promise an outcome on the prior firm's fee, because you cannot guarantee one. For the full set of terms, see Engagement letter: 6 terms to settle at intake.
Each of these steps takes a few minutes when done at the time, and much longer to reconstruct months later. The operations lead can run most of the list, while the responsible lawyer owns the conflict review and the consent discussion.
Closing the loop
The two duties are simple to state and easy to skip under pressure. Intake is the cheapest point to handle them, because the firm still has the choice of whether, and on what terms, to take the matter.
Pick the path that fits the facts, record the reasons when you pick it, and explain the next steps to the client in words they can repeat back to you. If the file shows that you checked, asked, and told the client what you were doing, you will be in a much better position than a firm that relied on a conversation it cannot prove happened.