For QBI client intake, check employee services, continued work for a former employer, and separate trade or business determinations.
Key takeaways
- Record employment pay separately from business income.
- Ask when employee status ended and what work continued.
- List each business and entity interest for review.
- Date the note and flag unknown facts for follow-up.
Every new client file starts with a description of what the business does. For most clients, that is enough. For the qualified business income (QBI) deduction under section 199A, one more question has to be answered early: does any of the work the client performs count as employee services? The answer decides whether that work is part of a trade or business for the deduction. It is much easier to settle while the client is across the table than months later at return time.
This post sets out three rules to check at each new client intake. Each one comes from the IRS instructions for Form 8995, and each one can be recorded in a short, standard note that stays in the file. Partners and operations leads can use the same note across the firm, so every preparer starts from the same facts.
Why intake is the right moment
Intake is when the facts are freshest. The client remembers which job they left and when, the engagement letter is still open, and the file has no return history to sort through. Waiting makes the work harder. By the time a return is prepared, the preparer may be piecing together old pay records and emails, and the question of employee services may be answered by guesswork.
The note also gives the reviewing partner something concrete to check. It shows the question was asked, not skipped.
One caution before you start. The rules below are summarized from the official instructions, and the instructions control. Read the Instructions for Form 8995 (2025) yourself before you rely on this post for any client decision. The IRS also notes that legislation enacted after the instructions are published can bring new developments, so the version you read should be the current one.
Rule 1: employee services are not a trade or business
The first rule addresses employee work when a client's income comes from several places. The IRS instructions state: "The trade or business of performing services as an employee isn't a trade or business for purposes of section 199A." ( Instructions for Form 8995 (2025))
Wages from a job do not become QBI-qualifying business activity because the client is skilled, works hard, or works for a company that happens to be profitable. Employee work and any real business the client runs are two different things, and the file has to keep them apart.
Here is a common situation. A client works full time as a project manager for a construction company and, on weekends, runs a small landscaping business from a truck and a trailer. The project management pay is wages from employment. The landscaping work is a separate activity that may be a trade or business. If the intake note lumps both under "self-employed consultant," the preparer will have no clear basis to separate them later.
At intake, ask three plain questions:
- Does the client receive a paycheck from an employer for services performed for that employer?
- Is the work done as part of a job the client holds, rather than as a service the client sells on their own account?
- Is any pay from employment mixed in with the business income records in the file?
If the answer to any of these is yes, write the employer, the type of work, and the pay source in the note. Keep the two streams on separate lines so the reviewer can see what was set aside and why. A short line is enough. For example: "Client performs project management services as an employee. Separate landscaping activity recorded below."
This section has one more point. Being an employee does not mean the client has no other trade or business. The first rule only removes the employee work from consideration. It does not decide the status of anything else in the file. Those other activities are judged on their own, which is the subject of Rule 3.
Partners sometimes assume the deduction question will sort itself out once the return is prepared. Early classification can make preparation easier, while supporting records can still help separate wages from business activity later.
Rule 2: the 3-year presumption after a client stops being an employee
The second rule covers a possible client situation. A person works for a company as an employee, leaves, and then keeps doing the same work for that company, now as an outside provider. The paperwork has changed, but the job has not. The IRS addresses that situation directly: "If you were previously an employee of a business and continue to provide substantially the same services to that business after you're no longer treated as an employee, there is a presumption that you're providing services as an employee for purposes of section 199A for the 3-year period after ceasing to be an employee." ( Instructions for Form 8995 (2025))
Read the sentence slowly, because each part matters at intake.
- The trigger is the end of employee treatment. Record when the person was no longer treated as an employee, rather than relying on when they first signed a new contract.
- The test is substantially the same services. Compare the work before and after, rather than relying on paperwork or job titles.
- The business is the former employer. Identify the business the person used to work for.
- The period is three years. Put the end date on the calendar for later review.
So what does the intake note need? Write down the date employee status ended, the name of the former employer, a short description of the work before and after, and a yes or no on whether the work for that employer looks substantially the same. If the answer is yes, flag the file. Do not just write "former employee." That phrase tells the reviewer nothing about the three-year period.
Next, calculate the end of the period. If employee status ended on a known date, the three-year window ends three years after that date. A future preparer who opens the file in year two should see the date and know the presumption is still running.
Consider a concrete case. A client worked as an in-house accountant for a manufacturer until last spring. Since leaving, the client has done monthly bookkeeping for the same manufacturer through the client's own company. The services look much the same as before. This is the pattern the presumption describes. The intake note should say so and flag the question for review rather than resolve it quietly. The presumption tells the preparer where to look. The note should record how the reviewer weighed the facts, instead of treating the presumption as a formality.
Not every former employee falls under this rule. A client who left a job years ago and now serves entirely different customers falls outside the stated condition if services to the former employer have stopped, regardless of whether the work itself is similar. For that reason, the intake question is narrow: find out whether the services to the former employer continued. Ask it directly and write down the answer.
Also ask about other former employers. A client may have worked for several companies in recent years. Check each one separately, because the presumption is tied to the business the person was employed by.
Rule 3: each trade or business is separate, and entities are judged at the entity level
The third rule has three parts. Each one changes how the intake form should be built, so it is worth reading slowly.
Each trade or business is separate. The instructions state: "If you're engaged in more than one trade or business, each trade or business is a separate trade or business for purposes of section 199A." ( Instructions for Form 8995 (2025)) A client who runs a consulting practice and also operates a retail shop has two activities. The intake form should give each one its own line, with its own description, its own income source, and its own note on whether any part of it is employee work.
Do not combine activities determined to be separate trades or businesses under one description. That phrasing blends separate activities together, and the reviewer cannot tell the pieces apart by income stream.
Ownership in an entity is judged at the entity level. The second part of the rule reads: "For purposes of section 199A, if you own an interest in a pass-through entity, the trade or business determination is made at the entity level." ( Instructions for Form 8995 (2025))
The client's own description of their role is not the test. For the intake note, list each entity the client owns an interest in, write down what that entity does, and record the client's interest in it. Use the site's entity intake guide to organize that part of the file.
Write the entity's activity, not the client's job title. A client who is a "managing partner" of a firm should have the firm's activity recorded, not just the title. The title alone tells the reviewer little about the business. If the client is also an employee of that entity, record both facts. The employee work and the entity's business are separate questions, and Rule 1 still applies to the wages.
Material participation is not required for QBI. The third part addresses material participation: "Material participation under section 469 isn't required to qualify for the QBI deduction." ( Instructions for Form 8995 (2025))
Clients often want to know whether they must be hands-on in the business. The intake note should record the distinction in one line, so no one spends time collecting hours logs for a test the QBI deduction does not require. The sentence says nothing about whether material participation matters elsewhere on a client's return, so do not extend it beyond QBI.
Illustrative example: recording separate activities
Picture a hypothetical client who works as a salaried analyst for a logistics company. The same client owns an interest in a partnership that runs a bakery and operates a freelance photography business on evenings and weekends.
Under Rule 1, the analyst salary is employee pay from the logistics company, so the note records it as wage income that is not a trade or business for section 199A.
The note records what the partnership does and the client's interest in it. The photography work gets its own description for review.
The result is a file where a reviewer can see which pay was set aside and which business each activity belongs to. That is the goal of the intake note.
Building the intake note
With the three rules in hand, the note itself can be short. A one-page form works well, and it can sit at the front of the client file. Use these fields:
- Client and entity types. The client's name, its legal form, and any entities the client owns.
- Activities. One line for each activity, each with its own description and income source.
- Employee services. Who the client works for as an employee, the type of work, and the pay source. This covers Rule 1.
- Former employers. The former employer's name, the date employee status ended, and whether the services are substantially the same. This covers Rule 2.
- Three-year window. The end date of the presumption period, if one applies, and a calendar reminder.
- Entities owned. Each entity, its activity, and the client's interest. This covers Rule 3.
- Material participation. A line recording the QBI distinction above.
- Reviewer initials and date. Who checked the entries and when.
Keep the language flat. Avoid words like "probably" or "should be fine." If a fact is unknown, write "unknown" and add a follow-up item. A file with an open question is more useful than one that looks finished but hides a gap.
Date every entry. The three-year period in Rule 2 only works if the file says when employee status ended. Calculate the window from the employment end date, even if the note itself lacks an entry date.
Store the note with the engagement letter. Preparers who open the file later should find it without searching through email. The site's client intake checklist can help organize the wider handoff.
Mistakes to avoid at intake
- Treating wages as business income. Keep employment pay identified in the file before reviewing other activities.
- Overlooking the former-employee pattern. Ask about continued work rather than relying on the client's description as self-employed.
- Combining activities. Combining descriptions can obscure separate trades or businesses and require clarification; it does not establish their classification.
- Describing entities by title. Record what the entity does alongside the client's role.
- Using material participation as a gate. Keep the QBI question distinct from other return questions about participation.
- Relying on memory. The facts at intake should come from documents or a dated conversation, not recollection at tax time.
Keep the note current
Forms and instructions change. The IRS says: "For the latest information about developments related to Form 8995 and its instructions, such as legislation enacted after they were published, go to IRS.gov/Form8995." ( Instructions for Form 8995 (2025)) Put that address in the intake form so every preparer checks the current version before applying the rules.
Review the form at the start of each filing season. If the instructions have changed, update the note's wording and tell the team what changed. A short changelog at the top of the form is enough.
Start with one client file today
Use the eight fields above to review one client file today. Record what you know, flag missing employment end dates, and leave a clear follow-up item for the reviewer.
Questions at intake
What should I write when a fact is unknown?
Write "unknown" and add a follow-up item. Keep the question visible for the reviewer rather than guessing.
Where should the intake note be stored?
Store the note with the engagement letter. That gives the next preparer a consistent place to find it.