Skip ahead to the main page
Partner Huddle
Pages

6 return checks before a client signs and files

Partner Huddle Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read

A client's return can have the right numbers and still not be ready to file. The sign-off step also has to confirm who signs the return, how it is signed, whether each identifying number belongs to the right person, and whether the timing works. This post sets out 6 checks that a partner or operations lead can run on an individual return before the client signs and the firm files it.

The checks are general practice points unless a section links a source. Where a section states a rule, the rule comes from the linked page, and it holds only in the setting that page describes. Check the linked page before you rely on any detail for a specific client.

The list works best when it is written down and followed in the same order every time. Run the checks on the final version of the return, not on a working copy, because a check passed on an earlier draft tells you little about what the client will sign. Finish all 6 checks before anyone signs, even when the first few look clean. A return that passes 5 checks and skips the 6th has not been reviewed.

1. Check that every required signature is present

Every return has to be signed, so the first check is simple: no signature line should be left empty. The Tax Adviser states the basic requirement in one line: "Every tax return has to be signed, so why is signing them so confusing?" The same article describes itself as "A guide to understanding all the ways to sign a tax return." It is a useful reference when a signing question comes up.

Signature stepWhat to confirm
Who is supposed to signPerson has seen the final version, not an earlier draft
Date entered with each signature Entered when the client actually signs, not later from memory
Page count of the final fileCompared with the version the client reviewed
Signing orderWritten into process notes if one sign-off depends on another
Version tied to each signing step Saved with a file name or version number if your process uses one

Walk through the return one signature line at a time. For each line, write down who is supposed to sign it, and confirm that the person has seen the final version rather than an earlier draft. If figures change after a client has signed, treat the changed return as a new version: go back over it with the partner and decide whether the client must sign again. If more than one person's name appears on the return, treat each person as a separate check so that nobody is missed.

Open the final file itself and look at each signature area in it. If your process records a date with each signature, make sure that date is entered when the client actually signs, not filled in later from memory.

Check that no page is missing. A signed return with a page left out is not the return the client approved. Compare the page count of the final file with the version the client reviewed.

Think about the order in which people sign. If one person's sign-off depends on another's, write that order into your process notes so nobody signs a page that is still changing. A signature is only as good as the version it sits on, so tie each signing step to a saved version, using a file name or version number if your process uses one.

Keep the signed version with the rest of the return file. The purpose of this check is not to find out whether a signature exists somewhere in the file. It is to confirm that each signature on the final version comes from the person it is meant for.

2. Check the signing method against the filing method

An e-filed return must be electronically signed, so confirm that the signing method matches the filing method before anything is sent. The Tax Adviser puts the rule this way: "And if the return is electronically filed (e-filed), it must be electronically signed (e-signed)." The sentence is short, but it answers the question for any return you plan to e-file.

Decide the signing method early, while there is still time to change the workflow. Confirm who will do the e-signing, and make sure the client has reviewed the version that will be filed, not an earlier one. Keep the record of the signing step with the return file so that the file shows how the return was signed.

The quoted rule covers e-filed returns only. It does not say what to do for a return filed another way, so if your firm files by another route, check that path separately rather than assuming this rule covers it.

Before you send the file, compare the signed record with the version in your filing software. Confirm that the e-signature is attached to the return you are about to send, and not to an earlier draft from the same work.

Be careful with changes after e-signing. If a figure changes after the client has signed electronically, do not simply carry the signature forward to the new numbers. Send the changed version back for review and decide, with the partner, whether a new signature is needed before anything is filed.

If your firm gives a client a preview of the return before signing, make sure the preview matches the version you will file. A preview that differs from the filed version is a problem even if the client never saw the difference.

3. Check whether a taxpayer under 16 can sign with a self-select PIN

A taxpayer under 16 may not be able to use the self-select PIN, depending on filing history. According to The Tax Adviser, primary taxpayers under 16 who have never filed cannot use the self-select PIN to sign, and secondary taxpayers under 16 who did not file in the prior tax year cannot use it either.

ItemWhat the cited source says
Primary taxpayer under 16Cannot use the self-select PIN to sign if they have never filed
Secondary taxpayer under 16 Cannot use the self-select PIN to sign if they did not file in the prior tax year
E-filed returnMust be electronically signed
1099 recipient TIN Depends on who the taxpayer is and how the business is treated for federal tax purposes
Filing deadline Generally April 15 for most people to file individual returns and pay any tax owed

Sources for the table: The Tax Adviser for the PIN and e-signing rows, Tax1099 for the TIN row, and the IRS for the deadline row.

Ask the client directly about each taxpayer's age and filing history, and write the answers in the file. Because the quoted rule turns on whether someone has filed before, check your prior-year records rather than relying on memory.

The quote covers only the two groups it names. It does not say what applies to a taxpayer outside those groups, so do not read it as a general ban on taxpayers under 16 using a PIN. For any other case, check the current instructions before you decide how the return will be signed.

Treat the under-16 check as a yes-or-no question for each taxpayer on the return, not for the household as a whole. The quoted rule names primary and secondary taxpayers separately, so write down which role each person holds and what their filing history is. A note that says "under 16, yes" for the whole return is not enough.

If a taxpayer's filing history differs from what you expected, do not assume the earlier answer still holds. Check the history for this return, and note the date you checked.

4. Check that each TIN belongs to the person it is attached to

Check each TIN against its owner: according to Tax1099, the right TIN depends on who the taxpayer is and how the business is treated for federal tax purposes. That page is about the recipient TIN on a 1099, so use it as a reason to check whose number each one is, not as a rule for every number on a return.

Write down whose number each entry is, then compare it with the client's records. Look especially at any case where a name and a number do not appear to belong together. Stop and resolve that question before the return is signed, and do not change a number to match another document until you have confirmed with the client which one is right.

Check how the number is used on the return. A number that belongs to one person should not appear as though it belongs to another, even if the two people are related. If you cannot tell from the records who a number belongs to, mark the item as unresolved and treat it the same way as any other open figure.

Look for the simple errors as well. Read each number digit by digit against the source, and check that each name is spelled the same way on the records and on the return. Small differences are easy to miss late in a review, so read each number slowly, one digit at a time.

Note in the file which facts you used to decide which number is right, so a later reviewer can see why. If the facts for a client are unclear, raise that with the partner before sign-off.

5. Check the work's timing against the filing deadline

Generally, April 15 is the deadline for most people to file their individual income tax returns and pay any tax owed, according to the IRS. That is a general statement, so use it as the starting point for the timing check rather than as a rule that covers every client.

Timing itemWhat the post says
General deadlineGenerally April 15 for most people to file individual returns and pay any tax owed
Count back to planned signing date Leave time for client review, questions, and signing
Shared list of planned datesSigning dates and filing dates for the team
Flag if not ready Flag at the time you find out, not on the day of filing
Actual signing dateNote shows the actual date if client signs earlier or later than planned

Count back from that date, or from whatever deadline applies to the client, to the planned signing date. Leave time for the client to review the final version, to ask questions, and to sign. If the work will not be finished in time, raise it with the partner and record what the client has been told. The aim is to avoid a rushed signature on a version nobody has checked.

Also make sure the client knows the same IRS statement covers paying any tax owed, not only filing the return.

Keep one shared list of planned signing dates and filing dates for the team. Flag any return that is not ready by its planned date at the time you find out, not on the day of filing, so the partner can decide the next step while there is still time to act.

Be specific about what is still open. A note that says "waiting on client" is less useful than one that names the document, the date it was requested, and who is following up. When the planned signing date moves, update the note and tell the partner the same day.

Pay attention to the day the signing takes place, not just the day it is planned. If a client signs earlier or later than planned, the note should show the actual date, so the file matches what happened.

6. Compare every figure with the client's source records

Before sign-off, compare each figure on the return with the source records the client provided. This check comes from general practice, not from a quoted rule, so the standard is simply that every number should trace back to a document.

Work from the documents, not from memory of what the client said in a meeting. Mark each figure as matched, changed or unresolved. Do not sign off while any item is still unresolved, and send any change back to the client before signature so they approve the final numbers.

Start with the figures that look largest or least routine, since they deserve a second look first. Then work through the rest in order so no line is skipped.

Trace a few figures all the way back, not just to the summary. Pick one or two items and follow them from the client's record, through the working papers, to the return. If the trail breaks anywhere, the figure is not ready for signature.

Finally, check the totals on the return against the detail behind them. A total that does not add up from its parts is easy to miss in a long review, so add the parts yourself.

Finish with a short review note: who checked what, which items were resolved, and who signed off. A note like this helps the next reviewer, and it gives the partner a clear record if a question comes up after filing.

Run the 6 checks in order, and keep the note with the file. If one check fails, the return is not ready for signature, whatever the state of the other 5.

Sources