The gap comes from a 0.5% floor on deductions and a rate drop from 37% to 35%.
- 2025 benefit: $37,000 (37% rate, full $100,000 deduction)
- 2026 benefit: $33,250 (35% rate, deduction reduced by the floor)
- The floor scales with AGI; the rate shift applies to the remaining deduction
- A qualified charitable distribution offers a different route for clients with IRAs
- Timing the gift into 2025 preserves the higher benefit
What the two figures are
The two benefit figures you compare are $37,000 and $33,250. Those are the federal tax benefits on a $100,000 charitable gift in the same scenario across 2025 and 2026, and the gap between them is the whole reason this year-end conversation matters.
The example comes from a Journal of Accountancy piece on how OBBBA alters charitable deduction strategies for 2025 and 2026. A taxpayer with AGI of $1 million and $100,000 of charitable contributions in the 37% marginal tax bracket would have a $37,000 federal tax benefit in 2025. In 2026, that same taxpayer gets a benefit of $33,250. The reason is a floor on deductions and a shift in the rate applied.
You already know the mechanics: the deduction is worth more when it comes off income at a higher rate. What changed is that a slice of the base no longer gets deducted, and the rate the remaining deduction works against moves down. Both changes bite for clients sitting at the top.
Your job before the year closes is to walk a client through those two numbers honestly, then decide whether to push the gift into 2025 or let it land in 2026. There is also a third route — giving in a way that does not rely on a deduction at all — which we will discuss.
The 2025 bracket that frames the example
The 2025 example sits in the 37% bracket. The bracket itself starts at taxable income of $626,351 for single filers and $751,601 for joint filers, as stated in the Journal of Accountancy piece ( Journal of Accountancy). A client whose taxable income clears those thresholds is the one this comparison is written for.
Note that taxable income and AGI are different measures. The $1 million figure in the example is AGI. The bracket thresholds above are taxable income. Both matter when you model the gift, and your client's return shows you each one.
Why the 2026 benefit lands lower
The 2026 benefit is lower because of a floor on the deduction and a lower rate. Under the example, $1 million of AGI is subject to a 0.5% nondeductible floor, so the maximum charitable deduction is $95,000, and the deduction is calculated at the 35% tax rate. That produces the $33,250 figure.
Two changes are stacked. First, the floor removes part of the gift from the deduction base. Second, the rate applied to what remains drops from the 2025 rate in the example. Neither change alone would produce the full gap; together they do.
The Journal of Accountancy piece puts the broader effect plainly: taxpayers in the top tax bracket may have a decrease in deductions for charitable contributions beginning in 2026. That is a may, not a certainty — the actual result depends on each client's facts.
For a client weighing when to give, the direction of travel is clear. The same dollars, the same charity, the same year-end timing — the benefit simply does not stretch as far once 2026 arrives.
If the client has flexibility on timing, 2025 is the year where the arithmetic favors them. If the gift was always going to happen in 2026 regardless, the lower benefit is a reason to size the gift with eyes open, not a reason to skip it.
What a qualified charitable distribution does differently
A qualified charitable distribution, or QCD, takes a different path through the return than a deduction. The Fidelity Charitable material describes the effect of a QCD rather than the mechanics of the transfer itself. The Fidelity Charitable page on qualified charitable distributions explains the appeal: donors may avoid being pushed into higher income tax brackets and prevent phaseouts of other tax deductions, though there are some other limitations.
That is a different benefit mechanism. The deduction route reduces the taxable income that is taxed at the client's marginal rate. The QCD route keeps the distribution out of income in the first place, which can matter for clients whose income already sits high enough to trigger phaseouts.
For a top-bracket client, the comparison is not whether one is always better. It is which lever fits the client's situation: income already at the top and heading higher, or income that can be managed down with a well-timed deduction.
The table below lines up the two benefit figures from the example with the rate and floor behind each, so you can see the arithmetic before you walk a client through it.
| Scenario | Federal tax benefit | Rate applied | Deduction after floor |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025, $100,000 gift, $1M AGI | $37,000 | 37% | $100,000 |
| 2026, $100,000 gift, $1M AGI | $33,250 | 35% | $95,000 |
The difference between the two benefits matters when you compare years side by side for the same gift. For a client considering a larger gift, or several gifts across years, that difference compounds.
Where the floor bites hardest
The 0.5% floor scales with AGI, so it grows as the client's income grows. At $1 million of AGI the floor removes part of the deduction base, leaving $95,000 of a $100,000 gift deductible in the 2026 example. A client with higher AGI sees a larger dollar amount removed by the same percentage.
This is worth saying out loud to a client who plans to give a fixed dollar amount. The gift size does not change. What changes is how much of it reaches the deduction line.
The floor also means a gift sized to match a prior year's benefit will not land the same way in 2026. If the client wants the same after-tax cost for the same charity, the gross gift may need to be larger.
The rate shift on its own
Separate from the floor, the rate the deduction works against moves from the 37% bracket figure in the 2025 example to 35% in the 2026 calculation. That shift alone accounts for a meaningful share of the benefit difference.
A client who expects to be in a higher bracket in a future year may prefer to give then, since the deduction is worth more at that rate. The deduction is worth what the client's rate makes it worth in that year.
Bracket position is a question that depends on each client. The thresholds for 2025 tell you where the top bracket begins; they do not tell you where a specific client will land in a later year.
Running the numbers for your client
Start with AGI, because the floor keys off it. Then find the client's marginal rate, because that sets what the deduction is worth. Then apply the floor, because that determines how much of the gift actually reaches the deduction line.
For the 2025 example, the arithmetic is direct. A $100,000 gift in the 37% bracket produces a $37,000 federal tax benefit. No floor applies in that year's calculation.
For 2026, the floor comes first. At $1 million of AGI, the example shows the maximum deduction becomes $95,000 after the floor. Apply the 35% rate and the benefit is $33,250.
The difference between the two benefits is the number your client feels when they compare years side by side. In this example it is the difference between $37,000 of benefit and $33,250 of benefit on the same gift.
If the client wants to give more than $100,000, run the same steps at the larger amount. The floor and the rate apply the same way; only the inputs change.
Timing is the lever with the most immediate effect. A gift completed in 2025 gets the 2025 treatment. A gift that slips into 2026 gets the 2026 treatment. The calendar does most of the work.
Cash gifts are the simplest to model because the amount is the amount. Noncash gifts introduce valuation questions that sit outside this comparison, so keep the year-end conversation on cash when the goal is a clean before-and-after.
The IRS Publication 526 (2025) on charitable contributions covers how cash contributions are treated, using a simple example of a $1,000 cash contribution to a qualified organization ( IRS Publication 526 (2025)). That publication is the reference for the mechanics of what qualifies and how it is reported.
Checking the bracket before you commit
Before you model the gift, confirm the client's taxable income against the 2025 thresholds. The 37% bracket starts at $626,351 for single filers and $751,601 for joint filers.
A client just above a threshold may fall below it after the deduction. That changes the marginal rate applied and the benefit you are modeling.
A client well above the threshold has room to give without dropping out of the top bracket. The benefit is calculated at the top rate for the portion that stays in it.
Filing status matters for the thresholds. Single and joint filers face different starting points, and the same gift produces different benefits depending on where the client sits.
Modeling a gift larger than $100,000
Scale the example proportionally for the rate, and apply the floor at the client's actual AGI. The rate and the floor formula do not change with gift size; only the inputs do.
In 2026, the floor grows with AGI but not with gift size. A larger gift does not trigger a larger floor; the floor is a function of income.
This is where the comparison gets client-specific. Two clients with the same AGI and the same bracket face the same floor. Two clients with different AGI face different floors even at the same gift size.
Cash and noncash gifts in the year-end window
Cash gifts are clean to time.
Noncash gifts carry valuation work that can compress badly in the final weeks of the year. If the client is considering one, start the process well before the deadline.
The benefit comparison in this post is built on a cash gift. The benefit comparison in this post is built on a cash gift; confirm how the rate and floor mechanics apply to noncash gifts against the current IRS rules.
IRS Publication 526 (2025) illustrates how certain payments are treated when the client pays for something of value at a charity event. At a fundraising auction conducted by a charity, you pay $600 for a week's stay at a beach house; separately, you pay $40 to see a special showing of a movie for the benefit of a qualified organization ( IRS Publication 526 (2025)). Those examples show that charitable payments come in forms beyond a simple transfer of cash, and each form follows its own set of rules.
Comparing a deduction against a qualified charitable distribution
The deduction reduces taxable income at the client's rate, less any floor. The QCD moves money out of an IRA and out of income, which affects the return through a different line.
For a client already in the top bracket, the deduction benefit is bounded by the rate and the floor. The QCD benefit is bounded by the rules that govern which distributions qualify and how much can be routed this way.
The Fidelity Charitable material notes that donors may avoid being pushed into higher income tax brackets and prevent phaseouts of other tax deductions through a QCD, though there are some other limitations ( Fidelity Charitable). The phrase "some other limitations" is the part your client needs spelled out against their own facts.
A client whose charitable giving already exceeds what a QCD could cover still has room for a deduction-based gift.
The two routes can coexist in one year. Part of the client's giving can go through a QCD and part through a deductible gift, each producing its own effect on the return.
Timing rules for QCDs are their own set, separate from the year-end deduction question. Confirm the current requirements for the client's situation before treating a QCD as settled.
When the deduction route wins
The deduction route wins when the client has taxable income to absorb the gift and sits in a bracket where the rate makes the deduction valuable. The 2025 example shows that mechanics at the top of the range.
It also wins when the client's giving exceeds what a QCD could handle. The deduction scales with the gift; it is not capped by an account type.
Year-end timing favors the deduction route because the contribution date is straightforward to control. Contribution dating rules for wires and checks should be confirmed for the client's situation.
For a client who itemizes, the deduction reaches the return directly.
When the QCD route wins
The QCD route wins when the client has an IRA, wants to keep distributions out of income, and is concerned about phaseouts. The mechanism described by Fidelity Charitable points at exactly that situation.
It also wins when the client's income is already high enough that an additional deduction has limited room to help. Taking the distribution out of income addresses a different problem than reducing it.
A client weighing both routes should look at the full return, not just the charitable line. The two routes touch income differently, and the net effect depends on everything else on the page.
What to cover in the year-end conversation
Lead with the two benefit figures and the reason they differ. The client does not need the statute; they need to see $37,000 next to $33,250 and understand the floor and rate behind each.
Then confirm the timing. A gift in 2025 gets one treatment; a gift in 2026 gets the other. The calendar decision usually comes before the amount decision.
Walk through AGI and bracket together. The floor keys off AGI; the rate keys off taxable income. Both numbers are on the return, and both drive the benefit.
If a QCD is on the table, compare it against the deduction route on the same page. The two mechanisms produce different effects, and the right answer depends on the client's account types and income profile.
Size the gift against the benefit the client actually wants. A fixed gift produces a smaller benefit in 2026 than in 2025 under the example. A fixed benefit requires a larger gift in 2026.
Confirm what the charity can receive and by when. The deduction cares about the contribution date; the charity's processing capacity is a practical constraint in the final days of December.
Put the agreed amount, timing, and route in writing before the year closes. A gift decided verbally on December 29 has nowhere to go if a detail falls through.
Your client's tax adviser can run the floor and rate against the actual figures on the return, which is the step that turns an example into a decision.
Questions worth asking before December 31
Where does the client sit against the 2025 bracket thresholds? Taxable income of $626,351 for single filers and $751,601 for joint filers marks the start of the 37% bracket. The answer sets the rate in the model.
What is the client's AGI for the year? The 0.5% floor in the 2026 example keys off AGI, so this number determines how much of the gift reaches the deduction line.
Is the gift happening in 2025 or 2026? The same $100,000 produces $37,000 of benefit in the 2025 example and $33,250 in the 2026 example. The timing decision drives the rest.
Does the client have an IRA that could fund a QCD? If yes, compare that route against the deduction. The benefit mechanisms differ, and the right choice depends on the client's income and phaseout exposure.
Has the charity confirmed it can receive the gift before year end? The deduction follows the contribution date. A last-minute delay moves the entire gift into the next year's treatment.
What amount does the client want to net after tax? Working backward from a target benefit produces the gross gift. The floor and the rate both feed that calculation.
Who is confirming the figures against the client's actual return? The example here uses $1 million of AGI and the 37% bracket. The client's real numbers may differ, and the benefit will differ with them.
Closing the gift before the year ends
The two figures are $37,000 and $33,250 on the same $100,000 gift, driven by a floor and a rate shift that both begin to apply in 2026.
For a top-bracket client with flexibility, 2025 carries the more favorable arithmetic in the example. For a client whose gift lands in 2026 regardless, size it with the floor and the lower rate in view.
A QCD offers a different mechanism for clients with IRAs and phaseout concerns. Compare it against the deduction route on the same page before committing.
The work between now and December 31 is confirmation: bracket, AGI, timing, route, amount, and the charity's ability to receive. Each one is a short conversation, and each one changes the number your client sees.
The Journal of Accountancy piece on OBBBA and charitable deduction strategies carries the example figures used throughout this post ( Journal of Accountancy). The Fidelity Charitable page on qualified charitable distributions carries the QCD description ( Fidelity Charitable). Both are worth reading in full before you sit down with a client.