A reasonable new client fee should fit the work involved and have a written basis explaining the scope, amount, and change triggers.
Key takeaways
- Compare the proposed fee with the scope, expected effort, and similar work.
- Write the scope, fee basis, and change triggers before quoting.
- Ask a colleague to explain the fee from the proposal alone.
- Review the written agreement before discussing a disputed bill.
If you set a fee in a hurry, or copy the price from a different job, you may end up defending it on a call you did not plan for. This post gives partners and operations leads two tests to run before the quote goes out, and again when the fee is questioned.
Neither test produces a single correct price. Both are ways of shaping a fee into a form you can explain to someone outside your firm. The first asks whether a neutral observer would see the fee as fair for the work. The second asks whether you can show, in writing, what the fee is based on.
The examples below come from lawyers' professional conduct rules, not from accounting standards. Treat them as a model for thinking, not as rules that bind your firm. Your own professional body's guidance and your engagement terms decide what applies to you.
Why "reasonable" needs a test
A client may say the bill is more than they expected. A fee can be fair in the abstract and still feel wrong to a client who was never told how the work would be scoped, how long it would take, or what could change the price.
"Reasonable" is hard to pin down because there is no single right price for a given service. Two firms can reasonably charge different amounts for the same bookkeeping cleanup, depending on experience, software, the condition of the client's records, and how much risk they take on. The useful question is not "what is the right number?" It is "can I justify this number from the facts I have?"
Utah's rule prohibits a lawyer from charging an unreasonable fee or an unreasonable amount for expenses. ( Utah Courts, SCRP Rule 3-1.05)
South Carolina's version of the rule says: "The factors specified in (1) through (8) are not exclusive." ( South Carolina Judicial Branch, Rule 1.5) The same page explains that the South Carolina version "differs from the Model Rule by making the test in paragraph (a)(2) objective rather than subjective." That distinction applies specifically to paragraph (a)(2).
Test one: would a neutral observer call the fee fair?
Use a neutral observer as a practical review of your quote. Set aside how the fee feels to you, to the partner who wants the work, and to the client who is eager to start. Imagine someone with no stake in the deal reading three things: the scope, the fee, and the effort you expect to spend. Would they call the fee fair?
This is a practical exercise, not a statement of the lawyer rule's overall legal test. It asks about the work and the going rate for similar work, not about your comfort. You can run it in three steps.
First, describe the work in plain terms. Write down what you will actually do: the records to collect, the transactions to review, the returns or reports to prepare, the meetings to attend, and the questions you expect to answer. A vague scope makes almost any fee look unreasonable to a later reader, because they cannot tell what was bought. Use the client intake checklist to organize that handoff.
Second, estimate the effort honestly. Utah's rule lists, among its items, that a lawyer "states the approximate time necessary to complete the task." ( Utah Courts, SCRP Rule 3-1.05) The same idea carries over to any firm. Whether you charge by the hour or by the job, a fee should have a rough basis in time or in the value of the result, and you should know which basis you are using. If you cannot say roughly how many hours the work will take, you are not ready to quote a fixed price.
Third, compare the number with the range a neutral person would expect. You do not need published market data to do this. Ask a senior colleague who has handled similar files. Look at what your firm charged for comparable work in the last year or two, and adjust for anything that has changed. The goal is not precision. The goal is to notice when your number sits far outside the range a reasonable observer would expect.
The neutral observer test has limits. It cannot settle a fee where the difficulty is hidden. A client whose records are in poor shape may cost you twice the hours you planned, and a neutral reader would not know that from the scope alone. Test one tells you whether a price is defensible on the facts you know. It does not protect you from facts you did not check. That is the job of the second test.
Run test one again whenever the facts change. A fee that passed on one day can fail a week later if the client adds entities or the bank statements arrive a year late.
Illustrative example: check the effort before quoting
Suppose a bookkeeping cleanup is estimated at 10 hours. Checking the records reveals another 5 hours of sorting, bringing the estimate to 15 hours. A fee copied from an easier cleanup now needs another look. Compare the revised effort with similar work before quoting. Write down whether sorting is included and what would change the fee if more difficult records arrive. The hours are illustrative; they show how checking the records can change the basis of a quote.
Test two: can you show the basis in writing?
The question is simple. Can you point to a document that says what the fee covers, what it is based on, and what would change it?
Write the answer before the quote goes out. Put three things into the engagement letter or proposal. The first is the scope, in the plain terms you wrote for test one. The second is the basis for the fee: a fixed amount, an hourly rate with a stated estimate, or a monthly retainer for a defined set of services. The third is the set of triggers that would move the fee. A trigger is a specific event that changes the work or the time, such as a late change in the client's ownership structure, a request for services outside the scope, or records that arrive in worse condition than described. Review the engagement letter terms alongside the proposal.
Here is a quick check. Give the proposal to a colleague who has not worked on the file and ask them to explain the fee to the client in two sentences. If they can do it from the document alone, the basis is written down clearly. If they have to ask you questions, the document is missing something. Fix the document, not the colleague's memory.
Writing the basis also protects the firm internally. Partners who did not sell the work can see why it was priced as it was, and operations leads can track whether the actual effort matches the basis. When the two diverge, the written record tells you early, while there is still time to talk to the client.
Operations leads are often best placed to own the basis. They see the hours as they are logged, they know which clients have historically sent messy records, and they are the first to notice when a trigger has been hit. Give them a clear role: confirm that the scope in the proposal matches the team's actual plan, and flag any trigger in the first week of work rather than at billing time.
Comparing the main fee options
Both tests apply to any pricing structure, but each structure passes them in a different way. Every entry in the table is illustrative guidance for comparing the options.
| Fee option (illustrative) | How the amount is set (illustrative) | Passes test one when (illustrative) | Passes test two when (illustrative) | Main risk (illustrative) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed fee | One agreed amount for a defined scope | The scope is narrow and the effort is well understood | The scope and the change triggers are written out | Scope creep leaves the firm absorbing extra time |
| Hourly with a written estimate | Rate times estimated hours, billed as work is done | The estimate matches comparable past work | The estimate and the rate are stated, with a process for revising the estimate | The client sees the total grow and questions every hour |
| Hourly with a cap | Rate times hours, with a stated ceiling | The cap sits within the range a neutral reader would expect | The cap and what happens above it are written down | Work stops at the cap, or the firm absorbs the excess |
| Monthly retainer | Flat monthly amount for a defined set of services | The services are listed and the monthly amount matches the expected load | The service list and the review points are written out | Heavy months and quiet months can make the fee feel unfair in either direction |
| Value-based fee | Amount tied to the result or benefit to the client | The result is measurable and the link to the fee is explained | The measure of value and how it is judged are agreed in writing | Hard to explain to a neutral reader, and the result may not be in the firm's control |
A fixed fee is the simplest to explain, but it is the most exposed to hidden difficulty. Every surprise comes out of your margin. Hourly billing with a written estimate is the most transparent, but it invites a line-by-line argument about each entry. An hourly cap moves risk back to the firm above the ceiling, so set the cap as a real number you can live with, not as a hope.
A monthly retainer suits steady, recurring work. For a one-off engagement it can hide the true cost, because the client never sees the hours behind the flat amount. A value-based fee can be fair, but it is the hardest to run through test one, since the value may be difficult to measure and the client may disagree about what counts.
Many firms combine options, for example a fixed fee for setup followed by a retainer for upkeep. Combining makes both tests harder to pass, because each part needs its own basis and its own triggers. If you combine, write the two parts separately so a neutral reader can see where one ends and the other begins.
Consider who carries the risk of being wrong. With a fixed fee the firm carries most of it. With hourly billing the client carries more of it, which can be fair when the work is hard to scope but will feel uncomfortable if the estimate was careless. None of these choices is wrong by itself. What matters is that the firm chose on purpose and wrote the choice down.
Defending a fee after it is questioned
When a client challenges a fee, the first move is to stop arguing about the number and go back to the document. Pull the scope, the basis, and the triggers. Then compare what was done with what was agreed. A fee dispute often turns on a simple question: was the work in the original scope, or was it added later?
Before any call, write a one-page summary: the agreed scope, the basis, the triggers that applied, the hours by category, and the amount you are asking for. Keep it factual. Leave out internal frustration with the client, and do not promise a result the firm has not agreed internally.
A workable sequence looks like this:
- Confirm what was agreed. Read the engagement letter as written, not as you remember it. Memory tends to favor whoever is speaking.
- Separate the work. Divide the time into work that was in scope, work added on request, and work prompted by a named trigger. Each category supports a different answer.
- Explain the difference in plain terms. Show the client which records changed, how long the extra work took, and which trigger applied. Point to what happened in this file rather than to general experience.
- Decide before the meeting what you will adjust. A small, deliberate concession can end a dispute that a firm argument would prolong. A concession made under pressure, without knowing the facts, becomes the expectation for the next client.
- Record the outcome. Note what was discussed, what was agreed, and whether the scope needs changing for the next period.
Keep the tone steady. The client is usually worried about money, not about your firm's process. A calm walk through the document often does more than a defense of the total.
If a dispute turns formal, involves a complaint to a professional body, or raises possible legal exposure, bring in your professional adviser or counsel early. This post covers the everyday test of reasonableness. It does not cover how a formal complaint is handled, and the process differs by jurisdiction and by professional body.
Putting the two tests to work
A simple workflow keeps the tests in the routine rather than in a special review:
- Before the quote, write the plain scope and the rough effort. Run test one with a colleague who has done similar work.
- Choose the fee option from the table that fits how predictable the work is.
- Put the scope, the basis, and the triggers into the proposal. Run test two with someone who did not write it, and fix any gap they find.
- At each milestone, or when a trigger appears, compare the actual effort with the stated basis. Tell the client early if the two have drifted apart.
- If the fee is questioned, go back to the document before the call, not after.
Neither test removes judgment. They make judgment visible. A partner who can show the reasoning, the rough range, and the triggers is in a much better position than one who relies on confidence alone. When a fee feels uncertain, ask what you would say to a neutral reader who has only the proposal in front of them. A clear answer helps you explain the fee, but does not by itself establish reasonableness. If the answer is vague, change the fee or the document before the client sees it.
Today, take one unsent proposal and ask a colleague to explain its scope, fee basis, and change triggers without your help. Revise any gap before sending it.
Related guides: Accountable plan tests: 3 rules before a reimbursement · ACH invoice fees: 4 facts to check before a client pays.
Questions about reasonable fees
Do these lawyer rules bind an accounting firm?
These examples are a thinking model for accounting firms, not rules that bind them. Check your own professional body's guidance and engagement terms.
Can a fixed fee change when the work changes?
A fixed fee needs written change triggers explaining what would move it. Compare the new work with the agreed scope before discussing a revised amount.
What should I review when a client questions a fee?
Review the agreed scope, fee basis, change triggers, and work performed. Use that comparison to prepare the discussion before the call.