Intake is where a small firm decides whether it can take a matter at all. Most new inquiries clear quickly. The prospective client has no history with the firm, or the history has nothing to do with the work being offered. Sometimes the search turns up a name the firm has seen before. That is when a former client becomes the question.
A name match alone does not answer it. The state's rule on duties to former clients asks what the firm did for the earlier client, what the new client wants, and how the two relate. This post walks through how that rule works, then looks at three examples from the rule's own commentary. It is written for partners and operations leads who screen new work. It is general education, not legal advice. A lawyer licensed where your firm practices should decide any close case.
Chief takeaways
- Run four intake questions in order: prior representation, same or substantially related matter, material adversity, informed consent.
- Compare facts, not file labels, when deciding whether two files are one matter.
- Check each of the three commentary examples: a drafted contract, a prosecutor turned civil counsel, co-clients who split.
- Record every affected person by name, and name the partner who owns the decision.
The examples here come from Pennsylvania's text, so the post stays with that state's rule. Other states have their own versions. A firm that practices elsewhere should read its own rules before relying on any of this.
The basic bar
The rule starts from a simple idea: a lawyer's duties do not end when the work does. After a client-lawyer relationship ends, a lawyer "has certain continuing duties with respect to confidentiality and conflicts of interest and thus may not represent another client except in conformity with this Rule" ( state rule text).
| Intake question | What it asks | Type of answer |
|---|---|---|
| Prior representation | Did the firm previously represent this person in a matter? | Factual |
| Same matter | Is the new work the same matter, or a substantially related one? | Factual |
| Material adversity | Are the new client's interests materially adverse to the former client's? | Factual |
| Informed consent | Has the former client given informed consent? | Specific thing obtained |
| Note quality | Does the note say how the interests conflict, not just that they do? | Intake record check |
The prohibition itself sits in paragraph (a). A lawyer who has formerly represented a client in a matter "shall not thereafter represent another person in the same or a substantially related matter in which that person's interests are materially adverse to the interests of the former client unless the former client gives informed consent."
That sentence has four parts an intake reviewer can check one at a time:
- Did the firm previously represent this person in a matter?
- Is the new work the same matter, or a substantially related one?
- Are the new client's interests materially adverse to the former client's?
- Has the former client given informed consent?
The first three questions are factual. The fourth asks whether a specific thing has been obtained. If the first three come back yes and the fourth is still open, the text says the lawyer should not take the engagement on those terms.
The order matters. The consent question only arises once the earlier questions are answered yes. If the firm never represented the person in a matter, the sentence has no work to do, and the reviewer can move on. The same is true if the earlier work exists but the new matter is unrelated and nothing about it is adverse. Asking the questions in order keeps the file short and saves the consent discussion for the cases that need it.
A practical way to run them is to write each question as a sentence the reviewer must complete. "The firm represented this person in a matter called ." "The new matter is the same as, or substantially related to, that matter because." "The new client's interests are adverse to this person's because ___." Blanks that stay empty show the reviewer where more facts are needed.
The rule uses the word "materially," so intake notes should say how the interests conflict, not just that they do. A note that reads "possible conflict" gives the partner nothing to decide with. A note that says what the new client wants to do to the former client, and what the firm did for the former client, gives the partner the facts the rule asks about.
Those questions belong to the full rule and to the lawyers who advise your firm. Intake should flag the consent question early, before anyone at the firm starts work for the prospective client.
What counts as the same matter
The second point in the commentary is about scope. It says that the scope of a "matter" for purposes of this rule "depends on the facts of a particular situation or transaction." Intake therefore cannot be a comparison of labels.
| Point in the commentary | What the text says | Intake implication |
|---|---|---|
| Scope of a matter | The scope "depends on the facts of a particular situation or transaction" | Compare facts, not file labels |
| Lawyers ending association | The question "is more complicated" | Case-by-case review needed |
| Application of paragraph (b) | Depends on "particular facts, aided by inferences, deductions or working presumptions" | Judgment rather than a fixed answer |
| Hire from government | Imputation "is governed by Rule 1.11(b) and (c), not this Rule" | Check the other rule first |
Two files with different titles can still describe one transaction. Two files with the same title can describe separate ones. A lease signed in one year and a later fight over the same building might look like different matters on a client list, while the underlying facts overlap almost entirely. The reverse can also be true. The rule asks about facts, so intake notes should record what the old work was, not only who the client was.
Consider two firm files. In the second, the firm advised the same company on an unrelated licensing question. The client name is the same in both. The first file may be close to the new work, because the disputed term sits in a document the firm helped prepare. The second may not be, because the subject matter does not overlap. Intake cannot tell these apart from the client list alone. It needs the file, or at least a clear summary of what was done in it.
Where the facts are close but not clear, the reviewer should write down the open question rather than guess. The scope point is a reason to look harder at the facts, not a reason to assume the answer in either direction.
The commentary also addresses lawyers who move between firms. Its fourth paragraph says that when lawyers "have been associated with a firm but then end their association, the question of whether a lawyer should undertake representation is more complicated." Its sixth paragraph adds that applying the rule "depends on a situation's particular facts, aided by inferences, deductions or working presumptions that reasonably may be made about the way in which lawyers work together."
A related point comes from the companion imputation rule, which covers lawyers who arrive from public service. It reads: "(7) Where a lawyer has joined a private firm after having represented the government, imputation is governed by Rule 1.11(b) and (c), not this Rule" ( imputation rule text). For intake, the practical point is that this post's rule may not control a hire who came from a government post. The reviewer should look to the other rule before clearing that hire.
For a small firm, the practical reading is that the search should not stop at the firm's own client list. If a lawyer who recently joined worked on a matter at a former firm, the intake reviewer should ask about that history as well. A yes answer there calls for case-by-case review under the scope point above and the commentary's paragraph on lawyers who end an association. The firm should decide in advance who makes that call and how the answer is recorded.
Example one: a contract the firm drafted
The first example concerns rescission. The text reads: "Under this Rule, for example, a lawyer could not properly seek to rescind on behalf of a new client a contract drafted on behalf of the former client."
Picture a small firm that drafted a supply agreement for a manufacturer a few years ago. Later, a distributor bound by that agreement asks the firm to help it get out of the contract. The new client wants to undo a document the firm itself prepared for someone who is now a former client.
The example does not require that the firm ever litigated anything. It turns on the contract the firm drafted, and on whether the new client wants that contract rescinded. Drafting work can feel less serious than a court case, and staff searching a file may treat it that way. The example points the other direction. What the work was, and what the new client wants done with it, matter more than the label.
Intake questions for this scenario:
- Pull the former client file and find the contract by its title, date, and parties.
- Ask the prospective client what they want to happen to that contract. Ending it, changing it, or challenging it are different answers, and each should be recorded.
- If the request is to rescind the contract the firm drafted, the example describes exactly that situation, and the firm should not take the work on the new client's behalf.
Note the last point. The example does not say every contract question involving a former client is barred. It addresses a rescission request aimed at the contract the firm drafted for that client. Intake should describe the request in the new client's own terms before deciding how close the match is.
Comparing the options
The table below turns the situations in this post into rows so a reviewer can compare them side by side. Read across each row: the first column is the situation at intake, the second is what the text says, and the third is the outcome the text supports.
| Intake situation | What the text says | Outcome the text supports |
|---|---|---|
| Same or substantially related matter, with interests materially adverse to a former client | A lawyer "shall not thereafter represent another person" in that situation unless the former client gives informed consent | Proceed only with the former client's informed consent |
| New client wants to rescind a contract the firm drafted for a former client | The lawyer "could not properly seek to rescind" on the new client's behalf | The example bars the work |
| Lawyer prosecuted an accused person, and the new work is a civil action against the government on the same transaction | The lawyer may not act for the accused in that action | The example bars the work |
| Lawyer represented multiple clients in a matter, and now acts for one against another after a dispute arose in that matter | The lawyer may not act for one against the others "unless all affected clients give informed consent" | Proceed only with consent from every affected client |
| Lawyer comes from another firm where a related matter was handled | The question "is more complicated" | Case-by-case review; the text gives no fixed result |
The table is a reading aid, and it covers only the language discussed in this post, not the whole rule.
Two rows deserve a closer look. Row one is the general rule, and it has a single exit: informed consent from the former client. Row four has the same exit, but the consent must come from every affected client, so more people have to agree. Row five is the only row where the text does not give an answer.
Example two: a prosecutor who becomes defense counsel
The second example involves a lawyer who was on the other side of a criminal case. The commentary says: "So also a lawyer who has prosecuted an accused person could not properly represent the accused in a subsequent civil action against the government concerning the same transaction."
The words "So also" tie this example to the one before it. The logic is the same, but the facts differ. The lawyer's earlier role was directed at the person who is now the client, and the new work is a civil action against the government. The text bars that representation because the action concerns the same transaction. That detail carries the example. A civil claim about a different transaction, even one involving the same people, would need its own analysis.
For a small firm, the lesson is about history on both sides of a matter. A lawyer who worked against a person in an earlier matter can carry that history into a new firm, and the firm may never have opened the earlier file. The intake reviewer needs to ask whether any lawyer who would work on the new matter was involved in the earlier one, and in what role.
Questions to put to the prospective client and to the lawyers at the firm:
- Which side of the earlier matter was the lawyer on, and was the person who now wants representation on the other side?
- Is the new work a claim about the same transaction the earlier matter concerned?
- Has any lawyer who will touch the new matter worked on the earlier one, in any role?
The second question is the center of the example. The text turns on the same transaction. A related but separate claim needs its own review, and the reviewer should write down exactly which transaction each side describes.
Example three: co-clients who fall out
The third example involves several clients in one matter. The commentary says: "Nor could a lawyer who has represented multiple clients in a matter represent one of the clients against the others … after a dispute arose among the clients in that matter, unless all affected clients give informed consent."
Picture a small firm that formed a company for two founders and represented both of them in that work. A few years later they disagree, and one founder calls the firm to pursue the dispute against the other. If the dispute is in the same or a substantially related matter to the formation work, the firm may not act for one founder against the other unless every affected person gives informed consent. Check that the hypothetical dispute meets that condition before applying the sentence.
Two details in the text matter for intake. The first is timing. The sentence applies after a dispute arose among the clients in that matter. It is aimed at what happens once the split has begun. It does not address a joint engagement that is still running, so do not read it as settling that situation.
The second detail is who must agree. The text refers to "all affected clients," not only the person who called. Intake should identify everyone the firm represented in that matter, decide who is affected, and not treat the caller's permission as enough.
There is a reason operations leads should care about this beyond the single call. Co-client matters often sit in the firm's system under one file number, or under the name of the founder who signed the engagement letter. A search by the caller's name may find the matter but not show the other people the firm represented in it. The intake record should list each person by name, not rely on the file's title, so the consent question can be answered for everyone.
Intake steps when a caller describes a split among people the firm once represented together:
- Pause the intake before discussing terms with the caller.
- List every person the firm represented in the matter, and note which of them the dispute involves.
- Identify the informed consent that the rule requires, and who must give it.
- Do not accept the work until the partner has made a decision on that record.
Recording the decision
Operations leads often own the search and the file, so their notes are the record a partner will rely on later. A useful intake record for a former-client question has a few parts. It names the people searched, including affiliated names. It lists each former-client matter found, with a short description of the facts and the lawyers who worked on it. It states how the new request relates to those facts, using the scope point from the commentary. It notes whether any lawyer joining the matter has history from another firm, and whether that history touches the imputation rule. Where a dispute among co-clients is involved, it lists every affected person.
| Record element | What it covers | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| Names searched | People and affiliated names checked | Operations lead |
| Former-client matters found | Short description of facts and lawyers who worked on it | Operations lead |
| Relation to new request | How the new request relates to those facts | Operations lead |
| Lawyer history from another firm | Whether that history touches the imputation rule | Partner |
| Informed consent relied on | Who gave it, when, and on what information | Named partner |
The record should also show who decided. The rule is written as a duty of the lawyer, so the firm should name the partner who owns the decision. If the firm relies on informed consent, the record should show who gave it, when, and on what information.
Access matters too. Former-client files often hold the facts the reviewer needs, and they may also hold confidential information about the former client. A firm should decide in advance which staff can open a closed file for a conflicts check, and what they may record in the intake note. The intake note should describe the facts needed for the decision without copying the confidential content of the old matter into a general system. That point follows from the rule's continuing duty of confidentiality, which the opening sentence of the rule names.
Finally, the record should be kept with the matter it concerns, so that a later reviewer can see the question and the answer together. A conflicts decision that lives only in someone's email is hard to defend and harder to reuse when the same former client returns with a new request.
Summary of the approach
A former-client bar works on facts, not labels. The state's rule asks whether the firm represented the person in a matter, whether the new work is the same or substantially related, whether the interests are materially adverse, and whether informed consent exists. The commentary's examples show how those questions play out for a contract the firm drafted, a prosecutor who switches sides, and co-clients who fall out. In each one, the intake question is the same: what did the firm do before, and what does the new client want to do now?
A short intake checklist, a written record, and a named partner who decides close cases give a small firm a repeatable way to catch these questions before work starts.
Related guides: 3 tests for a former-client conflict before an engagement · 3 duties to screen a new hire with a client conflict · Accounting Client Intake Checklist for a Clear Handoff.